What do you think?
Rate this book
Under the Tulip Tree
Sixteen-year-old Lorena Leland’s dreams of a rich and fulfilling life as a writer are dashed when the stock market crashes in 1929. Seven years into the Great Depression, Rena’s banker father has retreated into the bottle, her sister is married to a lazy charlatan and gambler, and Rena is an unemployed newspaper reporter. Eager for any writing job, Rena accepts a position interviewing former slaves for the Federal Writers’ Project. There, she meets Frankie Washington, a 101-year-old woman whose honest yet tragic past captivates Rena.
As Frankie recounts her life as a slave, Rena is horrified to learn of all the older woman has endured―especially because Rena’s ancestors owned slaves. While Frankie’s story challenges Rena’s preconceptions about slavery, it also connects the two women whose lives are otherwise separated by age, race, and circumstances. But will this bond of respect, admiration, and friendship be broken by a revelation neither woman sees coming?
As Frankie recounts her life as a slave, Rena is horrified to learn of all the older woman has endured―especially because Rena’s ancestors owned slaves. While Frankie’s story challenges Rena’s preconceptions about slavery, it also connects the two women whose lives are otherwise separated by age, race, and circumstances. But will this bond of respect, admiration, and friendship be broken by a revelation neither woman sees coming?
400 pages, Paperback
First published September 8, 2020
2201 people are currently reading
24776 people want to read
About the author
Michelle Shocklee
12 books1,030 followersMichelle Shocklee is the author of several historical novels, including APPALACHIAN SONG, a 2024 Christy Award Finalist; COUNT THE NIGHTS BY STARS, winner of the 2023 Christianity Today Book Award in Fiction; and UNDER THE TULIP TREE, a Christy Award & Selah Award finalist. As a woman of mixed heritage--her father's family is Hispanic and her mother's roots go back to Germany--she has always celebrated diversity and feels it's important to see the world through the eyes of one another. Learning from the past and changing the future is why she writes historical fiction.
With both her sons grown and happily married, Michelle and her husband make their home in Tennessee.
Click the "Influences" link in Michelle's profile to read more about why the theme of forgiveness is important, even in fiction.
With both her sons grown and happily married, Michelle and her husband make their home in Tennessee.
Click the "Influences" link in Michelle's profile to read more about why the theme of forgiveness is important, even in fiction.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,891 reviews
March 14, 2021
This was a Hoopla Audio. The premise is very good. Lorena Leland's family is struggling after the Stock market crash of 1929. Her father loses his job at the bank and 7 years later he's finding comfort in drinking and still unemployed. Lorena needs to help out the family and is offered a job with the Federal Writer's Project within the WPA. It is part of President Roosevelt's plans to rebuild the economy. She must interview former slaves and document their stories. Lorena begins with Frankie Washington who is 101 years old. She begins to form a sort of friendship with her as Frankie tells her story.
This started off wonderful. I was very interested in Frankie's story despite it being very sad and heartbreaking. Lorena's story was a little bit more dull and I must admit that I did not get the feel of the time period (1936) fully.
I did not realize this was a Christian Historical Fiction book when I started it. It's not usually something I read/listen to. I feel perhaps that it was a little too sweet for the subject matter and involved too many cliques. The two stories eventually intertwine and overall it was an okay story to listen to.
This started off wonderful. I was very interested in Frankie's story despite it being very sad and heartbreaking. Lorena's story was a little bit more dull and I must admit that I did not get the feel of the time period (1936) fully.
I did not realize this was a Christian Historical Fiction book when I started it. It's not usually something I read/listen to. I feel perhaps that it was a little too sweet for the subject matter and involved too many cliques. The two stories eventually intertwine and overall it was an okay story to listen to.
October 9, 2020
It is our choice “to be a small pebble on the path to the peaceful existence among people of different races and socioeconomic status.” And that’s what this story explores.
NYC, Tuesday, October 29, 1929 – the stock market has crashed.
Nashville, Tennessee. Eight hours earlier. Lorena ‘Rena’ Leland is celebrating her sixteenth-birthday today. An aspiring writer with a diary in her hand, she dreams of writing for one of the major magazines in NYC after college.
1936. Her family is broke and broken as many others. Many are homeless and starving. The government creates projects to provide jobs to those in most dire situations. The irony of those who govern at the state capitol is that their windows overlook the Hell’s Half Acre, where the poorest have lived for decades.
After seven years, without a degree and with lack of jobs, Rena takes a position as a writer interviewing former slaves to preserve their stories. She is assigned to Mrs. Washington, who lives at the Hell’s Half Acre.
Mrs. Washington is 101 years old. The God will not allow her to leave this world until she talks to Rena. Thus, she agrees to be interviewed as she’d rather leave the past in the past. There is something special about this character. There is so much warmth to her. The way she talks and is comfortable in her own skin. And makes Rena comfortable to ask any question as Rena is not comfortable in her own skin.
I enjoyed both characters very much. Rena knows that her hardship doesn’t compare to Frankie’s (Mrs. Washington) as she comes from privileged family, destitute at present time due to economic crash. She needs some encouragement while dealing with discouraging parents. She has the need to know the details of Frankie’s story. After what Frankie has revealed, how did she continue on with her life? Rena needs to sort out the confusion in her own life.
I also enjoyed Rena’s Grandma’s story very much. (Don’t want to give out too many details).
We’ve read those stories before. But this one gives a new perspective. A story like no other told before. Mrs. Washington revealing her story from a perspective of a child. A child, who doesn’t comprehend the injustice, who must obey the abuse. As an adult, going through a period of anger. Once, she reaches a peace inside her, it radiates from her. Her story is heart-wrenching, but it also gives hope. Despite the horrible injustice, there is so much warmness and beauty in this story.
The way the story flows between two timelines and the warmly developed characters make this story very engrossing. Sometimes I feel exhausted by dual-timeline narrative, but not here. It only makes the pages turn quicker. I relished the prose and the word choice. Beautifully woven story, which is a page-turner.
There is so much wisdom and honesty in this story that I truly hope it sells in record numbers. That’s the kind of book that I hope it reaches masses of people. It’s a perfect timing for such story.
What you take for granted today, tomorrow you might be very grateful for. And it’s not necessarily due to economics; it might be because you talked to another human being and got to know that person.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
NYC, Tuesday, October 29, 1929 – the stock market has crashed.
