Tina’s comment > Likes and Comments
1 like · Like
Although I thought differently, you had some really good claims and your arguments almost convinced me.
I agree with your argument but I think it would also be Friar Lawrence because he gave the plan to Juliet. I think you used amazing evidence to back up your claim.
I agree with what you said because I personally believe all the characters of the story and Romeo and Juliet themselves were at the fault of their death. It is interesting how the story connects all the characters by having a piece to do with Romeo and Juliet's end, like a tragic puzzle.
This is a great perspective on who caused Romeo and Juliet's death. Though I don't completely agree, your arguments were great.
I agree with this even though I also think that Friar Lawrence was mainly responsible.
Even though it may seem that the nurse had been at fault for pushing Juliet to do something that had caused Juliet to do something unwise, it hadn't been the nurses intention to kill the two lovers as she had been doing what she thought was best for Juliet.
Although my thought process was different, it seems that the nurse had a role in Romeo and Juliet's death. I believe that Lawrence was the reason that Juliet got the idea to fake her death, ultimately leading to the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.
I guess this is kind of true, but I don't think the nurse exactly pressured Juliet. Yeah sure, the nurse had suddenly turned on Juliet by telling her that she should have a second marriage with Paris, but I believe that the best the nurse could've done was distract others to get Juliet to Romeo. Another thing is, Juliet might've gone to Friar Laurence either way.
Like I said before, it's not fair for the nurse to support Juliet and then suddenly change her mind, but I honestly don't think it's her fault.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Hafsah
(new)
Mar 01, 2018 11:48AM
Although I thought differently, you had some really good claims and your arguments almost convinced me.
reply
|
flag
I agree with your argument but I think it would also be Friar Lawrence because he gave the plan to Juliet. I think you used amazing evidence to back up your claim.
I agree with what you said because I personally believe all the characters of the story and Romeo and Juliet themselves were at the fault of their death. It is interesting how the story connects all the characters by having a piece to do with Romeo and Juliet's end, like a tragic puzzle.
This is a great perspective on who caused Romeo and Juliet's death. Though I don't completely agree, your arguments were great.
I agree with this even though I also think that Friar Lawrence was mainly responsible.
Even though it may seem that the nurse had been at fault for pushing Juliet to do something that had caused Juliet to do something unwise, it hadn't been the nurses intention to kill the two lovers as she had been doing what she thought was best for Juliet.
Although my thought process was different, it seems that the nurse had a role in Romeo and Juliet's death. I believe that Lawrence was the reason that Juliet got the idea to fake her death, ultimately leading to the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.
I guess this is kind of true, but I don't think the nurse exactly pressured Juliet. Yeah sure, the nurse had suddenly turned on Juliet by telling her that she should have a second marriage with Paris, but I believe that the best the nurse could've done was distract others to get Juliet to Romeo. Another thing is, Juliet might've gone to Friar Laurence either way.Like I said before, it's not fair for the nurse to support Juliet and then suddenly change her mind, but I honestly don't think it's her fault.
