What do you think?
Rate this book
Memorable Proposals #1
Une fâcheuse demande
Eleanor Daventry's inheritance promises an end to her problems—until she discovers that she must marry to keep it. Meanwhile, Stratford Tunstall learns that his uncle willed his lands to Miss Daventry. To Stratford, it's only logical that they should marry, but he botches the proposal, and badly. Disgusted, Eleanor is certain they could never love each other, but being thrown together for a season in London threatens to change both their minds.
364 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2021
855 people are currently reading
853 people want to read
About the author
Jennie Goutet
28 books622 followersJennie Goutet is the best-selling author of eighteen historical romances, including the Clavering Chronicles, Memorable Proposals, and The Bridwells’ Grand Tour series. Her books have received first place in historical romance for the New England Reader’s Choice Awards and have hit the number one spot in Regency Romance on Amazon. They have been featured on BookBub and Hoopla, and are translated into six languages. Jennie is an American-born Anglophile who lives with her French husband and their three children in a small town outside of Paris, but her imagination resides in Georgian England, where her proper historical romances are set. You can learn more about Jennie’s books and sign up for her newsletter on her author website, jenniegoutet.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 312 reviews
April 4, 2022
The problem for me was that I don't see this book as really a romance. And it has nothing to do with the fact that it is a Christian romance. But the fact that the main couple was not really deciditing if they wanted to be together until the very end. We had much more romance from the side couple than anything else.
It was definitely an enjoyable read, but not a romance imo. And everything ended up super fast without answering the important questions. Almost like you have to read the next one to find out how things turned out with this couple. And I hated the girl from the next book, so I won't know...
It was definitely an enjoyable read, but not a romance imo. And everything ended up super fast without answering the important questions. Almost like you have to read the next one to find out how things turned out with this couple. And I hated the girl from the next book, so I won't know...
January 22, 2020
There should be different categories of regency romances. Some are very true to the times and some are a little lenient with the language, correct behavior and society. There was very little opportunity for 2 people to have alone time. That is why you get Jane Austen books where the couples only talk 4 times and are in love. This is one of those books. I felt like I was reading an author who had written this a hundred years ago. It was well done and the writing was very good. I was happy with this romance but wished they would have broke the rules a little more and had more conversations. I liked the whole spy element it added a nice touch that kept the book moving. I want to give it 4 stars but it just left me wanting more.
March 31, 2022
Lovely couple! The hero shares Mr. Darcy’s talent for frank proposals ;)
I truly enjoyed this book. The heroine was young but mature and intelligent, and the hero shared Mr. Darcy’s talent for frank speech, especially during proposals (lol), and his infallible honor.
I plan to binge the whole series!
I truly enjoyed this book. The heroine was young but mature and intelligent, and the hero shared Mr. Darcy’s talent for frank speech, especially during proposals (lol), and his infallible honor.
I plan to binge the whole series!
May 12, 2019
I honestly ADORED this book! I have long been a clean regency romance lover, but only recently began reading Georgette Heyer, and have really enjoyed reading her novels and coming to know more of the true history behind the regency era. I mention this because I have not yet read a book in this genre that I felt mixed knowledge of the era in such an easy-to-read manner with superb writing. On that note, I loved that though Goutet focused on her two main characters, she also wrote intertwining subplots that we were able to read snippets of from a 3rd person POV. Additionally, I loved the plot line, that the characters had their flaws but were still endearing, and the underlying espionage/mystery. The romance was slow to build, and definitely started on rocky footing, but it was believable and sweet. I would definitely recommend this book to anyone looking for a clean, can't-put-down read!
February 1, 2020
A charming Regency with likable characters and evil villains, witty dialogue, an espionage attempt, and a perfect amount of romance!
October 10, 2023
Audiobook
This was a sweet, gentle romance. Stratford, Earl of Worthing , having spent the past three years fighting, is home and growing into his unexpected title. Eleanor, his uncle’s ward, is a kind and independent lady. They do have an attraction to each other but they are friends first of all. Stratford also has an unfortunate way of explaining himself to Eleanor which causes problems. There is also the mystery to solve, of who is the spy and a jealous ex,with which to contend. I did enjoy this story, it was a little slow at times but it had plenty of action in the latter part. I received a copy and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This was a sweet, gentle romance. Stratford, Earl of Worthing , having spent the past three years fighting, is home and growing into his unexpected title. Eleanor, his uncle’s ward, is a kind and independent lady. They do have an attraction to each other but they are friends first of all. Stratford also has an unfortunate way of explaining himself to Eleanor which causes problems. There is also the mystery to solve, of who is the spy and a jealous ex,with which to contend. I did enjoy this story, it was a little slow at times but it had plenty of action in the latter part. I received a copy and have voluntarily reviewed it. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
January 13, 2022
Reminiscent of Austen and Heyer, this is a clever, well written story of intrigue and romance that I thoroughly enjoyed. Eleanor and Stratford have quite a few obstacles to overcome on the road to happiness, not the least of which is the regrettable proposal. There is also a jealous ex-fiancé, a gossipy schoolmate, a French spy, and a scandal just waiting to be heard. I really liked the secondary characters, especially Lydia and Major Fitzwilliam, and also Stratford’s sisters Anna and Phoebe, who each have their own books in the series. This is a sweet Regency romance that stands alone with a satisfying ending.