Nashville, Tennessee. Eight hours earlier. Lorena ‘Rena’ Leland is celebrating her sixteenth-birthday today. An aspiring writer with a diary in her hand, she dreams of writing for one of the major magazines in NYC after college.
1936. Her family is broke and broken as many others. Many are homeless and starving. The government creates projects to provide jobs to those in most dire situations. The irony of those who govern at the state capitol is that their windows overlook the Hell’s Half Acre, where the poorest have lived for decades.
After seven years, without a degree and with lack of jobs, Rena takes a position as a writer interviewing former slaves to preserve their stories. She is assigned to Mrs. Washington, who lives at the Hell’s Half Acre.
Mrs. Washington is 101 years old. The God will not allow her to leave this world until she talks to Rena. Thus, she agrees to be interviewed as she’d rather leave the past in the past. There is something special about this character. There is so much warmth to her. The way she talks and is comfortable in her own skin. And makes Rena comfortable to ask any question as Rena is not comfortable in her own skin.
I enjoyed both characters very much. Rena knows that her hardship doesn’t compare to Frankie’s (Mrs. Washington) as she comes from privileged family, destitute at present time due to economic crash. She needs some encouragement while dealing with discouraging parents. She has the need to know the details of Frankie’s story. After what Frankie has revealed, how did she continue on with her life? Rena needs to sort out the confusion in her own life.
I also enjoyed Rena’s Grandma’s story very much. (Don’t want to give out too many details).
We’ve read those stories before. But this one gives a new perspective. A story like no other told before. Mrs. Washington revealing her story from a perspective of a child. A child, who doesn’t comprehend the injustice, who must obey the abuse. As an adult, going through a period of anger. Once, she reaches a peace inside her, it radiates from her. Her story is heart-wrenching, but it also gives hope. Despite the horrible injustice, there is so much warmness and beauty in this story.
The way the story flows between two timelines and the warmly developed characters make this story very engrossing. Sometimes I feel exhausted by dual-timeline narrative, but not here. It only makes the pages turn quicker. I relished the prose and the word choice. Beautifully woven story, which is a page-turner.
There is so much wisdom and honesty in this story that I truly hope it sells in record numbers. That’s the kind of book that I hope it reaches masses of people. It’s a perfect timing for such story.
What you take for granted today, tomorrow you might be very grateful for. And it’s not necessarily due to economics; it might be because you talked to another human being and got to know that person.
Source: ARC was provided by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
December 21, 2020
I can absolutely say without a doubt this is one of the best books I've read this year.
The author pens a fictionalized story based upon true events/
Under The Tulip Tree takes place when the stock market crashes and along with this crash so does sixteen year old Lorena Leland's dreams of becoming a writer.
Seven years into the Great Depression Rena's father has taken to the bottle and she is an unemployed newspaper reporter.
"In 1935 President Roosevelt established the Federal Writer's Project as part of the Works Progress Administration,a New Deal program that put out-of-work writers,librarians,teachers,and others to work."
Rena jumps at the chance to do this writing narratives of those enslaved prior to the civil war.
One of the people she interviews is an elderly lady named Frankie,enslaved as a young child in Tennessee by the Hall family many years ago.
Hearing Frankie's story as she recalls her life growing up,her devastating injury and the civil war playing out and her true love being seriously injured. This time slip goes back and forth in time between the nineteen thirties and civil war times as Frankie recounts her life and the inequality of how she is treated . Despite the mental and physical abuse she has endured as a slave Frankie has a pure heart and as we are told to do she forgives those who have wronged her. Non forgivers just hold bitterness and have hardened hearts. Frankie is not like this. Frankie was so happy to have a way to tell her life's story , she has a voice that needs to heard and it will not be quieted.
When Rena discovers a connection she has with Frankie she is shocked,ashamed and afraid of how Frankie will react but knows she must tell her what she finds out because it is the right thing to do.
This book is heartbreaking and heart warming at the same time. The inequality of treatment towards people just because of the color of their skin is heartbreaking and it still goes on today.
Under The Tulip is on my list of one of the best books I have ever read!
Pub Date 08 Sep 2020
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
The author pens a fictionalized story based upon true events/
Under The Tulip Tree takes place when the stock market crashes and along with this crash so does sixteen year old Lorena Leland's dreams of becoming a writer.
Seven years into the Great Depression Rena's father has taken to the bottle and she is an unemployed newspaper reporter.
"In 1935 President Roosevelt established the Federal Writer's Project as part of the Works Progress Administration,a New Deal program that put out-of-work writers,librarians,teachers,and others to work."
Rena jumps at the chance to do this writing narratives of those enslaved prior to the civil war.
One of the people she interviews is an elderly lady named Frankie,enslaved as a young child in Tennessee by the Hall family many years ago.
Hearing Frankie's story as she recalls her life growing up,her devastating injury and the civil war playing out and her true love being seriously injured. This time slip goes back and forth in time between the nineteen thirties and civil war times as Frankie recounts her life and the inequality of how she is treated . Despite the mental and physical abuse she has endured as a slave Frankie has a pure heart and as we are told to do she forgives those who have wronged her. Non forgivers just hold bitterness and have hardened hearts. Frankie is not like this. Frankie was so happy to have a way to tell her life's story , she has a voice that needs to heard and it will not be quieted.
When Rena discovers a connection she has with Frankie she is shocked,ashamed and afraid of how Frankie will react but knows she must tell her what she finds out because it is the right thing to do.
This book is heartbreaking and heart warming at the same time. The inequality of treatment towards people just because of the color of their skin is heartbreaking and it still goes on today.
Under The Tulip is on my list of one of the best books I have ever read!
Pub Date 08 Sep 2020
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
February 7, 2021
Sigh.... I just don’t know what to say. I do think this book would appeal to many women, but I am not among them. If one desires to read a story with strong Christian themes and a happy ending, then this is for you. There is nothing wrong with those things and they are not what I objected to. It was something else that bothered me.
There are two stories told herein, that of Rena (Lorena) and her interviewee, Frankie a former slave. The stories take place during the Depression and the Civil War, both in Nashville, TN. The two stories end up intertwined but it seemed obvious to me right from the start that was where the reader is being led. It was not a twist or a surprise at all. Frankie’s story is the more interesting of the two.
Here is my issue with the book: I can’t help but be uncomfortable with a white author writing the story of a slave who forgives those who abused her. Forgiveness is a wonderful thing but in this case it felt preachy and presumptuous to me. I just did not feel like this story is the author’s to tell. In terms of writing, there is nothing challenging here. I completed the book quickly.
