What do you think?
Rate this book
O’Donovan Family #1
In Name Only
1876, Philadelphia. Caroline Martin's life has finally taken a turn for the better. After years of hard work, she has met a virtuous and wealthy man whose love seems to promise the kind of life realized only within the comforting novels she keeps on her night table. Tragedy, however, will teach Caroline of the complexity with which God Himself authors the lives of those who turn towards Him. Gold Medal Winner in Religious Fiction, 2010 IPPY Awards. Amazon Kindle Bestseller. The author is currently working on a sequel to "In Name Only" entitled "A Subtle Grace." “If you love romance but hate smut, pick up this beautiful story and let it carry you away. The characters are believable, layered, human and humorous even in the midst of tragedy. The reader never loses hope and is rewarded on every page with little gems of character behavior, dialogue, plot twists and romantic intrigue. I was so very sorry when it ended!" Lisa Mladinich, writer, novelist “All in all, a pleasant summer read...I enjoyed it, and I'll be passing it around to the fellow readers in my life..” Sarah Reinhard, author “ ...conveys the beautiful Catholic teachings on conjugal love, and shares both a pro-life story and a conversion story.” Jean Heimann, Catholic Fire “There are so many things I love about this book. The book is a very enjoyable read, neither predictable nor formulaic.” Elizabeth Kathryn Gerold-Miller “Searching for a page-turning historical Catholic novel? ‘In Name Only’ by Ellen Gable is one book you won't want to put down until you finally reach its satisfying conclusion.” Anne Faye, author, “Through the Open Window”
406 pages, Kindle Edition
First published June 1, 2009
189 people are currently reading
997 people want to read
About the author
Ellen Gable
34 books147 followersEllen Gable (Hrkach) is an award-winning, bestselling author of thirteen books, contributor to numerous others, ghostwriter of five books, and publisher/editor of 60 other books. Her newest book, Life From the Bottom Shelf, is a humorous look at being short. Her novel, Where Angels Pass, was #1 in New Releases on Amazon.ca. for two days and won first place in Religious Fiction in the 2022 CMA Book Awards. Four of her other books have also won literary awards. She and her husband, James Hrkach, are the parents of five adult sons, three beautiful daughters-in-law, and grandparents to four precious and entertaining grandchildren. Her books are available in several languages and on Audible. When not writing, Ellen enjoys watching classic movies, reading, researching her family tree, and playing board games with her family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews
October 1, 2011
I enjoy historical fiction, especially those that are romances. However, I have been hard pressed to find one that isn't full of imagery I would rather not be exposed to. With her novel In Name Only, Ellen Gable satisfied all my needs. This story is a true romance, wonderfully written and set in the Victorian time period.
Ellen tackles some difficult subjects with finesse. While the novel's main character is Caroline Martin, an orphan who goes to live with a wealthy uncle in Philadelphia, it is also about the O'Donovan brothers; Liam and David. Liam is a virtuous sort and David is the exact opposite. I was impressed with the skill Ellen displayed in painting a picture of David's sordid life without corrupting her own novel.
The unpredictable plot, the incredibly romantic scenes and the historical time period make this a very satisfying read. I hope Ellen will consider writing a sequel.
Ellen tackles some difficult subjects with finesse. While the novel's main character is Caroline Martin, an orphan who goes to live with a wealthy uncle in Philadelphia, it is also about the O'Donovan brothers; Liam and David. Liam is a virtuous sort and David is the exact opposite. I was impressed with the skill Ellen displayed in painting a picture of David's sordid life without corrupting her own novel.
The unpredictable plot, the incredibly romantic scenes and the historical time period make this a very satisfying read. I hope Ellen will consider writing a sequel.
June 20, 2015
2.5 stars, extra 1/2 star given because of the people who gave it lows stars because is was too "Catholic."
I came upon this book years ago and tried several times to read it. I never could get past the first chapter, but I recently came upon it again while reading an article about Catholic doctrine, specifically NFP, sacramental marriage, abortion, etc. The author article mentioned this book was a nice way to teach doctrine without resorting to dry lectures and handouts. I decided to read the book, no matter how long it took me, as I am a RCIA sponsor.
It was okay. I really, really, really wanted to love this book, but I'm not a clean romance/historical fiction fan.
The novel is set in Philadelphia during the post Civil War Victorian era, approximately 1876-1886. Caroline Martin is an adult orphan who is sent to live with her not-quite-estranged uncle and cousin. There is no animosity between the parties, but a fight between Caroline's father and her grandfather when he married someone beneath his station resulted in "sorry dad's a jerk/trying to stay out of it/NBD I don't need your money anyway" type of relationship.
Caroline meets the O'Donovan brothers when she arrives in Philadelphia. Liam is fair and good, David is dark and bad. Caroline immediately falls for Liam, the safe bet. David is far more interesting, even if he can't keep his pants on for most of the book.
Caroline, and her relationship with the brothers, is the center from which the rest of the plot extends.
Lots of people die, lots of sad of things happen, lots of forgiveness required. The ability to move on, understand, and forgive reflect the character's faith in God. Several reviewers complained about the amount of death. Of all the deaths in the story, I can think of only one that didn't serve to move the plot forward.
The writing was fair, though choppy in parts. There were some issues with the passage of time; months or years go by in the space of a paragraph. Overall, the transitions were the most troubling. The use of imagery was good, especially in the more dramatic scenes. The dialogue needed a heavy editing hand. It often felt stilted and unnatural, and that's allowing for Victorian usage.