April 22, 2022
Fun, clean regency romance read! Always fun to discover an author of such, now to work my way through her backlist. I suppose I’ll take a break now and then. 😊
October 9, 2023
I know that I'd listened to this book before, but that was before I'd kept track of books or left reviews. Honestly, I couldn't remember much about the book, right up to the end! I'm terrible about remembering plots and stories!
The author kindly gifted me a copy of the audiobook and I decided I'd listen again. I really enjoyed it! There were romance and intrigue in the story.
This begins a series of "proposal" books. I am looking forward to revisiting those stories as well. Now that I've been reintroduced to the characters, I want to remember what happens to each of them.
The narrator for this book is exceptional! She does great character voices and has a very pleasing manor to her reading.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
The author kindly gifted me a copy of the audiobook and I decided I'd listen again. I really enjoyed it! There were romance and intrigue in the story.
This begins a series of "proposal" books. I am looking forward to revisiting those stories as well. Now that I've been reintroduced to the characters, I want to remember what happens to each of them.
The narrator for this book is exceptional! She does great character voices and has a very pleasing manor to her reading.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
November 14, 2020
This is by no means a perfect book.
But I needed this brand of light -almost- consequence free romance just now. Like ice cold lemonade on a real hot day.
So first the Bad:
There's a historical-military-spy fiction-mystery subplot happening and other than giving the male characters a thing to do other than being Gentlemen, I'm not sure what the purpose was. The romance and plot wouldn't have changed substantially without it except that it would have been a lot more Jane Austen in tone and feel.
I for one quite like the personal drama of a Jane Austen type story but if you need more action this has that.
A lot of the side characters and their relationships feel like obvious set ups for sequel romances. Not necessarily a bad thing but it felt particularly heavy handed in this case.
I thought the romantic rival was overly done. She and the schoolroom rival both seemed more like caricatures than well fleshed out characters, which was jarring next to the other characters who all at least passed surface level realism tests.
I didn't like the twist about who the "real" villain for the subplot was, mostly because it was set up as a mystery but I felt like there were no clues or indication as to what the answer was going to be before the answer just sort of... gets vomited up during what turns out to be a completely unrelated incident.
It ends abruptly. Which is fine I suppose, particularly if this story is tied up to a sequel with one of the other characters. I just expected more than the declaration followed by "the end".
And the Good:
The MAIN CHARACTER. I loved Eleanor. I loved how grounded she was in the reality of her time period while still shying toward wanting Independence. I liked that even in her wishy washy (typical romance heroine) "does he love me? I'm unsure of my feelings" moments, she still felt in character.
I loved that she's a plain jane. And not Hollywood "everybody compliments her because obviously she's just one nice dress of turning the head of every man in the room" plain. She's genuinely unbecoming. She's described as no great beauty by almost every character, including herself, and it's fine. She dresses to her advantage but being beautiful or not doesn't concern her. People are drawn to her personality and strength of character (and surprise inheritance). It's a nice change to have a "not that pretty" protagonist that really isn't all that pretty.
Worthing is no Darcy but he's an absolute mess of an attractive man who can't stop sticking his foot in his mouth and I like that in a romantic lead? Idk there's something fundamentally wrong with me.
Also The Older Brother. I wish the obvious nudge toward his pending romance in a later book had been less slap in the face but as a character I liked him a lot. Affectionate and indulgent but not overly involved with enough personality to build into a Leading Man later.
I loved Lydia! And the twins! The SISTERHOOD. The FRIENDSHIP. Part of why the spy thriller interludes displeased me is because all of the scenes from woman's perspective in woman's spheres of influence just dazzled. From the salons and drawing rooms to the dance floors and walks in Hyde Park.
The Almost Leading Man. He's so good! And there's nothing wrong with him! And it's fine that Eleanor doesn't love him! It's rare that the guy who is sweet and charming and cares about the leading lady but isn't Leading Man doesn't also have a dark and terrible (usually murderous) secret. And this one doesn't. She just doesn't love him. Oh well. He's not suddenly a monster for that fact, though he doesn't take the rejection totally gracefully. He and his relations were likable and I wanted to read a story where he found someone to love.
Over all a good time. If you like a regency romance with strong Austen influence you might give this a try.
But I needed this brand of light -almost- consequence free romance just now. Like ice cold lemonade on a real hot day.
So first the Bad:
There's a historical-military-spy fiction-mystery subplot happening and other than giving the male characters a thing to do other than being Gentlemen, I'm not sure what the purpose was. The romance and plot wouldn't have changed substantially without it except that it would have been a lot more Jane Austen in tone and feel.
I for one quite like the personal drama of a Jane Austen type story but if you need more action this has that.
A lot of the side characters and their relationships feel like obvious set ups for sequel romances. Not necessarily a bad thing but it felt particularly heavy handed in this case.
I thought the romantic rival was overly done. She and the schoolroom rival both seemed more like caricatures than well fleshed out characters, which was jarring next to the other characters who all at least passed surface level realism tests.