There are two stories told herein, that of Rena (Lorena) and her interviewee, Frankie a former slave. The stories take place during the Depression and the Civil War, both in Nashville, TN. The two stories end up intertwined but it seemed obvious to me right from the start that was where the reader is being led. It was not a twist or a surprise at all. Frankie’s story is the more interesting of the two.
Here is my issue with the book: I can’t help but be uncomfortable with a white author writing the story of a slave who forgives those who abused her. Forgiveness is a wonderful thing but in this case it felt preachy and presumptuous to me. I just did not feel like this story is the author’s to tell. In terms of writing, there is nothing challenging here. I completed the book quickly.
May 18, 2025
Lorena Leland’s world was turned upside down on the night of her sixteenth Birthday party, the American stock market crashed, her family lost its fortune and her father’s bank went broke. For Lorena’s mother Margaret and her sister Mary it a big shock, it’s highly embarrassing, they worry about their social status and her father starts drinking a lot. The Leland’s manage to keep the family home, with some help from a relative and everything is sold to pay debts.
Seven years after the stock market crash Rena is an out of work newspaper reporter and she hears about a new program. President Franklin Roosevelt came up with many brilliant ideas during the great depression all funded under The Emergency Relief Appropriation Act we have all heard of the pack-horse librarian scheme and another program of his was the Federal Writer’s Project. They needed writers to interview former slaves; to create a permanent record of what happened to them and to do this they visited the person at home. Rena gets a job interviewing the former slaves; she’s to write down their stories, experiences and has a list of questions to ask them.
On her first day at work she’s picked up by Alden Norwood, a fellow writer and they drive to Hells Half Acre in Nashville. The first person on her interview list is Frankie Washington; she’s a hundred and one years old and was born a slave. Lorena is rather shocked by the poverty and living conditions in Hells Half Acre and her own life is very comfortable compared to theirs.
As Frankie recounts her life as a slave, Rena is horrified to hear what happened to her as a six year old child, she returns every day to write down Frances story and what she hears makes her very upset. Frankie is a real character, she endured many hardships, heartbreaking loss, terrible abuse and this increases Lorena’s awareness of how evil slavery was. Rena and Frankie become friends, Rena looks forward to visiting her house, and they cook and share meals together. If Rena’s mother knew about their close relationship she would be horrified, as time goes on Rena starts to look into her own relatives past and they owned slaves.
Thanks to Edelweiss, Tyndale House Publishers and Michelle Shocklee for my copy of, Under the Tulip Tree its a wonderful book, I loved the relationship formed between Frankie and Lorena, despite what happened to her Frankie faith was strong and her forgiveness towards others was truly remarkable and five stars from me.
Seven years after the stock market crash Rena is an out of work newspaper reporter and she hears about a new program. President Franklin Roosevelt came up with many brilliant ideas during the great depression all funded under The Emergency Relief Appropriation Act we have all heard of the pack-horse librarian scheme and another program of his was the Federal Writer’s Project. They needed writers to interview former slaves; to create a permanent record of what happened to them and to do this they visited the person at home. Rena gets a job interviewing the former slaves; she’s to write down their stories, experiences and has a list of questions to ask them.
On her first day at work she’s picked up by Alden Norwood, a fellow writer and they drive to Hells Half Acre in Nashville. The first person on her interview list is Frankie Washington; she’s a hundred and one years old and was born a slave. Lorena is rather shocked by the poverty and living conditions in Hells Half Acre and her own life is very comfortable compared to theirs.
As Frankie recounts her life as a slave, Rena is horrified to hear what happened to her as a six year old child, she returns every day to write down Frances story and what she hears makes her very upset. Frankie is a real character, she endured many hardships, heartbreaking loss, terrible abuse and this increases Lorena’s awareness of how evil slavery was. Rena and Frankie become friends, Rena looks forward to visiting her house, and they cook and share meals together. If Rena’s mother knew about their close relationship she would be horrified, as time goes on Rena starts to look into her own relatives past and they owned slaves.
Thanks to Edelweiss, Tyndale House Publishers and Michelle Shocklee for my copy of, Under the Tulip Tree its a wonderful book, I loved the relationship formed between Frankie and Lorena, despite what happened to her Frankie faith was strong and her forgiveness towards others was truly remarkable and five stars from me.
November 21, 2020
I really enjoyed this one!
I will start by being clear on the fact that I listened to the audio version of this book. The story is one thing, but I was so impressed with the narrator. She has a talent for this and I was quickly pulled into her voice. It was complete with a southern accent (supporting the novel), inflection, and just a way that sort of hypnotizes you and sucks you in. So much talent!
In terms of the story...a young woman's family loses their income due to the stock market crash and she lands a job with the WPA. Her job is to interview prior slaves. She is introduced to a woman and spends many days interviewing her and learning about the horrors of slavery. Their relationship has an interesting tie at the end, but their budding friendship is heart warming and refreshing.
I will start by being clear on the fact that I listened to the audio version of this book. The story is one thing, but I was so impressed with the narrator. She has a talent for this and I was quickly pulled into her voice. It was complete with a southern accent (supporting the novel), inflection, and just a way that sort of hypnotizes you and sucks you in. So much talent!
In terms of the story...a young woman's family loses their income due to the stock market crash and she lands a job with the WPA. Her job is to interview prior slaves. She is introduced to a woman and spends many days interviewing her and learning about the horrors of slavery. Their relationship has an interesting tie at the end, but their budding friendship is heart warming and refreshing.
December 2, 2020
Waffling between a 2 and 3 rating. I listened via hoopla and definitely wouldn't have finished if it were not an audio book. Maybe this is woke culture getting into my brain but I didn't like the white author telling the story of what it was like to be a slave and then forcing the character to forgive over and over again. I also didn't like that Rena felt the need to fall apart, be ruined emotionally for days, and then apologize and be shocked that she was forgiven for sins her great-great ancestors committed. You should not take on the guilt of other people's sins when you truly had nothing to do with it. It felt like contrived and forced guilt and then took a turn to soothe white people 🤷 meh.
December 8, 2020
Lorena, "Rena", Leland always dreamed of becoming a writer. But when the stock market crashed on her sixteenth birthday her world was drastically altered. Her banker father took to drinking, her sister married the wrong man, and her mother is still trying to maintain her place in Nashville society.