And now, the diabolical Catholic doctrine that many people didn't see coming.
"I wish I would have known earlier this was a Catholic book."
"There are so many other religious books out there that aren't Catholic."
"A Kindle freebie... glad it was free. I don't think I realized this was fiction from a Catholic standpoint until I was halfway through it."
"I am a Christian, but not Catholic. I felt like this author was pushing her own personal religious agenda on the reader, so I stopped in the middle."
"...too much emphasis on the Catholic Church..."
And so on. To dislike a book because of the religious beliefs of a character is thinly veiled discrimination. Let me tell you what those blood-drinking, Mary-worshipping, knickle dragging Catholics believe, according to this book.
1. Don't drink yourself into oblivion.
2. Don't be consumed with material possessions.
3. Treat people kindly, ignore stations or levels of status.
4. Don't use women as sexual play things.
5. If you get a girl pregnant, accept responsibility.
6. If you are young and find yourself pregnant and can not keep the baby, consider adoption.
7. Don't cheat on your wife.
8. If you cheat on your wife, accept responsibility.
9. Ask for forgiveness from God and anyone you have wronged.
10. Do not live with a heavy, angry heart. Forgive, though it may not come easily. Be prepared for forgiveness to take years.
Catholics, as you can see, are not to be trusted.
I wonder if these reviews are written by the same people who love to read Amish romance. Main character can't use a phone and for the most part stop formal schooling at age 15 = okay. Main character makes the sign of the cross and goes to confession = "rather unbelievable, and too much Catholic stuff as well."
I came upon this book years ago and tried several times to read it. I never could get past the first chapter, but I recently came upon it again while reading an article about Catholic doctrine, specifically NFP, sacramental marriage, abortion, etc. The author article mentioned this book was a nice way to teach doctrine without resorting to dry lectures and handouts. I decided to read the book, no matter how long it took me, as I am a RCIA sponsor.
It was okay. I really, really, really wanted to love this book, but I'm not a clean romance/historical fiction fan.
The novel is set in Philadelphia during the post Civil War Victorian era, approximately 1876-1886. Caroline Martin is an adult orphan who is sent to live with her not-quite-estranged uncle and cousin. There is no animosity between the parties, but a fight between Caroline's father and her grandfather when he married someone beneath his station resulted in "sorry dad's a jerk/trying to stay out of it/NBD I don't need your money anyway" type of relationship.
Caroline meets the O'Donovan brothers when she arrives in Philadelphia. Liam is fair and good, David is dark and bad. Caroline immediately falls for Liam, the safe bet. David is far more interesting, even if he can't keep his pants on for most of the book.
Caroline, and her relationship with the brothers, is the center from which the rest of the plot extends.
Lots of people die, lots of sad of things happen, lots of forgiveness required. The ability to move on, understand, and forgive reflect the character's faith in God. Several reviewers complained about the amount of death. Of all the deaths in the story, I can think of only one that didn't serve to move the plot forward.
The writing was fair, though choppy in parts. There were some issues with the passage of time; months or years go by in the space of a paragraph. Overall, the transitions were the most troubling. The use of imagery was good, especially in the more dramatic scenes. The dialogue needed a heavy editing hand. It often felt stilted and unnatural, and that's allowing for Victorian usage.
And now, the diabolical Catholic doctrine that many people didn't see coming.
"I wish I would have known earlier this was a Catholic book."
"There are so many other religious books out there that aren't Catholic."
"A Kindle freebie... glad it was free. I don't think I realized this was fiction from a Catholic standpoint until I was halfway through it."
"I am a Christian, but not Catholic. I felt like this author was pushing her own personal religious agenda on the reader, so I stopped in the middle."
"...too much emphasis on the Catholic Church..."
And so on. To dislike a book because of the religious beliefs of a character is thinly veiled discrimination. Let me tell you what those blood-drinking, Mary-worshipping, knickle dragging Catholics believe, according to this book.
1. Don't drink yourself into oblivion.
2. Don't be consumed with material possessions.
3. Treat people kindly, ignore stations or levels of status.
4. Don't use women as sexual play things.
5. If you get a girl pregnant, accept responsibility.
6. If you are young and find yourself pregnant and can not keep the baby, consider adoption.
7. Don't cheat on your wife.
8. If you cheat on your wife, accept responsibility.
9. Ask for forgiveness from God and anyone you have wronged.
10. Do not live with a heavy, angry heart. Forgive, though it may not come easily. Be prepared for forgiveness to take years.
Catholics, as you can see, are not to be trusted.
I wonder if these reviews are written by the same people who love to read Amish romance. Main character can't use a phone and for the most part stop formal schooling at age 15 = okay. Main character makes the sign of the cross and goes to confession = "rather unbelievable, and too much Catholic stuff as well."
April 23, 2012
It is certainly tempting to look around at our world and lament simpler days gone by. We find ourselves surrounded by violence, sexual immorality, abortion, addiction…in short all of those things that we pray may never affect our children.
As one begins reading IN NAME ONLY, set in post-Civil War America in the late 1800’s, the cares and travails of today’s world rapidly melt away into a time when men were gentlemen and ladies were, well, just that. In fact it is easy to imagine that Gable’s skillful portrayal of the period may result in little more than a pleasant frolic in Victorian era life, complete with afternoon tea, parasol, top hat and cane. The author, however, quickly transports the reader from the innocuous vignette of a Hallmark card into the timeless struggle of the human soul. Herein lays the main appeal of the book, as we suddenly are reminded that vice was no less prevalent in 1876 AD, or indeed in 1876 BC, than it is today.