I didn't like the twist about who the "real" villain for the subplot was, mostly because it was set up as a mystery but I felt like there were no clues or indication as to what the answer was going to be before the answer just sort of... gets vomited up during what turns out to be a completely unrelated incident.
It ends abruptly. Which is fine I suppose, particularly if this story is tied up to a sequel with one of the other characters. I just expected more than the declaration followed by "the end".
And the Good:
The MAIN CHARACTER. I loved Eleanor. I loved how grounded she was in the reality of her time period while still shying toward wanting Independence. I liked that even in her wishy washy (typical romance heroine) "does he love me? I'm unsure of my feelings" moments, she still felt in character.
I loved that she's a plain jane. And not Hollywood "everybody compliments her because obviously she's just one nice dress of turning the head of every man in the room" plain. She's genuinely unbecoming. She's described as no great beauty by almost every character, including herself, and it's fine. She dresses to her advantage but being beautiful or not doesn't concern her. People are drawn to her personality and strength of character (and surprise inheritance). It's a nice change to have a "not that pretty" protagonist that really isn't all that pretty.
Worthing is no Darcy but he's an absolute mess of an attractive man who can't stop sticking his foot in his mouth and I like that in a romantic lead? Idk there's something fundamentally wrong with me.
Also The Older Brother. I wish the obvious nudge toward his pending romance in a later book had been less slap in the face but as a character I liked him a lot. Affectionate and indulgent but not overly involved with enough personality to build into a Leading Man later.
I loved Lydia! And the twins! The SISTERHOOD. The FRIENDSHIP. Part of why the spy thriller interludes displeased me is because all of the scenes from woman's perspective in woman's spheres of influence just dazzled. From the salons and drawing rooms to the dance floors and walks in Hyde Park.
The Almost Leading Man. He's so good! And there's nothing wrong with him! And it's fine that Eleanor doesn't love him! It's rare that the guy who is sweet and charming and cares about the leading lady but isn't Leading Man doesn't also have a dark and terrible (usually murderous) secret. And this one doesn't. She just doesn't love him. Oh well. He's not suddenly a monster for that fact, though he doesn't take the rejection totally gracefully. He and his relations were likable and I wanted to read a story where he found someone to love.
Over all a good time. If you like a regency romance with strong Austen influence you might give this a try.
January 22, 2022
There were so many things I loved about this story. It almost had a part I and part II feel to it I actually love, getting a change of scenery and introducing new characters and knowing that this is a series it makes me excited to think about the next story coming!
The premise of this story was super fun. I loved the plot twist that Eleanor will be saved by this inheritance, but is required to marry to use it. Stratford has quite the character arc and I loved watching it play out. I grew to really love his character and there were so many sweet and special moments between him and Eleanor that I couldn’t help but cheer for them… or laugh at all the ways Stratford blundered through things.
I’m excited to see where this series takes me! If you like anything relating to history and marriage proposals I think you’ll enjoy this one!
Thanks to the author for the copy. All thoughts in this review are my own.
The premise of this story was super fun. I loved the plot twist that Eleanor will be saved by this inheritance, but is required to marry to use it. Stratford has quite the character arc and I loved watching it play out. I grew to really love his character and there were so many sweet and special moments between him and Eleanor that I couldn’t help but cheer for them… or laugh at all the ways Stratford blundered through things.
I’m excited to see where this series takes me! If you like anything relating to history and marriage proposals I think you’ll enjoy this one!
Thanks to the author for the copy. All thoughts in this review are my own.
September 22, 2021
Reading this book was like eating a bag of crisps I used to eat as a child.
The bag is a lot emptier and more full of air than you realise and the crisps taste like they’ve been sitting on the shelf since the 90s, yet there’s something moreish about it so you keep eating because you’re enjoying the weird artificial flavouring.
Next thing you know, you look down and you’ve finished the entire bag in one sitting. You’re left feeling not entirely satisfied yet strangely and sickeningly full.
In other words, a light regency romance with not enough character development and too many plot lines but held together well enough to somehow keep you reading.
The bag is a lot emptier and more full of air than you realise and the crisps taste like they’ve been sitting on the shelf since the 90s, yet there’s something moreish about it so you keep eating because you’re enjoying the weird artificial flavouring.
Next thing you know, you look down and you’ve finished the entire bag in one sitting. You’re left feeling not entirely satisfied yet strangely and sickeningly full.
In other words, a light regency romance with not enough character development and too many plot lines but held together well enough to somehow keep you reading.
February 21, 2019
I read A Regrettable Proposal in one day! Jennie Goutet's characters are likable, their story arcs believable, and I enjoyed the just-right amount of tension and conflict between them in their moments of joy and sadness. I was riding right along in the emotions of the main characters of Eleanor Daventry and Stratford Tunstall and enjoyed the supporting cast of friends and family.
I'm not usually a fan of romance but Goutet's compelling storytelling and kindness in which she treats her characters made me a convert. A must-read then, for romance readers.
I'm not usually a fan of romance but Goutet's compelling storytelling and kindness in which she treats her characters made me a convert. A must-read then, for romance readers.
July 5, 2019
This was a decent book. I probably would have rated it three stars, except that I felt the details of the time period were well done (I loved reading about the dance cards, how one had to ask permission for a waltz, etc.), and the romance was very clean -- no excessive kissing or focus on the other's physical attributes. The love seemed to develop naturally.