Seven years later, with the Great Depression still impacting their lives, Rena accepts a job with the Federal Writer's Project interviewing former slaves. Her first interview is with Frankie Washington, a 101 year old woman with a compelling and tragic story. Rena feels a close connection to Frankie and wants to do her story justice. Frankie endured unbearable incidents in her years as a slave. As a sheltered white child and adult, Rena had no idea what the true hardships of slavery entailed, both physically and emotionally. She is enlightened by by Frankie's story and vows that her story will make a difference in the future.
Profound, poignant, insightful and an important reminder to not forget the past and strive to make a better future for all people.
4.5 stars
Seven years later, with the Great Depression still impacting their lives, Rena accepts a job with the Federal Writer's Project interviewing former slaves. Her first interview is with Frankie Washington, a 101 year old woman with a compelling and tragic story. Rena feels a close connection to Frankie and wants to do her story justice. Frankie endured unbearable incidents in her years as a slave. As a sheltered white child and adult, Rena had no idea what the true hardships of slavery entailed, both physically and emotionally. She is enlightened by by Frankie's story and vows that her story will make a difference in the future.
Profound, poignant, insightful and an important reminder to not forget the past and strive to make a better future for all people.
4.5 stars
August 17, 2025
3.25-3.5⭐️
I’m glad I found this one while randomly scrolling on KU.
This tells the story of 101 year old Frankie being interviewed in the 1930’s (during the Great Depression) by a young white woman about her experiences as a slave.
While, this wasn’t a story to write home about, I definitely enjoyed it and would recommend to everyone.
It’s a cozy, touching read about a girl’s ignorance about slavery and what it TRULY entailed.
Loved the relationships that formed in this between all the characters.
The plot twist in this didn’t really twist as I believe anyone can see where the story would go within the first few chapters.
Nevertheless, a solid story.
I’m glad I found this one while randomly scrolling on KU.
This tells the story of 101 year old Frankie being interviewed in the 1930’s (during the Great Depression) by a young white woman about her experiences as a slave.
While, this wasn’t a story to write home about, I definitely enjoyed it and would recommend to everyone.
It’s a cozy, touching read about a girl’s ignorance about slavery and what it TRULY entailed.
Loved the relationships that formed in this between all the characters.
The plot twist in this didn’t really twist as I believe anyone can see where the story would go within the first few chapters.
Nevertheless, a solid story.
October 8, 2020
This time I really have no words. Okay, maybe I have a smidgen. But if they come out in a disjointed, discombobulating mess it's the book's fault. Phew. Here goes:
Profound. Compelling. Powerful. Pertinent. Emotionally charged. Rocked-my-word-earth-shattering. :-) I have to pause here and say I listened to the audible edition of this book and Sarah Zimmerman's narration brought this already incredible story to a whole other level. I may have used the word gobsmacked to the point of cliche in my reviews lately, but I can't help it. I am!
I felt this story right through every fiber of my being. It touched me and changed me and testified to me. Frankie and Rena came to life through the power of their stories, convicting me afresh of the importance of remembering our past in all it's imperfect, heartbreaking, hard-to-stomach reality. It's only by seeking truth that we can be set free. I saw that so clearly in both Rena and Frankie's stories.
Gah -- there are so many specific talking points in this novel which are more suited for a book club than a review so if you belong to a book club, seriously consider adding Under the Tulip Tree to your reading list.
Not only in the Top Ten of my Best Reads of 2020 -- but also the most important title on that list.
Profound. Compelling. Powerful. Pertinent. Emotionally charged. Rocked-my-word-earth-shattering. :-) I have to pause here and say I listened to the audible edition of this book and Sarah Zimmerman's narration brought this already incredible story to a whole other level. I may have used the word gobsmacked to the point of cliche in my reviews lately, but I can't help it. I am!
I felt this story right through every fiber of my being. It touched me and changed me and testified to me. Frankie and Rena came to life through the power of their stories, convicting me afresh of the importance of remembering our past in all it's imperfect, heartbreaking, hard-to-stomach reality. It's only by seeking truth that we can be set free. I saw that so clearly in both Rena and Frankie's stories.
Gah -- there are so many specific talking points in this novel which are more suited for a book club than a review so if you belong to a book club, seriously consider adding Under the Tulip Tree to your reading list.
Not only in the Top Ten of my Best Reads of 2020 -- but also the most important title on that list.
September 20, 2020
Well written novel about the daughter of a banker that went from a life of privilege to one of financial difficulty following the stock market crash in 1929. After Rena loses her job with the local newspaper, she secures a position with the Works Progress Administration as a writer in the Federal Writers' Project. She is nervous about the position, but the pay is good and definitely needed by her family. Rena's job is to capture the story of former slaves.
Engaging novel that brings to light the importance of getting to know people different from ourselves.
Engaging novel that brings to light the importance of getting to know people different from ourselves.
March 23, 2021
POWERFUL, THOUGHT PROVOKING, WELL TOLD STORY ON FORGIVENESS
Seven years after the stock market crash, Lorena Leland's family still struggles with a fortune lost. Lorena's debutante status crashed when her father's bank collapsed due to bad investments. The result is Lorena's college plans are discarded, her father has become an alcoholic hermit, Lorena's mother dismisses their help and they become out casts in Nashville society. Now Lorena takes a temporary job for the WPA's Federal Writer's Project, recording the memories of former slaves many who are nearing or older than 100 years old. Lorena immediately connects especially to Frankie, a woman who was in her late 20's during the civil war. Their affinity toward one another draws Lorena to dig deeper beyond the assigned questions to understand Frankie more personally. To do this, Lorena meets with Frankie during off hours especially the weekend.
Meanwhile, Lorena's mother is horrified that Lorena is interviewing negros and says disparaging things. Lorena is displeased with her mother's racist views especially as she worries what the society she once was a part of, will think of her child going to the negro section of town. However, Lorena refuses to quit her job. Her mother realizes that the funds are desperately needed but nevertheless continues to say ugly things about the program and those being interviewed.
Eventually, Lorena understands that the comments heard among the society's upper crust along with the lack of true factual information during her schooling has led her to really misunderstand the horrors of slavery. The reality challenges her in many ways and she is compelled to understand Frankie's past. I was near tears several times during the story. The telling was very matter of fact and heart wrenching. I noticed several times I was so impacted, I was holding my breath!