The comfortable love story involves a beautiful late adolescent woman and a nearly perfect, wealthy young man. The heroine, Caroline must also deal with her suitor’s brother, David, who is a womanizing, gambling, drunkard. He is a vile man, irreverent and antithetical to his brother. Largely through this character, Gable explores the economic reality of 19th century class distinction in the relationship between her main characters and the supporting cast, most of whom are domestic servants.
Caroline’s perspective is reflective of the ethos of the period, driven more by her innocence than by a religious point of view. Yet, here is where the writer skillfully begins a subtle exploration of Christian principles. By the time the reader realizes that the book is profoundly Catholic the catechesis has been so plausible and logical that the debate is over before it starts. This, I believe, is Gable’s intention and the real genius of the book. She masterfully covers most of the flashpoints in Catholic theological debates of our day, simply by reminding us that these issues are timeless. Men riding in carriages and wearing waistcoats had affairs. Women in petticoats got abortions. Alcoholism and pornography existed 130 years ago, as they do today. Yet, these sordid scenarios are tastefully presented in order to cry out for the same solutions then as they do today and will a thousand years from now: contrition, firm amendment, and the Grace of Redemption.
The author skillfully presents the alternatives of a life well lived as opposed to one filled with the banal debauchery of the wounded human spirit. She does so in a well-crafted, fast moving, period piece that is both authentic and moving. Gable’s characters are believable and well integrated into the plot stream. The dialogue is excellent and appropriate to the diverse social station of the cast, and the writing, of course, is what we expect from Ellen Gable, excellent.
I highly recommend this book as an exciting, easy read. The benefits are literary, historical and spiritual.
As one begins reading IN NAME ONLY, set in post-Civil War America in the late 1800’s, the cares and travails of today’s world rapidly melt away into a time when men were gentlemen and ladies were, well, just that. In fact it is easy to imagine that Gable’s skillful portrayal of the period may result in little more than a pleasant frolic in Victorian era life, complete with afternoon tea, parasol, top hat and cane. The author, however, quickly transports the reader from the innocuous vignette of a Hallmark card into the timeless struggle of the human soul. Herein lays the main appeal of the book, as we suddenly are reminded that vice was no less prevalent in 1876 AD, or indeed in 1876 BC, than it is today.
The comfortable love story involves a beautiful late adolescent woman and a nearly perfect, wealthy young man. The heroine, Caroline must also deal with her suitor’s brother, David, who is a womanizing, gambling, drunkard. He is a vile man, irreverent and antithetical to his brother. Largely through this character, Gable explores the economic reality of 19th century class distinction in the relationship between her main characters and the supporting cast, most of whom are domestic servants.
Caroline’s perspective is reflective of the ethos of the period, driven more by her innocence than by a religious point of view. Yet, here is where the writer skillfully begins a subtle exploration of Christian principles. By the time the reader realizes that the book is profoundly Catholic the catechesis has been so plausible and logical that the debate is over before it starts. This, I believe, is Gable’s intention and the real genius of the book. She masterfully covers most of the flashpoints in Catholic theological debates of our day, simply by reminding us that these issues are timeless. Men riding in carriages and wearing waistcoats had affairs. Women in petticoats got abortions. Alcoholism and pornography existed 130 years ago, as they do today. Yet, these sordid scenarios are tastefully presented in order to cry out for the same solutions then as they do today and will a thousand years from now: contrition, firm amendment, and the Grace of Redemption.
The author skillfully presents the alternatives of a life well lived as opposed to one filled with the banal debauchery of the wounded human spirit. She does so in a well-crafted, fast moving, period piece that is both authentic and moving. Gable’s characters are believable and well integrated into the plot stream. The dialogue is excellent and appropriate to the diverse social station of the cast, and the writing, of course, is what we expect from Ellen Gable, excellent.
I highly recommend this book as an exciting, easy read. The benefits are literary, historical and spiritual.
February 23, 2014
I wanted to like this book because I feel like Christ can change a heart, a life, a relationship......but there was too much emphasis on the Catholic Church. It's not the church but Christ that is the answer. Having said that, I felt character development was lacking and writing predictable and slow.
April 29, 2012
First, I will start off by saying that I am male and that I do not tend to gravitate towards romance, romantic comedy or anything in that same vein. Sure, I went through that stage when I was dating in which I watched romantic comedies for the sake of my then girlfriend, now wife and occasionally I still will at her request. However, on the whole I find the genre contrived, predictable and as painting unrealistic pictures of love, marriage and sensuality. In Name Only is none of those things.
In Name Only presents a real-life Christian view on marriage, relationships and the difficulties people experience in them. It does not gloss over the characters' faults as people and clearly does not adhere to the cliché of being “in love” as the centrality of a marriage. In fact, the book explores what can happen when two people who aren't “in love” are married.
I will take this opportunity to state that, being a romance novel, one expects that there will be some sensual/sexual activity in the book. However, the way in which it is approached within In Name Only is a breath of fresh air. The sexual scenes within the book are descriptive enough to inspire the passions of the reader but, are not so descriptive as to be pornographic, which is the level to which many romance novels stoop. The book also goes a step further in making a clear point to illustrate the TRUE meaning and purpose of sexuality and also the abuse of this gift and what fruits both can reap.