The only problem was that there was not really a problem to them falling in love. This, perhaps, might have been fine. I might have actually enjoyed a love story in which the characters never shove themselves away and claim that they cannot be together but rather fall in love in a stable and promising way.
However, the author attempted to add this layer in by including the subplot with the traitor. For me, the subplot fell flat, especially in that it needed extra POVs to accomplish (whenever we switched into a viewpoint that was not Eleanor's or Stratford's, it jarred me out of the story). To me, there was no reason for this subplot aside from some contrived conflict. It had no connection with the characters, nor their desires and motivations.
Perhaps, though, that's because the characters didn't have motivations. Eleanor said she wanted to become a schoolteacher, and secretly she wanted to get married and have a family, but why? She was a pleasant, nice face, but had no burning desires. Or even non-burning ones--I have no idea what her interests are. Perhaps reading, but we don't even know what genre she reads.
Similarly, Stratford was a nice guy, if sometimes dense; however, he didn't really seem to have any underlying goals or deep standards that drove him. He was kind but nothing more. Apparently, he had some loyalty to his country, yet we only get one paragraph-long memory from his time fighting in the war. But why would he be so loyal? Again, we learn of no defining events or backstory for him.
TLDR: It was enjoyable, but there was no real conflict fighting against the main characters getting together, and the characters themselves didn't have enough depth.
The only problem was that there was not really a problem to them falling in love. This, perhaps, might have been fine. I might have actually enjoyed a love story in which the characters never shove themselves away and claim that they cannot be together but rather fall in love in a stable and promising way.
However, the author attempted to add this layer in by including the subplot with the traitor. For me, the subplot fell flat, especially in that it needed extra POVs to accomplish (whenever we switched into a viewpoint that was not Eleanor's or Stratford's, it jarred me out of the story). To me, there was no reason for this subplot aside from some contrived conflict. It had no connection with the characters, nor their desires and motivations.
Perhaps, though, that's because the characters didn't have motivations. Eleanor said she wanted to become a schoolteacher, and secretly she wanted to get married and have a family, but why? She was a pleasant, nice face, but had no burning desires. Or even non-burning ones--I have no idea what her interests are. Perhaps reading, but we don't even know what genre she reads.
Similarly, Stratford was a nice guy, if sometimes dense; however, he didn't really seem to have any underlying goals or deep standards that drove him. He was kind but nothing more. Apparently, he had some loyalty to his country, yet we only get one paragraph-long memory from his time fighting in the war. But why would he be so loyal? Again, we learn of no defining events or backstory for him.
TLDR: It was enjoyable, but there was no real conflict fighting against the main characters getting together, and the characters themselves didn't have enough depth.
October 11, 2023
Eleanor Daventry has received and unexpected inheritance but she can't receive it until she's married. Stratford Tunstall has discovered a prime piece of property has been left to Miss Daventry. His brilliant plan to marry her solves both problems--she gets her inheritance and he gets his property back, and he suggest this while after partaking in quite a bit of alcohol. Because drunken proposals are never a good idea Stratford spends a great deal of time apologizing and making up for his drunken proposal to Eleanor, then proving that it isn't about the land; he really does care for her.
I liked that Eleanor didn't care about the inheritance if it meant she was to marry someone she didn't love. She'd rather be a spinster. I loved that Eleanor was such a strong character and I liked Stratford's growth in the story. It was fun to watch them run into each other at the all the society functions in London. Being a lover of mysteries, I really enjoyed the spy subplot in this one.
I listened to the audiobook and thought the narrator did a wonderful job. I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I liked that Eleanor didn't care about the inheritance if it meant she was to marry someone she didn't love. She'd rather be a spinster. I loved that Eleanor was such a strong character and I liked Stratford's growth in the story. It was fun to watch them run into each other at the all the society functions in London. Being a lover of mysteries, I really enjoyed the spy subplot in this one.
I listened to the audiobook and thought the narrator did a wonderful job. I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
March 5, 2019
This was a wonderfully sweet regency novel! Not only was the romance satisfying in its beginning, middle, and end, but there was a layer of mystery and espionage as the hero attempts to find the traitor turned spy. The characters were well developed with flaws that they attempted to overcome through time and all the supporting characters were wonderful as well. I only wish we’d had an epilogue that concluded with a wedding, but that is merely pure indulgence on my part. ♥️
Thank you Cedar Fort Publishing and Jennie Goutet for this eARC!
Thank you Cedar Fort Publishing and Jennie Goutet for this eARC!
March 7, 2019
I VERY much enjoyed A Regrettable Proposal by Jennie Goutet! It read like a true Regency romance.
Miss Eleanor Daventry has been a ward of a wealthy man and came into an unexpected inheritance after he passed away. There is a condition on the inheritance though - she must wed in order to gain her property.
Stanford Tunstall is the heir. He learns the entailed land has been willed to Elanor, and, while this is unforeseen, it is not an insurmountable obstacle. He decides they will wed.