It is truly one of the best books I've ever read on the topic of forgiveness. I couldn't seem to read fast enough as I became so immersed in Frankie's story. I completed the story in less than 36 hours (approximately 400 pages long), as I skipped hours of sleep and responsibilities to see how the story would end. This past week since, I have returned to its message a number of times, this won't be a book I soon forget.
I look forward to future stories by this master storyteller. The characters were so well crafted and the story so well composed it just flowed as though you are in the room listening to Frankie's voice.
Recommend for anyone who enjoyed "The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman", "The Color Purple" and "The Kitchen House".
Though I marked this Christian, the spiritual references are not aggressive or pushy to the reader. This book would be enjoyed by most readers, without feeling preachy.
Trigger warnings: War, Death, Physical Abuse, and Murder; though none were gratuitous in nature.
Seven years after the stock market crash, Lorena Leland's family still struggles with a fortune lost. Lorena's debutante status crashed when her father's bank collapsed due to bad investments. The result is Lorena's college plans are discarded, her father has become an alcoholic hermit, Lorena's mother dismisses their help and they become out casts in Nashville society. Now Lorena takes a temporary job for the WPA's Federal Writer's Project, recording the memories of former slaves many who are nearing or older than 100 years old. Lorena immediately connects especially to Frankie, a woman who was in her late 20's during the civil war. Their affinity toward one another draws Lorena to dig deeper beyond the assigned questions to understand Frankie more personally. To do this, Lorena meets with Frankie during off hours especially the weekend.
Meanwhile, Lorena's mother is horrified that Lorena is interviewing negros and says disparaging things. Lorena is displeased with her mother's racist views especially as she worries what the society she once was a part of, will think of her child going to the negro section of town. However, Lorena refuses to quit her job. Her mother realizes that the funds are desperately needed but nevertheless continues to say ugly things about the program and those being interviewed.
Eventually, Lorena understands that the comments heard among the society's upper crust along with the lack of true factual information during her schooling has led her to really misunderstand the horrors of slavery. The reality challenges her in many ways and she is compelled to understand Frankie's past. I was near tears several times during the story. The telling was very matter of fact and heart wrenching. I noticed several times I was so impacted, I was holding my breath!
It is truly one of the best books I've ever read on the topic of forgiveness. I couldn't seem to read fast enough as I became so immersed in Frankie's story. I completed the story in less than 36 hours (approximately 400 pages long), as I skipped hours of sleep and responsibilities to see how the story would end. This past week since, I have returned to its message a number of times, this won't be a book I soon forget.
I look forward to future stories by this master storyteller. The characters were so well crafted and the story so well composed it just flowed as though you are in the room listening to Frankie's voice.
Recommend for anyone who enjoyed "The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman", "The Color Purple" and "The Kitchen House".
Though I marked this Christian, the spiritual references are not aggressive or pushy to the reader. This book would be enjoyed by most readers, without feeling preachy.
Trigger warnings: War, Death, Physical Abuse, and Murder; though none were gratuitous in nature.
May 9, 2021
The beginning of this book was really promising! It follows a wealthy family in the American south and their life after the stock market crash in 1929. Rena, our main character finds a job interviewing former slaves, where we are introduced to Frankie, and are told her story. In predictable ways, as the two women become friends, we discover that their lives have already intertwined prior to their first meeting.
I genuinely enjoyed the first half of this novel and I think Michelle Shocklee is amazing at her craft. The dual perspectives fit perfectly together and I found that although I prefered reading about Frankie's story much more, I was interested enough in Rena's to follow along without hesitation.
Though, I couldn't help but notice things in the story that left me uneasy. Although I understand the importance of how Rena educated herself and pushed herself to learn more about the cruel history of her ancestors, I feel as if she was constantly being praised in the writing for doing the bare minimum. The LEAST anyone can do is to hear the stories of survivors and listen to those who have been wronged, but why does this privileged woman from a wealthy upbringing receive so much credit for it? I also found it absurd how their stories even compared; especially in a specific scene where Rena is walking down the sidewalk of a poverty stricken neighborhood apparently evoked the same feeling as when Frankie was running away from slavers. There were multiple examples of this common theme, which dampened the entirety of an otherwise well written story.
I was not aware that this was a Christian text when I started reading, but it became very clear in the second half of the novel. I found that the specific -magical element- in the end of the book to be extremely unnecessary and the novel would have served greater purpose without it. The world and issues faced by Frankie do not disappear at the end of this novel, it is 2021 and prejudices still exist.
Another thing that could be left out of this novel was the romances. They added absolutely nothing to the story and I found them to be unnecessary. Honestly, I don't think I would have minded it as much if the library hadn't misleadingly shelved this book as "Historical Romance" which is why I picked it up in the first place.
Overall, I enjoyed reading about Frankie and Rena's story, though the execution of certain topics and events did not sit easy with me. I can absolutely see how some people may love this book and others may also hate it. Though for me, I'm having a bit of trouble formulating that strong of an opinion on it.
I genuinely enjoyed the first half of this novel and I think Michelle Shocklee is amazing at her craft. The dual perspectives fit perfectly together and I found that although I prefered reading about Frankie's story much more, I was interested enough in Rena's to follow along without hesitation.
Though, I couldn't help but notice things in the story that left me uneasy. Although I understand the importance of how Rena educated herself and pushed herself to learn more about the cruel history of her ancestors, I feel as if she was constantly being praised in the writing for doing the bare minimum. The LEAST anyone can do is to hear the stories of survivors and listen to those who have been wronged, but why does this privileged woman from a wealthy upbringing receive so much credit for it? I also found it absurd how their stories even compared; especially in a specific scene where Rena is walking down the sidewalk of a poverty stricken neighborhood apparently evoked the same feeling as when Frankie was running away from slavers. There were multiple examples of this common theme, which dampened the entirety of an otherwise well written story.
I was not aware that this was a Christian text when I started reading, but it became very clear in the second half of the novel. I found that the specific -magical element- in the end of the book to be extremely unnecessary and the novel would have served greater purpose without it. The world and issues faced by Frankie do not disappear at the end of this novel, it is 2021 and prejudices still exist.
Another thing that could be left out of this novel was the romances. They added absolutely nothing to the story and I found them to be unnecessary. Honestly, I don't think I would have minded it as much if the library hadn't misleadingly shelved this book as "Historical Romance" which is why I picked it up in the first place.