The imagery in the book was outstanding. The author has a great way of describing everything from clothing to emotion. However, the descriptions are not over-done and do not take away from the story.
The characters are well developed and the reader can clearly see the full dimensions of all of them. The book is also well-researched in terms of the time period in which it takes place and the culture of that time.
The only issues that I personally had with the book, was how the passage of time was handled. It seemed at one moment a child was say, 10 months old and then a chapter or two later the child is 3 or 4 years old. The other issue I had was that I felt the ending of the story itself was a bit abrupt, considering the events that occurred before it. However, the epilogue does fill in some of the gaps.
In summary, In Name Only is probably the best romantically involved novel that I have ever read. I couldn't afford to put the book down for very long and read it in 3 days, including reading until midnight to complete it. I could truly see parts of myself in some of the characters and could associate with their plight. I can't highly recommend this book enough, especially for Christian/Catholic readers However, that isn't to say that someone who isn't of faith wouldn't enjoy this story as well.
In Name Only presents a real-life Christian view on marriage, relationships and the difficulties people experience in them. It does not gloss over the characters' faults as people and clearly does not adhere to the cliché of being “in love” as the centrality of a marriage. In fact, the book explores what can happen when two people who aren't “in love” are married.
I will take this opportunity to state that, being a romance novel, one expects that there will be some sensual/sexual activity in the book. However, the way in which it is approached within In Name Only is a breath of fresh air. The sexual scenes within the book are descriptive enough to inspire the passions of the reader but, are not so descriptive as to be pornographic, which is the level to which many romance novels stoop. The book also goes a step further in making a clear point to illustrate the TRUE meaning and purpose of sexuality and also the abuse of this gift and what fruits both can reap.
The imagery in the book was outstanding. The author has a great way of describing everything from clothing to emotion. However, the descriptions are not over-done and do not take away from the story.
The characters are well developed and the reader can clearly see the full dimensions of all of them. The book is also well-researched in terms of the time period in which it takes place and the culture of that time.
The only issues that I personally had with the book, was how the passage of time was handled. It seemed at one moment a child was say, 10 months old and then a chapter or two later the child is 3 or 4 years old. The other issue I had was that I felt the ending of the story itself was a bit abrupt, considering the events that occurred before it. However, the epilogue does fill in some of the gaps.
In summary, In Name Only is probably the best romantically involved novel that I have ever read. I couldn't afford to put the book down for very long and read it in 3 days, including reading until midnight to complete it. I could truly see parts of myself in some of the characters and could associate with their plight. I can't highly recommend this book enough, especially for Christian/Catholic readers However, that isn't to say that someone who isn't of faith wouldn't enjoy this story as well.
June 12, 2013
feminine, romance, intense
The Good: profound Catholic content; an intense story; a gripping romance
The Bad: lots of death to handle; climax of the story occurs much earlier than is typical
Characters:
The characters aren't particularly colorful, but they are outstandingly human. Gable is somehow able to grow the characters organically as they mature in response to traumatic, life-changing events. In addition to this, you absolutely become emotionally invested in them.
Plot:
The book starts out in 19th century Philadelphia, and based on the initial impression of the characters and the story, it seems like it's setting out to be a Jane Austen copycat. How wrong this is! The book is filled with big plot twists and relentless turmoil, strife, and emotion that will force you to finish the book as quickly as humanly possible.
There is one linear plot progression, which ends relatively early, at the halfway point of the book. This is because it's Gable intention to imply that in life, there is no "happily ever after." So the story continues with Gable using a random assortment of disease, miscarriage, and death to advance the plot. Fortunately, Gable has such a way with words, that these random events totally keep you engrossed in the story.
Death is a permanent part of life, and being such, it's continually a nuisance in the story, with around ten deaths in total that are significantly mourned. Despite this, the emergence and growth of the Catholic faith within the characters allows the mood of the story to overcome the stench of death, as the characters trudge on, with love and faith guiding their way.
Style:
There is a surprising amount of content on "the marital act," especially considering that this is a work of Catholic fiction. Gable is neither crude nor lewd in this area, as she handles the topic very gently albeit in-depth. She also does a fantastic job covering the gamut of Catholic social teaching on sex, as well as the mentality that Catholics should have. This entire area is where Gable's catholicity really shines.
There are three lasting elements of the novel that have serious staying power: its discussion on the marital act, its illustration of the fragility of life, and lastly, the romance of the story itself. Ms. Gable accomplishes what every Catholic fiction writer should seek to accomplish: a story with Catholicism seamlessly woven into it that is good enough to compete with all fiction, not just in the small Catholic fiction book market.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 10, 2011
In 1876, nineteen year old Caroline Martin journeys to Philadelphia to live with her uncle and cousin after the death of her beloved father, whom she has taken care of for many years. Uncomfortable in her new surroundings because of her own modest background, but welcomed by her wealthy uncle, she settles into her new life and is soon courted by her kind and upstanding neighbor, Liam O’Donovan, as well as frustrated by the presence of his vice-ridden, womanizing brother, David. Despite her concerns over Liam’s wealth and their differing views on some subjects because of it, Caroline finds happiness when she becomes Liam’s wife. But when a terrible tragedy strikes, she finds herself forced into having the relationship she never wanted with the troubled and troubling David.