However, Stanford cocks it up royally when proposing to Miss Daventry while in his cups. She is insulted, dismayed and hurt by his actions and decides to cut him from her life. This seems to be a good idea in theory but life keeps throwing them together! And while thrown together, they come to learn more of each other and begin to think they may have been hasty in their mutual dislike.
This was an EXTREMELY enjoyable book! I truly did get a feel of the Regency period. There was no modern language, the characters seemed real, the characters followed a more acceptable and proper Regency protocol, the descriptions were lovely and the story flowed well. The characters also were not "in Love" at first sight but rather allowed their feeling to grow naturally.
The bulk of the writing was also quite well done and mostly proper.
The ONLY reasons I did not give this book a 5 star review are because of what I consider to be technical writing issues that may have been missed by the editor. There were too many sentences ending incorrectly with prepositions. For example: "Any idea what he was searching for?" should really be "Any idea of for what he was searching?", or "You'll have someone to enter society with." instead of "You'll have someone with whom to enter society." or "What is there to speak of?" instead of "Of what is there to speak?" or "......other wildlife she had never heard of,....." instead ".....other wildlife of which she had never heard,...." or "Even so," said Lyia, "there's nothing she can accuse you of." which should be "..... there's nothing of which she can accuse you."
When the overall writing is very good, these thing really jump out to me as careless mistakes/overlooks by the editor.
The editor also overlooked the adverb "got". It should have been "gotten", as in "Now that you have returned to England and have 'gotten' (not got) acquainted with the estate,....." etc. HOWEVER, that is the use in American English.
"Gotten is a past tense form of the verb to get. ... The past tense form of get is got; the past participle of got is gotten. A past participle is a word that's used with had, have or has. Therefore, it's perfectly acceptable to use gotten if it's being used with its companion word.Sep 6, 2012"
http://jadevarden.blogspot.com/2012/0...
And wouldn't Ingram call Anna "Miss Tunstall"? Would he be that familiar?
Personally, I feel there is vast overuse of the words "smirk", "smirked", "grin" and "grinned" (as well as some others......) One or two "grins" at the most should do it. There are many other words in that are just as good for facial expressions. I think the "grin" and "grinning" too much are at odds with the propriety of the Regency era.
And I hate "smirk". Overused and under-descriptive. Just my personal bug-a-boo.
Again, these are my own thoughts and critiques. Don't let them stop you from reading this lovely novel!! I just have to be true to myself as a reviewer.
I very much look forward to the next book from this author! I think she has a good career ahead of her.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my honest review.
Miss Eleanor Daventry has been a ward of a wealthy man and came into an unexpected inheritance after he passed away. There is a condition on the inheritance though - she must wed in order to gain her property.
Stanford Tunstall is the heir. He learns the entailed land has been willed to Elanor, and, while this is unforeseen, it is not an insurmountable obstacle. He decides they will wed.
However, Stanford cocks it up royally when proposing to Miss Daventry while in his cups. She is insulted, dismayed and hurt by his actions and decides to cut him from her life. This seems to be a good idea in theory but life keeps throwing them together! And while thrown together, they come to learn more of each other and begin to think they may have been hasty in their mutual dislike.
This was an EXTREMELY enjoyable book! I truly did get a feel of the Regency period. There was no modern language, the characters seemed real, the characters followed a more acceptable and proper Regency protocol, the descriptions were lovely and the story flowed well. The characters also were not "in Love" at first sight but rather allowed their feeling to grow naturally.
The bulk of the writing was also quite well done and mostly proper.
The ONLY reasons I did not give this book a 5 star review are because of what I consider to be technical writing issues that may have been missed by the editor. There were too many sentences ending incorrectly with prepositions. For example: "Any idea what he was searching for?" should really be "Any idea of for what he was searching?", or "You'll have someone to enter society with." instead of "You'll have someone with whom to enter society." or "What is there to speak of?" instead of "Of what is there to speak?" or "......other wildlife she had never heard of,....." instead ".....other wildlife of which she had never heard,...." or "Even so," said Lyia, "there's nothing she can accuse you of." which should be "..... there's nothing of which she can accuse you."
When the overall writing is very good, these thing really jump out to me as careless mistakes/overlooks by the editor.
The editor also overlooked the adverb "got". It should have been "gotten", as in "Now that you have returned to England and have 'gotten' (not got) acquainted with the estate,....." etc. HOWEVER, that is the use in American English.
"Gotten is a past tense form of the verb to get. ... The past tense form of get is got; the past participle of got is gotten. A past participle is a word that's used with had, have or has. Therefore, it's perfectly acceptable to use gotten if it's being used with its companion word.Sep 6, 2012"
http://jadevarden.blogspot.com/2012/0...
And wouldn't Ingram call Anna "Miss Tunstall"? Would he be that familiar?
Personally, I feel there is vast overuse of the words "smirk", "smirked", "grin" and "grinned" (as well as some others......) One or two "grins" at the most should do it. There are many other words in that are just as good for facial expressions. I think the "grin" and "grinning" too much are at odds with the propriety of the Regency era.
And I hate "smirk". Overused and under-descriptive. Just my personal bug-a-boo.
Again, these are my own thoughts and critiques. Don't let them stop you from reading this lovely novel!! I just have to be true to myself as a reviewer.