Overall, I enjoyed reading about Frankie and Rena's story, though the execution of certain topics and events did not sit easy with me. I can absolutely see how some people may love this book and others may also hate it. Though for me, I'm having a bit of trouble formulating that strong of an opinion on it.
February 20, 2021
This was the most tone deaf book I’ve possibly ever read and I wish I had done a bit more research before purchasing it. The book/author has a major white saviour complex and the author has no place writing about slavery and forgiveness, especially considering her previous books (I’ve since learned) are plantation romance novels. Everything is problematic from the dialect she uses for black characters to the supposed ignorance of all the white characters to anything to do with slavery and racism. I am honestly appalled that this book has so many 4 and 5-star reviews.
July 15, 2020
From Endorsement:
Under the Tulip Tree is a brilliant and authentic look at the power of a story to break through the complicated entanglement of racial tension. Brave, authentic, and moving, Michelle Shocklee takes readers on an adventure of historical significance that is sure to leave them with hope. A grace-filled and beautiful reminder that every story—and every person—matters.
Under the Tulip Tree is a brilliant and authentic look at the power of a story to break through the complicated entanglement of racial tension. Brave, authentic, and moving, Michelle Shocklee takes readers on an adventure of historical significance that is sure to leave them with hope. A grace-filled and beautiful reminder that every story—and every person—matters.
October 16, 2020
Wow, what a fabulous book! This is split fiction, moving between the 1860s and the 1930s. Michelle does a wonderful job of bringing the characters to life, both the slave woman and the young woman who interviews her. The story is well done, well thought out, and very timely. One of my favorite reads of the year. Yes, I cried, it was that beautiful.
January 12, 2021
Think...The Help
DNF-I just rolled my eyes so hard. PASS
DNF-I just rolled my eyes so hard. PASS
January 17, 2021
Amazing book! Moving and healing!
August 12, 2021
I loved this book, and the audiobook version was done so very well! Great story, bravely told. I am eager to read more from this author.
October 9, 2020
Really good book! I cried at the ending!
April 1, 2025
This book was absolutely beautiful. The writing was amazing, and I loved how the author handled the historical setting with such care and depth.
Between the market crash in the 1920s and Frankie’s story as a former slave, there was so much depth to this book. The way those two timelines connected made the story really powerful.
I absolutely loved the main character and Frankie! They listened to each other with so much grace, shared some really hard parts of their lives, and did such a great job of showing what it was like to live through slavery a hundred years before Frankie’s story was told.
The most impactful part for me was when Frankie shared how she gave her life to the Lord and, because of that, was able to forgive someone who had deeply hurt her and her family. That moment showed the heart of the gospel, and it was written so well.
I recommend this book to everyone! There wasn’t a single cuss word, no romance or inappropriate scenes—just a really incredible story. I’ll definitely be reading more from this author!
Between the market crash in the 1920s and Frankie’s story as a former slave, there was so much depth to this book. The way those two timelines connected made the story really powerful.
I absolutely loved the main character and Frankie! They listened to each other with so much grace, shared some really hard parts of their lives, and did such a great job of showing what it was like to live through slavery a hundred years before Frankie’s story was told.
The most impactful part for me was when Frankie shared how she gave her life to the Lord and, because of that, was able to forgive someone who had deeply hurt her and her family. That moment showed the heart of the gospel, and it was written so well.
I recommend this book to everyone! There wasn’t a single cuss word, no romance or inappropriate scenes—just a really incredible story. I’ll definitely be reading more from this author!
October 6, 2020
Past and Present mixes rather nicely in this novel. The author has done a very nice job with this book. I enjoyed it very much.
The past can define us as to whom we become in the future. It can make us or break us if we let it.
I have never been more prouder than I was with Rena and Frankie.
These amazing women sure have some powerful stories to tell. I got lost in their stories. I found myself wanting to cry many times especially when Frankie was remembering her past. I really couldn't imagine going through what Frankie or Rena has and coming out much stronger and courageous for it.
Redemption and forgiveness are a part of this story too.
My favorite quote:
"Hatred is a powerful thing." " It can turn a person into something they ain't. It don't matter what color your skin is. "
Yes, sometimes it's hard to let go and it never really goes away but if we decide to accept God's love and forgive even if it's for yourself I'd like to think that we can be at peace. Hate and fear just eats a person up on the inside and out.
Forgiving isn't always easy which was why I admired Frankie that much more! I think my mouth dropped open when I found out how old she really was!
I was delighted to see that the author mentioned Fisk University in her novel. I had the honor of meeting someone from Fisk. He was a young guest pastor at the church I was going to at the time. I was so excited to meet him because I'd just got done reading Tamera Alexander's book. I felt like the timing couldn't have been more perfect!
This novel was so very good! This is like the fourth book this year that has spoken to my heart. Inside is a story that needs to be read especially because of 2020's events going on.
I highly recommend this book. It wil speak to you in more ways than one. Trust me.
My thanks to Netgalley/Tyndale House for an ecopy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review and all opinions are my own.
The past can define us as to whom we become in the future. It can make us or break us if we let it.
I have never been more prouder than I was with Rena and Frankie.
These amazing women sure have some powerful stories to tell. I got lost in their stories. I found myself wanting to cry many times especially when Frankie was remembering her past. I really couldn't imagine going through what Frankie or Rena has and coming out much stronger and courageous for it.
Redemption and forgiveness are a part of this story too.
My favorite quote:
"Hatred is a powerful thing." " It can turn a person into something they ain't. It don't matter what color your skin is. "
Yes, sometimes it's hard to let go and it never really goes away but if we decide to accept God's love and forgive even if it's for yourself I'd like to think that we can be at peace. Hate and fear just eats a person up on the inside and out.
Forgiving isn't always easy which was why I admired Frankie that much more! I think my mouth dropped open when I found out how old she really was!
I was delighted to see that the author mentioned Fisk University in her novel. I had the honor of meeting someone from Fisk. He was a young guest pastor at the church I was going to at the time. I was so excited to meet him because I'd just got done reading Tamera Alexander's book. I felt like the timing couldn't have been more perfect!
This novel was so very good! This is like the fourth book this year that has spoken to my heart. Inside is a story that needs to be read especially because of 2020's events going on.
I highly recommend this book. It wil speak to you in more ways than one. Trust me.
My thanks to Netgalley/Tyndale House for an ecopy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review and all opinions are my own.
December 9, 2020
2/5.