In her second novel, author Ellen Gable has crafted another beautiful historical romance which examines difficult issues faced by people in every age. While her exceptional attention to historical detail allows the reader to feel immersed in the story’s post-Civil War era, the challenges the characters must deal with – lust, adultery, abortion, class and gender prejudice – all are still very real and relevant to a modern audience. Handled with amazing sensitivity, In Name Only is not simply a novel about one man’s redemption from the addictions that plague him, but a story about how love can change us all if we let it. Through the evolving relationship between Caroline and David, it shows not only how love makes us want to be a better person for the beloved, but also how love as an act of the will, rather than simply an emotion, can open us to the truest, most precious type of all – the kind that sees and sympathizes with the pain and struggle in others and allows us to recognize that these human weaknesses are not so different from our own.
Although this is an outstanding Catholic novel which celebrates the Christian ideals of charity, forgiveness, faith, redemption and the sanctity of life, I highly recommend it to anyone who cherishes a wonderfully well-written story featuring complex and superbly-developed characters, whose challenges are universal – above all the one that calls us to love another truly, not in spite of human frailty, but in it.
In her second novel, author Ellen Gable has crafted another beautiful historical romance which examines difficult issues faced by people in every age. While her exceptional attention to historical detail allows the reader to feel immersed in the story’s post-Civil War era, the challenges the characters must deal with – lust, adultery, abortion, class and gender prejudice – all are still very real and relevant to a modern audience. Handled with amazing sensitivity, In Name Only is not simply a novel about one man’s redemption from the addictions that plague him, but a story about how love can change us all if we let it. Through the evolving relationship between Caroline and David, it shows not only how love makes us want to be a better person for the beloved, but also how love as an act of the will, rather than simply an emotion, can open us to the truest, most precious type of all – the kind that sees and sympathizes with the pain and struggle in others and allows us to recognize that these human weaknesses are not so different from our own.
Although this is an outstanding Catholic novel which celebrates the Christian ideals of charity, forgiveness, faith, redemption and the sanctity of life, I highly recommend it to anyone who cherishes a wonderfully well-written story featuring complex and superbly-developed characters, whose challenges are universal – above all the one that calls us to love another truly, not in spite of human frailty, but in it.
December 21, 2012
A Kindle freebie... glad it was free. I don't think I realized this was fiction from a Catholic standpoint until I was halfway through it. So many better "religious fiction" choices out there than this one... the writing fell flat on so many levels, the characters were not rounded out, and the dialogue was so unbelievable (even for 1870's upper class people). A good idea: an orphaned 19-year-old who comes to live with her rich uncle & cousin, marries a next door neighbor, then has to navigate through a relationship-shattering plot twist - (don't want to say more because it would give away what plot there is). The execution of the idea, though, was very flat... for me, not the page turner those lovely reviewers on Amazon claim it is!
March 8, 2012
I like to read faith-based fiction and this book looked interesting. The writing was a little above average and did keep my interest until about half way through. However, I started to get weary of the story and the over use of Catholic references. I am a Christian, but not Catholic. I felt like this author was pushing her own personal religious agenda on the reader, so I stopped in the middle. It was disappointing because the story line was solid except for a couple of Biblical fact errors. I wanted to read a sweet, Christian romance, but for me this book fell short. It is safe to say I will not read other books by this author.
February 20, 2016
Wonderful christian love story. I had a hard time putting this book down. I enjoyed the setting. Great story on how people can change their bad ways by coming to know and trust in God.
May 26, 2016
n her second novel In Name Only, author/editor Ellen Gable Hrkach creates a masterfully complex late eighteen hundreds setting ripe for drama, suspense, and intrigue. The characters are richly described and deeply developed. The complete conversion in thought, word, and deed of two of the main characters is very moving. I can easily see why In Name Only won the Gold Medal in Religious Fiction in the 2010 Independent Publisher Book Awards and has been in the top ten of its category on Amazon Kindle since February 2012, usually in the top five.
The leading lady, Caroline, finds herself in a number of difficult, quite distressing situations which eventually lead her to a period in her life where things are looking up. She meets and falls in love with a respectable man and finds hope in the future of their relationship and lives together. Tragedy strikes but the opportunity for true love, passion, marital bliss, and a more profound hope based on God isn’t lost forever.
One thing that really blew me away about this novel was the powerful, extremely real descriptions of the physical, emotional, and spiritual devastation of losing a loved one. I have never experienced the particular type of loss dealt with in this novel, but it is one that I have often thought would be one of the most difficult to live through and move beyond. This is one of the few books where this topic is treated on such an intimate level that the reader can tangibly identify the pain and suffering involved, even if she has not experienced the same tragedy.
This novel proves that wild hearts can not only be broken, but also converted, and completely transformed. The relational, psychological, and spiritual intricacies of the main characters are explored in tremendous depth, which makes this book hard to put down. The moral struggles and questions that the characters grapple with are fascinating and some of them very unexpected.
One ladies’ man goes from being completely driven by and acting out based on pleasure and pride, to learning to live out of compassion, humility, and love. Find out what it takes to turn this reckless rake into a true gentleman.
Of course, even post paradigm-shift, the main man still has some haunting memories and some sins from the past that have a major impact on his present, not a devastating, damning one, but one that becomes redemptive in nature. Through the grace of God, the admission of truth and previous lies, and a selfless love for others, healing happens in realistically miraculous ways.