I very much look forward to the next book from this author! I think she has a good career ahead of her.
I received a free copy of this book and am voluntarily leaving my honest review.
October 15, 2023
Audiobook Review:
This is an enjoyable sweet Regency romance. The new Lord Worth continually lands himself in hot water with Eleanor, his late predecessor’s ward by saying embarrassing and insulting things, including a drunken proposal of marriage over some land she inherited, carved off from his new estate. As they spend more time together in London and come to really know one another, both develop stronger feelings. I really like this story. The romance is lovely and gradual. There are many interesting characters, and a sweet secondary romance as well. There is also subplot of intrigue as some of the male characters endeavour to uncover a French spy. The story is interesting and the romance is lovely. It evolves gradually. This is book one in a trilogy and introduces many characters that appear in the other two books, but can be read as a standalone. This is a sweet and clean story with no harsh language.
The narration is good and I liked it overall. The tone and volume were steady and easy to listen to. The narrator has a pleasant voice and varied the voices for the female characters, but there was less variation with the male characters. I did find that there were a few words that the narrator seemed to pronounce oddly. Most prominent for me was “Boney”, referring to Napoleon Boneaparte. I am fairly certain it is pronounced as “bone-ee”, but she said it as “Bonnie”.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
This is an enjoyable sweet Regency romance. The new Lord Worth continually lands himself in hot water with Eleanor, his late predecessor’s ward by saying embarrassing and insulting things, including a drunken proposal of marriage over some land she inherited, carved off from his new estate. As they spend more time together in London and come to really know one another, both develop stronger feelings. I really like this story. The romance is lovely and gradual. There are many interesting characters, and a sweet secondary romance as well. There is also subplot of intrigue as some of the male characters endeavour to uncover a French spy. The story is interesting and the romance is lovely. It evolves gradually. This is book one in a trilogy and introduces many characters that appear in the other two books, but can be read as a standalone. This is a sweet and clean story with no harsh language.
The narration is good and I liked it overall. The tone and volume were steady and easy to listen to. The narrator has a pleasant voice and varied the voices for the female characters, but there was less variation with the male characters. I did find that there were a few words that the narrator seemed to pronounce oddly. Most prominent for me was “Boney”, referring to Napoleon Boneaparte. I am fairly certain it is pronounced as “bone-ee”, but she said it as “Bonnie”.
I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.
September 15, 2022
A Regrettable Proposal: A Regency Romance (Memorable Proposals Book 1)
349 pages
Pros:
◇Closed Door Regency story (clean romance)
◇Well Written
◇The Plot
Cons:
◇Romance is not really the A Plot so I would have said it was a Regency Romance. More like a Regency/ Historical/ Spy genre. Not a con just mis marketing in my opinion.
I would have been alright with zero romance and friendship instead. Wish we would have seen more of the spy 🕵️♂️ 🕵️♀️ Plot. Maybe it's just me 😊
Book Synopsis:
"Orphaned at a young age, Eleanor wants nothing more than to settle in a home of her own. Stratford, having met once with betrayal, desires a woman who will be true. When a complicated inheritance forces them together, they little expect this to be the answer to their innermost desires.
Eleanor Daventry has come into money, but she cannot access her inheritance without a husband. Steadfast and independent, she would rather become a schoolmistress than take a husband she does not love.
Stratford Tunstall has just discovered his predecessor willed the estate’s unentailed land to Miss Daventry. Although cynical regarding love, the man recognizes a practical solution when he sees one. He and Miss Daventry must marry, and Stratford wastes no time in pressing his suit — with disastrous results.
In the face of such an insulting proposal, Eleanor flees to London where she lands unwittingly in the home of Stratford’s closest friends. Now thrown together constantly, Eleanor can't help admiring his masterful apologies, never mind how often he must deliver them. Stratford concedes that, against all his predictions, Eleanor has no shortage of determined suitors."
349 pages
Pros:
◇Closed Door Regency story (clean romance)
◇Well Written
◇The Plot
Cons:
◇Romance is not really the A Plot so I would have said it was a Regency Romance. More like a Regency/ Historical/ Spy genre. Not a con just mis marketing in my opinion.
I would have been alright with zero romance and friendship instead. Wish we would have seen more of the spy 🕵️♂️ 🕵️♀️ Plot. Maybe it's just me 😊
Book Synopsis:
"Orphaned at a young age, Eleanor wants nothing more than to settle in a home of her own. Stratford, having met once with betrayal, desires a woman who will be true. When a complicated inheritance forces them together, they little expect this to be the answer to their innermost desires.
Eleanor Daventry has come into money, but she cannot access her inheritance without a husband. Steadfast and independent, she would rather become a schoolmistress than take a husband she does not love.
Stratford Tunstall has just discovered his predecessor willed the estate’s unentailed land to Miss Daventry. Although cynical regarding love, the man recognizes a practical solution when he sees one. He and Miss Daventry must marry, and Stratford wastes no time in pressing his suit — with disastrous results.
In the face of such an insulting proposal, Eleanor flees to London where she lands unwittingly in the home of Stratford’s closest friends. Now thrown together constantly, Eleanor can't help admiring his masterful apologies, never mind how often he must deliver them. Stratford concedes that, against all his predictions, Eleanor has no shortage of determined suitors."