I enjoyed the first 70% or so of this book. The story was interesting, engaging and well written, and I loved Frankie and Rena and their budding friendship.
But then the typical tropes starting coming up to the surface.
Frankie is written as a character that endures tragedy after tragedy after tragedy, and somehow is happy despite all of this when she reflects on her life during her interview. I hate when they paint Black enslaved people as grateful for what little good they are given through years of trauma, enslavement and abuse.
Then we have Rena, the only person who Frankie will tell this story to who is... white (*feigns surprise*). It doesn't end there though, when the WPA won't publish the interview as written, Rena goes and gets the piece published.... all after Frankie's death. *insert eye roll*. Rena's character screamed white saviour to a point where I could hardly get through the last bit of the book.
Finally, what I thought was the dumbest, most unnecessary plot point, Rena's ancestor was the one who owned Frankie as a child! This was so unnecessary, and I feel like it would have made the book so much better if there was no connection between the two characters. Instead, we have Rena dealing with the guilt of her ancestors (who felt hardly any), and Frankie forgiving both Rena and her family for everything they did to her.
Dumb, dumb, dumb.
This book had so much potential, but, as a Black woman myself, I can't forgive how bad it got right near the end.
I enjoyed the first 70% or so of this book. The story was interesting, engaging and well written, and I loved Frankie and Rena and their budding friendship.
But then the typical tropes starting coming up to the surface.
Frankie is written as a character that endures tragedy after tragedy after tragedy, and somehow is happy despite all of this when she reflects on her life during her interview. I hate when they paint Black enslaved people as grateful for what little good they are given through years of trauma, enslavement and abuse.
Then we have Rena, the only person who Frankie will tell this story to who is... white (*feigns surprise*). It doesn't end there though, when the WPA won't publish the interview as written, Rena goes and gets the piece published.... all after Frankie's death. *insert eye roll*. Rena's character screamed white saviour to a point where I could hardly get through the last bit of the book.
Finally, what I thought was the dumbest, most unnecessary plot point, Rena's ancestor was the one who owned Frankie as a child! This was so unnecessary, and I feel like it would have made the book so much better if there was no connection between the two characters. Instead, we have Rena dealing with the guilt of her ancestors (who felt hardly any), and Frankie forgiving both Rena and her family for everything they did to her.
Dumb, dumb, dumb.
This book had so much potential, but, as a Black woman myself, I can't forgive how bad it got right near the end.
August 11, 2020
Life changing events really do form us, and change us personally, and with the stock market crash of 1929 our girl Rena life changes forever.
Frankie Washington was born a slave, as we hear her story, you will cringe, so much pain for a little girl. We meet her at 101 years old, and I wanted to be there with Rena. What a gift she is given when Frankie agrees to tell her story, but never in my wildest dreams would I have guessed the connection.
The story Frankie tells will have you page turning, and we are gifted with her coming to faith, and how she shares it. Could I do what she did? No, I don't think so, but God was pushing her, and the results were life changing.
A wonderful read, and I really couldn't put it down!
I received this book through Edelweiss and Tyndale House Publishers. and was not required to give a positive review.
Frankie Washington was born a slave, as we hear her story, you will cringe, so much pain for a little girl. We meet her at 101 years old, and I wanted to be there with Rena. What a gift she is given when Frankie agrees to tell her story, but never in my wildest dreams would I have guessed the connection.
The story Frankie tells will have you page turning, and we are gifted with her coming to faith, and how she shares it. Could I do what she did? No, I don't think so, but God was pushing her, and the results were life changing.
A wonderful read, and I really couldn't put it down!
I received this book through Edelweiss and Tyndale House Publishers. and was not required to give a positive review.
March 2, 2022
It took me the longest to finish this audiobook. I’d put it down to finish library books, then pick it back up throughout the next four+ weeks. But once I got about halfway, I couldn’t put it down.
The story of Frankie, an ex-slave, is not to be missed.
Beautiful faith messages from an abused woman who held it against God for the longest time. But the love and tenderness of a Quaker woman, and a handsome man who trusted in the Lord for everything, radically changed Frankie's heart.
Wonderful, wonderful story!
Narration by Sarah Zimmerman was superb!
The story of Frankie, an ex-slave, is not to be missed.
Beautiful faith messages from an abused woman who held it against God for the longest time. But the love and tenderness of a Quaker woman, and a handsome man who trusted in the Lord for everything, radically changed Frankie's heart.
Wonderful, wonderful story!
Narration by Sarah Zimmerman was superb!
April 26, 2022
Wow, just wow! This book has just become one of my new favourite reads; pretty sure it will make the top books of 2022!
I loved the dual timeline, the lovely twist (which I guessed), and the very minimal romance. The emphasis was more on friendship and strong relationships instead of romance, which was a nice breath of fresh air. I loved everything about this book and wasn’t ready for it to end. I want more of these characters - Rena, Mary, Frankie, Alden, Jael, and all the rest!
I listened to this as an audiobook book, and I absolutely adored the narrator; her southern accent is perfectly in keeping with the story, soft and southern-belle like.
The themes of forgiveness, loving one’s enemy, and the danger of prejudice and racism were beautifully woven in. To be fair, I will point out that not all Southerns treated their slaves horribly, as the book didn’t really discuss this.
This book gave me much to think about, and the characters and their stories won’t be leaving my mind anytime soon.
And the cover! *swoons* I want a copy on my shelf!
I loved the dual timeline, the lovely twist (which I guessed), and the very minimal romance. The emphasis was more on friendship and strong relationships instead of romance, which was a nice breath of fresh air. I loved everything about this book and wasn’t ready for it to end. I want more of these characters - Rena, Mary, Frankie, Alden, Jael, and all the rest!
I listened to this as an audiobook book, and I absolutely adored the narrator; her southern accent is perfectly in keeping with the story, soft and southern-belle like.
The themes of forgiveness, loving one’s enemy, and the danger of prejudice and racism were beautifully woven in. To be fair, I will point out that not all Southerns treated their slaves horribly, as the book didn’t really discuss this.
This book gave me much to think about, and the characters and their stories won’t be leaving my mind anytime soon.
And the cover! *swoons* I want a copy on my shelf!
December 14, 2020
You need to see life in a different perspective in order to move forward.