The messiness and confusion suggestive of real life relationships, the true transformation the Lord offers, and God’s ability to bring about good from even the most devastating circumstances are what make this novel such a compelling read. Temptation, sin, morality, and virtue are all weighed in the balance on a spellbinding level that captures the depths of despair and the heights of hope.
I highly recommend In Name Only.
The leading lady, Caroline, finds herself in a number of difficult, quite distressing situations which eventually lead her to a period in her life where things are looking up. She meets and falls in love with a respectable man and finds hope in the future of their relationship and lives together. Tragedy strikes but the opportunity for true love, passion, marital bliss, and a more profound hope based on God isn’t lost forever.
One thing that really blew me away about this novel was the powerful, extremely real descriptions of the physical, emotional, and spiritual devastation of losing a loved one. I have never experienced the particular type of loss dealt with in this novel, but it is one that I have often thought would be one of the most difficult to live through and move beyond. This is one of the few books where this topic is treated on such an intimate level that the reader can tangibly identify the pain and suffering involved, even if she has not experienced the same tragedy.
This novel proves that wild hearts can not only be broken, but also converted, and completely transformed. The relational, psychological, and spiritual intricacies of the main characters are explored in tremendous depth, which makes this book hard to put down. The moral struggles and questions that the characters grapple with are fascinating and some of them very unexpected.
One ladies’ man goes from being completely driven by and acting out based on pleasure and pride, to learning to live out of compassion, humility, and love. Find out what it takes to turn this reckless rake into a true gentleman.
Of course, even post paradigm-shift, the main man still has some haunting memories and some sins from the past that have a major impact on his present, not a devastating, damning one, but one that becomes redemptive in nature. Through the grace of God, the admission of truth and previous lies, and a selfless love for others, healing happens in realistically miraculous ways.
The messiness and confusion suggestive of real life relationships, the true transformation the Lord offers, and God’s ability to bring about good from even the most devastating circumstances are what make this novel such a compelling read. Temptation, sin, morality, and virtue are all weighed in the balance on a spellbinding level that captures the depths of despair and the heights of hope.
I highly recommend In Name Only.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 14, 2011
I was asked to review the novel " In Name Only" by the author Ellen Gable on my Kindle.This is a historical romance novel set in the 1800's. Nineteen year old Caroline Martin journeys to Philadelphia to live with her uncle and cousin after the death of her beloved father, whom she has taken care of for many years. Uncomfortable in her new surroundings because of her own modest background, but welcomed by her wealthy uncle, she settles into her new life and is soon courted by her kind and upstanding neighbor, Liam O’Donovan, as well as frustrated by the presence of his vice-ridden, womanizing brother, David. Despite her concerns over Liam’s wealth and their differing views on some subjects because of it, Caroline finds happiness when she becomes Liam’s wife. But when a terrible tragedy strikes, she finds herself forced into having the relationship she never wanted with the troubled and troubling David.
In her second novel, author Ellen Gable has crafted another beautiful historical romance which examines difficult issues faced by people in every age. While her exceptional attention to historical detail allows the reader to feel immersed in the story’s post-Civil War era, the challenges the characters must deal with – lust, adultery, abortion, class and gender prejudice – all are still very real and relevant to a modern audience. Handled with amazing sensitivity, In Name Only is not simply a novel about one man’s redemption from the addictions that plague him, but a story about how love can change us all if we let it.
Reading this book was like a moment frozen in time.It was well written, and for a moment I had a glimpse of what it was like to live in those times.An enjoyable read.
In her second novel, author Ellen Gable has crafted another beautiful historical romance which examines difficult issues faced by people in every age. While her exceptional attention to historical detail allows the reader to feel immersed in the story’s post-Civil War era, the challenges the characters must deal with – lust, adultery, abortion, class and gender prejudice – all are still very real and relevant to a modern audience. Handled with amazing sensitivity, In Name Only is not simply a novel about one man’s redemption from the addictions that plague him, but a story about how love can change us all if we let it.
Reading this book was like a moment frozen in time.It was well written, and for a moment I had a glimpse of what it was like to live in those times.An enjoyable read.
August 21, 2009
In Name Only is set in the late 1800’s in Pennsylvania. Recently orphaned Caroline finds herself living with her uncle and cousin, and a romance blossoms. Throughout the book, Caroline struggles with a variety of hurdles and challenges, and in the midst of appreciating the writing, I also was reminded that this house I live in was built in about that time period.
It’s easy for me to forget how different life is in 2009 than it was in 1878. It’s so much more comfortable here, but I couldn’t help but notice how much less reading I do than Caroline did. Granted, we have very different lives and responsibilities, but it was a welcome reminder to me, a chance to explore my own priorities through the lens of something other than a griping voice in the back of my head.
I was impressed by how Gable kept the lurid details from being the focus. There were some opportunities when she could have -- and probably would have, if she had been a different kind of writer -- shared too much. But she didn’t, and the book is better for it. I won’t say too much more, because I hate spoilers in reviews.
All in all, a pleasant summer read, and a nice example of an author growing in her work. With this novel, Gable’s writing matured and that the plot well-defined. I enjoyed it, and I’ll be passing it around to the fellow readers in my life or encouraging them to get their own copy.
It’s easy for me to forget how different life is in 2009 than it was in 1878. It’s so much more comfortable here, but I couldn’t help but notice how much less reading I do than Caroline did. Granted, we have very different lives and responsibilities, but it was a welcome reminder to me, a chance to explore my own priorities through the lens of something other than a griping voice in the back of my head.