March 10, 2019
A very enticing and thoroughly enjoyable book. The story was gripping and kept my interest. Statham has "inherited" the earldom from his uncle after the deaths of two in front of him. He has been called back from the war to take this title and gather others for the reading of the will. He is introduced to his uncle's "ward" Eleanor, who was the daughter of his uncle's best friend. As the will is read there is one very big surprise for everyone - Eleanor is given the best piece of property in the estate's holding. However, she must marry to inherit the property and then it becomes her husband's! This story progresses from there as they all go to London to prepare for the season. Eleanor will be staying at the home of her best friend Lydia and Statham will be escorting his twin sisters into society. There are some interesting and multi layered events that take place as the story progresses and you won't be bored reading. Characters range from vindictive to loving with many between. A very clean and enjoyable book, but give yourself time - there are places you don't want to put it down. I did receive an ARC copy of this book. This is my voluntary and honest review with my own personal thoughts and opinions.
Vicki from Wyoming
Vicki from Wyoming
March 13, 2019
This was such a lovely read!! It was relaxing enough to enjoy during my limited "me time" but exciting enough that I could hardly put it down (there were two nights with far too little sleep!). While I'm not necessarily a big romance fan I am a huge historical fiction fan, this had plenty of the latter and just enough of the former. Jennie painted the scenes with her words so well you would think she had been there, she has done an amazing job researching and understanding the setting of her story so that she can help the reader picture it.
Unlike many historical fiction books this one is CLEAN. I would be completely comfortable letting my 13 year old daughter read it. While there are some underlying themes that touch on tough topics there are no scenes in the book that would make a reader blush.
I have been a fan of Jennie's writing for a couple of years, she is a woman of faith and a Christian author. While this book's theme is not specifically religious, it adheres to Christian values and there is an underlying thread of faith throughout. The more obvious themes have to do with honesty, friendship, perseverance, and integrity.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or anyone looking for a good fiction book to enjoy during some down time.
I received an advanced digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Unlike many historical fiction books this one is CLEAN. I would be completely comfortable letting my 13 year old daughter read it. While there are some underlying themes that touch on tough topics there are no scenes in the book that would make a reader blush.
I have been a fan of Jennie's writing for a couple of years, she is a woman of faith and a Christian author. While this book's theme is not specifically religious, it adheres to Christian values and there is an underlying thread of faith throughout. The more obvious themes have to do with honesty, friendship, perseverance, and integrity.
I highly recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or anyone looking for a good fiction book to enjoy during some down time.
I received an advanced digital copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
March 14, 2019
In her latest novel, A Regrettable Proposal, Jennie Goutet serves up the very best of Regency with her signature wit and wisdom, cheek and charm. The author's dialogue and prose are so much fun, the delighted reader might miss her careful attention to detail, but it's there in spades—the period and genre so thoroughly researched as to be its own seamless thread in this meant-to-be romance.
The course of true love, however, never did run smooth; so Eleanor Daventry and Stratford Tunstall face their share of obstacles along the way — some of which they throw in their own path. Luckily, with the assistance of Goutet's colorful cast of side characters, Eleanor and Stratford get more than once chance to find their way to each other in Goutet's happiest-ever-after yet!
Bottom line: I adored this book, I adore that Eleanor wants to marry for love, and that her proposals — regrettable or otherwise — are so completely entertaining. Five stars to Goutet's Regency romance!
The course of true love, however, never did run smooth; so Eleanor Daventry and Stratford Tunstall face their share of obstacles along the way — some of which they throw in their own path. Luckily, with the assistance of Goutet's colorful cast of side characters, Eleanor and Stratford get more than once chance to find their way to each other in Goutet's happiest-ever-after yet!
Bottom line: I adored this book, I adore that Eleanor wants to marry for love, and that her proposals — regrettable or otherwise — are so completely entertaining. Five stars to Goutet's Regency romance!
May 11, 2024
This book was a hard review. There were several romantic scenes that made me keep reading but there were also moments where I wanted to throw the book against a wall (metaphorically, since I was reading on kindle). It really bothered me that the guy was just waiting for his turn. He knew he loved her about 60% into the book and yet he waited for TWO men to court and propose to her and then STILL didn’t immediately tell her how he felt. That being said it was cute to see him switch to flirting and such once he did decide to “court” her. Also, the book felt like an idea that the writer wasn’t sure how to make into a whole book. The mystery felt like a half done side story. And even the romance felt like it was 40% of them just waiting for the other to show their feelings. Anyways, the above rant makes it seem like I didn’t enjoy the book but I did. The romance scenes that were there were very good so I give this book a ✨3.75✨
March 11, 2019
Having enjoyed this author's modern romances, I was excited to read this since I generally prefer books set in a historical period. I was not disappointed. The period details were well done, and I was able to lose myself in Regency London.
Just as important, the characters were well written. The hero and heroine were likeable but not perfect. Stratford was honorable but not so good at expressing himself. Eleanor was spirited but a bit naive. The secondary characters were well done too, and I'd love to see Phoebe, Anna, and Frederick again in the future. As for the antagonists, there were a couple of characters I disliked or even despised, but they still felt real.