Lorena Leland 16th birthday changed her life forever. She had big dreams and her 16th birthday party would be the catalyst of those dreams. When the stock market hit, her family lost their social standing and the wealth that comes with it. Her family changed over night. Seven years later, her father drinks to oblivion, her mother is working, and her oldest sister's marriage is falling apart. Lorena's life changes yet again when she accepts the New Deal project - the Federal Writer's Project. Reporters/writers are being hired out to interview men and women who survived slavery 70 years later. The government sees a need to bring these stories to light to learn from them and to change policy for the country to move forward.
Lorena is apprehensive about her new project. She knows about slavery but not the evils of slavery. How slaves were treated and abused. Her attitude begins to come to light when she meets Franki Washington. Upon meeting Lorena, Franki tells her that she has been waiting for her to tell her story.
With a dual time line, you get a wide range of emotions. Starting with Franki as a young child and being brutally beaten by the lady of the house. Her separation from her mother and losing each person she has loved. Lorena's emotions as she is faced with her own prejudices and her own families loss and prejudices.
Being a Christian Historical novel, I thought it had a nice aspect of faith. I enjoy real struggles of our sin. Lorena struggled with faith and who God is. Her questioning God on how can a loving God allow evil and suffering. Franki also struggled with faith until she became free. That is the spiritual lesson in their stories. Both women were in bondage of a different kind but the road to freedom was the same.
Another good aspect of Historical fiction is taking some actual accounts such as the request of the president to have these stories recorded. Another was the the time that the civil war ended and picking up the pieces of both the South and the North. The healing is still taking place because where there is no freedom, there is no healing. Highly recommend.
A Special Thank you to Tyndale Publishing House and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportuity to post an honest review.
Lorena Leland 16th birthday changed her life forever. She had big dreams and her 16th birthday party would be the catalyst of those dreams. When the stock market hit, her family lost their social standing and the wealth that comes with it. Her family changed over night. Seven years later, her father drinks to oblivion, her mother is working, and her oldest sister's marriage is falling apart. Lorena's life changes yet again when she accepts the New Deal project - the Federal Writer's Project. Reporters/writers are being hired out to interview men and women who survived slavery 70 years later. The government sees a need to bring these stories to light to learn from them and to change policy for the country to move forward.
Lorena is apprehensive about her new project. She knows about slavery but not the evils of slavery. How slaves were treated and abused. Her attitude begins to come to light when she meets Franki Washington. Upon meeting Lorena, Franki tells her that she has been waiting for her to tell her story.
With a dual time line, you get a wide range of emotions. Starting with Franki as a young child and being brutally beaten by the lady of the house. Her separation from her mother and losing each person she has loved. Lorena's emotions as she is faced with her own prejudices and her own families loss and prejudices.
Being a Christian Historical novel, I thought it had a nice aspect of faith. I enjoy real struggles of our sin. Lorena struggled with faith and who God is. Her questioning God on how can a loving God allow evil and suffering. Franki also struggled with faith until she became free. That is the spiritual lesson in their stories. Both women were in bondage of a different kind but the road to freedom was the same.
Another good aspect of Historical fiction is taking some actual accounts such as the request of the president to have these stories recorded. Another was the the time that the civil war ended and picking up the pieces of both the South and the North. The healing is still taking place because where there is no freedom, there is no healing. Highly recommend.
A Special Thank you to Tyndale Publishing House and Netgalley for the ARC and the opportuity to post an honest review.
May 31, 2025
3ish/4 ⭐️ I had quite a few jumbled thoughts while reading this. I felt it had many thought provoking moments that held space for good conversations.. somewhere in the middle I caught an air of the white savior vibe.. not sure if the author had a mission or just offered many opinions as there is many throughout the book, which I can appreciate.. BUT it did kinda throw me off with the tone of the whole rest of the story..
in spite of any of this it IS a beautiful story🤷🏻♀️
in spite of any of this it IS a beautiful story🤷🏻♀️
September 25, 2020
4.5 stars
"Hatred is a powerful thing. It can turn a person into something they ain't. It don't matter what color your skin in."
Never did she imagine that taking a job with the Federal Writers' Project would lead her to a face in the mirror that she never wanted to call her own. Lorena Leland simply dreamed of being a writer, that's all. Her post-depression family desperately needed the income that she could generate and the job sounded interesting if not a bit inconsequential, for "How could interviewing people who'd lived in bondage decades earlier help (Lorena) see her future more clearly? There was only one way to find out."
Mrs. Francis Washington. "Fact is, I ain't never told my story to anyone since freedom come. No sense in rememberin' them days, I say". But remember them she did; Lorena spent days listening and writing, and writing and listening, to a story that begged release. . . . under the tulip tree.
Behold the lives of two women; one young and unsure of herself, the other "older than dirt" and quite certain that she has lived the life that God meant her to live; nonetheless the struggles were real, for Frankie's outer wounds scarcely covered the ones she kept hidden within. Skillfully showcasing the power of forgiveness, the author tastefully pens events from a period of history that many would like to pretend never happened, but it's only in the remembering that we can erase the possibility of repetition.
"I am going to tell your story, Frankie . . . . . .Thank you for entrusting me with it."
"Hatred is a powerful thing. It can turn a person into something they ain't. It don't matter what color your skin in."
Never did she imagine that taking a job with the Federal Writers' Project would lead her to a face in the mirror that she never wanted to call her own. Lorena Leland simply dreamed of being a writer, that's all. Her post-depression family desperately needed the income that she could generate and the job sounded interesting if not a bit inconsequential, for "How could interviewing people who'd lived in bondage decades earlier help (Lorena) see her future more clearly? There was only one way to find out."
Mrs. Francis Washington. "Fact is, I ain't never told my story to anyone since freedom come. No sense in rememberin' them days, I say". But remember them she did; Lorena spent days listening and writing, and writing and listening, to a story that begged release. . . . under the tulip tree.
Behold the lives of two women; one young and unsure of herself, the other "older than dirt" and quite certain that she has lived the life that God meant her to live; nonetheless the struggles were real, for Frankie's outer wounds scarcely covered the ones she kept hidden within. Skillfully showcasing the power of forgiveness, the author tastefully pens events from a period of history that many would like to pretend never happened, but it's only in the remembering that we can erase the possibility of repetition.
"I am going to tell your story, Frankie . . . . . .Thank you for entrusting me with it."
March 14, 2021
Not sure why the author felt that this was her story to tell. Lots of Christian saviorism going on and forcing the abused to forgive their abuser 🤢
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,891 reviews