I was impressed by how Gable kept the lurid details from being the focus. There were some opportunities when she could have -- and probably would have, if she had been a different kind of writer -- shared too much. But she didn’t, and the book is better for it. I won’t say too much more, because I hate spoilers in reviews.
All in all, a pleasant summer read, and a nice example of an author growing in her work. With this novel, Gable’s writing matured and that the plot well-defined. I enjoyed it, and I’ll be passing it around to the fellow readers in my life or encouraging them to get their own copy.
April 11, 2012
I'll be honest. This is not the type of book I would ordinarily put to the front of my reading list. I don not read a lot of fiction. But I had the privilege of meeting the author and seeing a sample of her work. I became enthralled with her story telling abilities.
Caroline, Liam and David immediately came to life. I felt that I was actually in Philadelphia in the mid 1800's witnessing the story unfolding right before my eyes. The author naturally, realistically and compellingly weaves the fundamental and challenging tenets of the Catholic Faith into a fascinating story line. She does it in a way where the reader gains a better understanding of not only what the Catholic Church teaches about such things as marriage, contraception, fidelity, redemption, sin, and forgiveness, but why. She demonstrates not only how difficult it can be to live out those beliefs in real life situations, but how God's grace can lead to amazing things. And she does this without being "preachy".
I am sure glad that I made reading this book a priority (although I've delayed far too long in offering a review). I couldn't put it down and that hasn't happened to me too often.
It's a great read. You'll enjoy it.
Caroline, Liam and David immediately came to life. I felt that I was actually in Philadelphia in the mid 1800's witnessing the story unfolding right before my eyes. The author naturally, realistically and compellingly weaves the fundamental and challenging tenets of the Catholic Faith into a fascinating story line. She does it in a way where the reader gains a better understanding of not only what the Catholic Church teaches about such things as marriage, contraception, fidelity, redemption, sin, and forgiveness, but why. She demonstrates not only how difficult it can be to live out those beliefs in real life situations, but how God's grace can lead to amazing things. And she does this without being "preachy".
I am sure glad that I made reading this book a priority (although I've delayed far too long in offering a review). I couldn't put it down and that hasn't happened to me too often.
It's a great read. You'll enjoy it.
December 10, 2010
What fascinated me most about this lovely Catholic romance was all of the historical detail Ellen provides; it was like stepping back in time into Caroline's era. Ellen must have done a lot of research into this time period, and that makes the story that much more engaging. Caroline's story was sweet and moving, and like another reviewer, I also found myself thinking about her during the day when I wasn't reading the book; her characters are that real and that compelling. This book is a must-read for Catholics looking for wholesome, meaningful fiction.
May 2, 2012
This was a relaxing read, instead of watching mindless tv, etc. It is a historical romance, exploring issues of loss, grieving, human frailty, and redemption, and class discrepancies. Surprisingly, the book explores many Catholic concepts as heart practices rather than the modern day ritual it so often becomes. Unfortunately, it pushes Catholic concepts such as the immorality of birth control to a ridiculous measure. Still, all in all it was enjoyable, and an entertainment for a few hours. For its genre, it receives 3 stars as the writer does develop characters and the style is developed.
July 28, 2011
In Name Only a novel by Ellen Gable is a wonderful work of Catholic historical fiction. It is so delightful to read a romance that keeps to moral teaching. I cried and I laughed while reading this book. Once started it is hard to put down and by the end I wished it could continue. A great book that I highly recommend.
August 30, 2012
Complex and intriguing story line with excellent characters grappling with life's ups and downs. Forgiveness, grace, mercy and growth permeate the story line of all 3 of the main characters in this interesting book.
January 20, 2014
A light reading. A romance novel which makes it very unusual fare for me. But some good words about sexual tension and Catholic (Christian) principles on self control. A little overly contrived in places and a fair number of deaths. Not a great novel but a reasonable effort to pass time.
March 10, 2020
**I am reviewing the audio version of this book.**
I really enjoyed this book.
I love historical romance fiction, and even more so when there is a faith based story. All the characters were very real and relatable.
I looked at some reviews before reading this book. Some reviewers felt that there was too much talk about what david did with women etc. I however, feel that was necessary, so we could really see how much David had changed throughout the story.
I actually think the topic was dealt with very well.
WE also got to see how much Caroline grew and matured. I think the children were portrayed very well. there were some very cute moments especially with little cat.
I love the way scripture was woven in to the story.
I also enjoyed the way the relationship between David and Caroline developed slowly.
There were also a few twists and turns I wasn’t expecting.
Once i got started with this book, it was hard to put down.
As for the Narration, it was top notch. I have heard this Narrator before and absolutely love her narrating style. She reads with so much emotion, and gives the characters their own distinct voices and sometimes accents.
A great read. Would highly recommend.
Note: I was given this review copy audio book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
I really enjoyed this book.
I love historical romance fiction, and even more so when there is a faith based story. All the characters were very real and relatable.
I looked at some reviews before reading this book. Some reviewers felt that there was too much talk about what david did with women etc. I however, feel that was necessary, so we could really see how much David had changed throughout the story.
I actually think the topic was dealt with very well.
WE also got to see how much Caroline grew and matured. I think the children were portrayed very well. there were some very cute moments especially with little cat.