The ending was sweet and romantic. I wouldn't have minded if it had been a bit longer.
I'm really happy I got to read and review an early copy of this book. I look forward to reading more by this author.
Just as important, the characters were well written. The hero and heroine were likeable but not perfect. Stratford was honorable but not so good at expressing himself. Eleanor was spirited but a bit naive. The secondary characters were well done too, and I'd love to see Phoebe, Anna, and Frederick again in the future. As for the antagonists, there were a couple of characters I disliked or even despised, but they still felt real.
The ending was sweet and romantic. I wouldn't have minded if it had been a bit longer.
I'm really happy I got to read and review an early copy of this book. I look forward to reading more by this author.
January 23, 2023
Nice story
Eleanor is an orphan under the guardianship of the elderly Earl who pays for her education. Upon his death she inherited enough money for a season in London and a large piece of property once she marries. The new Earl, drunkenly proposed and was turned down because she's only going to marry for love. In London staying with her best friend, the Earl attempts to change her mind about him while they deal with other suitors, gossips, and French spies.
This writer obviously has read Pride And Prejudice because her story is riddled with " tolerable ", an Army office named Fitzwilliam ( Major not a Colonel though), Georgiana, Lydia, a trouble making redheaded woman who wants to be the next Countess ( clone of Caroline Bingley) a gentleman stalking the walls of the balls, and the unpopular desire to only marry for love.
Eleanor is an orphan under the guardianship of the elderly Earl who pays for her education. Upon his death she inherited enough money for a season in London and a large piece of property once she marries. The new Earl, drunkenly proposed and was turned down because she's only going to marry for love. In London staying with her best friend, the Earl attempts to change her mind about him while they deal with other suitors, gossips, and French spies.
This writer obviously has read Pride And Prejudice because her story is riddled with " tolerable ", an Army office named Fitzwilliam ( Major not a Colonel though), Georgiana, Lydia, a trouble making redheaded woman who wants to be the next Countess ( clone of Caroline Bingley) a gentleman stalking the walls of the balls, and the unpopular desire to only marry for love.
March 2, 2019
I found the story so intriguing, could not put the book down. A real page Turner. The Regency period is very well displayed throughout. I loved the way the plot, upon plot of the story draws you in. It feels like I am living the story. I would recommend this story to anyone who loves romance and / or Regency stories. I have read many authors before and found her one of the best writers. I am not big on romance stories, though I have read Pride and prejudice, also Sense and sensibility. Yet , I loved reading this story and was drawn in by it.
March 10, 2019
As I am a great fan of Regency novels, I could not wait to read A regrettable proposal.
I have found all the ingredients which I enjoy in such books : the love intrigue, but also the spy plot, as well as all the inevitable events of the London Season!
I have found the male characters particulary well chiseled. Usually in such novels the light is more on the female hero character. Here although we follow Eleanore's way of thoughts, a great focus is on Stratford and his male friends as well.
Stratford is so irresistible with his blunders but also his greatness of character and loyalty.
I have really enjoyed it!
I have found all the ingredients which I enjoy in such books : the love intrigue, but also the spy plot, as well as all the inevitable events of the London Season!
I have found the male characters particulary well chiseled. Usually in such novels the light is more on the female hero character. Here although we follow Eleanore's way of thoughts, a great focus is on Stratford and his male friends as well.
Stratford is so irresistible with his blunders but also his greatness of character and loyalty.
I have really enjoyed it!
March 12, 2019
There's quite a bit in this regency romance!
It's got humor and intrigue mixed with the oh-so-sweet romance.
All of the characters were well written, and the dialog and narrative are written in keeping with the setting.
The main characters were wonderful. Oh! Stratford keeps vacillating between rude and charming at every meeting! You know he's going to fall for Eleanor, even if it's against his will! I love that Eleanor is described as no great beauty to start, but before the end her beauty is seen in her personality.
This is my voluntary review of an Advance Reader Copy of this book.
It's got humor and intrigue mixed with the oh-so-sweet romance.
All of the characters were well written, and the dialog and narrative are written in keeping with the setting.
The main characters were wonderful. Oh! Stratford keeps vacillating between rude and charming at every meeting! You know he's going to fall for Eleanor, even if it's against his will! I love that Eleanor is described as no great beauty to start, but before the end her beauty is seen in her personality.
This is my voluntary review of an Advance Reader Copy of this book.
March 15, 2022
It wasn't bad, per se, and i did finish it, but nothing really enchanted me here and although i like eleanor and stratford, they were the least interesting of the group. might skip 2 and go straight for phoebe/fred because i do feel a little invested in the two of them
full review on spinebreaker
full review on spinebreaker
March 2, 2019
Was like taking a step back in time. This author writes very much like Georgette Heyer, which in my opinion is a good thing.
This is a story about how first impression can not be counted on and how with time a friendship can be formed that will lead to so much more. But will a scandal tear them apart.
I received this as an arc and I am giving my honest review voluntarily
This is a story about how first impression can not be counted on and how with time a friendship can be formed that will lead to so much more. But will a scandal tear them apart.
I received this as an arc and I am giving my honest review voluntarily
Displaying 1 - 30 of 312 reviews