I love the way scripture was woven in to the story.
I also enjoyed the way the relationship between David and Caroline developed slowly.
There were also a few twists and turns I wasn’t expecting.
Once i got started with this book, it was hard to put down.
As for the Narration, it was top notch. I have heard this Narrator before and absolutely love her narrating style. She reads with so much emotion, and gives the characters their own distinct voices and sometimes accents.
A great read. Would highly recommend.
Note: I was given this review copy audio book at my request and have voluntarily left this review.
November 10, 2020
This is the first book I've read or listened to by this author, although I've enjoyed this narrator a few times! She is the reason I took a chance on this book.
There is much grief and joy in this story. There is also a lot about the Catholic faith helping the characters get through their struggles. I know many people follow this faith, but I completely disagree with it as a Christian faith, so I have not labeled this story as Christian, although others may do so.
The story was fascinating yet evil in the sexual life of David before he married Caroline. There is much emphasis on his mistreatment of women and the callousness of his lifestyle while focusing on the compassion and forgiveness of Caroline as she tries to repair much of the damage he has committed.
Gryphon did an amazing job narrating this story. From the sweet voice of Caroline and the children, to the boisterous voice of an Irish servant and the drunken David. I was quite impressed!
There is much grief and joy in this story. There is also a lot about the Catholic faith helping the characters get through their struggles. I know many people follow this faith, but I completely disagree with it as a Christian faith, so I have not labeled this story as Christian, although others may do so.
The story was fascinating yet evil in the sexual life of David before he married Caroline. There is much emphasis on his mistreatment of women and the callousness of his lifestyle while focusing on the compassion and forgiveness of Caroline as she tries to repair much of the damage he has committed.
Gryphon did an amazing job narrating this story. From the sweet voice of Caroline and the children, to the boisterous voice of an Irish servant and the drunken David. I was quite impressed!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 29, 2020
I deeply appreciated this book. The author created a story where you could better understand Theology of the Body in action including the true ordering of marital love. it's so beautiful to see this truth in an over sexualized culture. Even after learning more about the Theology of the Body it's sometimes difficult to understand what it looks like applied to realty so I appreciated that this book helped me do that. Since she was overall more focused on her stories moral, it was a bit unrealistic at parts, didn't have the best quality writing ever and focused a lot on the marital act, which made it a bit heavier. For those reasons it's a 🌟🌟🌟🌟 star book to me, but I do absolutely recommend it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 12, 2019
I'm a fan of historical fiction/romance and this book caught my eye because it is set in a time frame different than most of the historical fiction I read (set in the late 1800s). The story was interesting because it was a love story but it wasn't sugar-coated by any means. As it does today, life had its ups and downs back then and people are people, no matter what era they live in. People make poor choices and have to live with them. Luckily, we have the gift of redemption.
December 1, 2019
This was an excellent historical fiction novel with a great deal of tragedy with characters that changed for the better because of it. There is a great deal mentioned about religion but it is not overly in your face or overly preachy. It is just a sign of the times that the characters lived in and the way things were during that time period. The story was well written with well developed characters.
April 3, 2023
Endurance with God's Grace
Caroline from Boston goes to live with her uncle and cousin after her father dies. Her life goes from grief to extreme happiness at her wedding to grief again. She has to marry someone she detests while pregnant. How can she endure her life?
This book is one of the best I've read. It is very Catholic. God's grace allows the characters to endure many heart-wrenching times and to change for the better.
Caroline from Boston goes to live with her uncle and cousin after her father dies. Her life goes from grief to extreme happiness at her wedding to grief again. She has to marry someone she detests while pregnant. How can she endure her life?
This book is one of the best I've read. It is very Catholic. God's grace allows the characters to endure many heart-wrenching times and to change for the better.
October 25, 2017
A real life story.
I do not always read historical books but I am glad I found this one. It was a very good storyline with many different characters and good and bad situations. It was a different time and a different way of life but with their faith they struggled through. I think even I learned something from this story.
I do not always read historical books but I am glad I found this one. It was a very good storyline with many different characters and good and bad situations. It was a different time and a different way of life but with their faith they struggled through. I think even I learned something from this story.
December 17, 2022
This book had me wondering what tragic thing is going to happen next to this poor woman! I loved every bit of it. Alongside the main character I mourned, was repulsed, and fell in love. This is a **redemption story** and every bit of it really took me by surprise. I'm now a fan of this author and I definitely recommend her to others.
February 16, 2018
Nice story
There were moments in this book that I couldn’t put it down and then other times where I felt it dragged. Good writing, interesting but feel there was something lacking in the premise and specifically the ending. Still a good story. Strong Catholic content.
There were moments in this book that I couldn’t put it down and then other times where I felt it dragged. Good writing, interesting but feel there was something lacking in the premise and specifically the ending. Still a good story. Strong Catholic content.
March 14, 2018
Sweet and life adventure fillef
I have read both of these books and even though I read the 2nd book 1st I enjoyed them immensely. Well written and with life's problems and adventures written with careful following of the norms of the day.
I have read both of these books and even though I read the 2nd book 1st I enjoyed them immensely. Well written and with life's problems and adventures written with careful following of the norms of the day.
November 7, 2020
I love David. The language isn't great but the story is. I've read it once and now: I read only scenes that touch my heart and love! I LOVE hard to put down romances... and this is one of them! Ignore the language and READ IT! God bless you, Ellen Gable!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews