Kathy’s comment > Likes and Comments
2 likes · Like
I agree. I think it was the wrong love in the wrong time. A combination of hate and love that led to the suicides of Romeo and Juliet. Yes, the lovers may have been a bit over the top and quick, but say they did truly love eachother. This love and relationship between Romeo and Juliet would've been fine in most families and circumstances; not with the Capulets and Montgues, too much hate. So sad. If only this world was capable of harvesting such love.
I believe that Romeo Montague is to blame for the deaths of both Romeo and Juliet. I believe that Romeo is the cause of death for Juliet and himself because of his recklessness. When Romeo sees Juliet he immediately assumes that she is dead and kills himself which results in Juliet realizing he has died which results in her death. If Romeo had not drank the potion both him and Juliet would be reunited and safe. The quote in act 5 scene 3 supports my claim by stating, “? O no! a lantern, slaughter’d youth, For here lies Juliet, and her beauty makes This vault a feasting presence full of light. Death, lie thou there, by a dead man interr’d.” Romeo states the death of Juliet in the texts without analyzing his situation, he kills himself which leads to Juliet’s legitimate death.
In my opinion, you make some valid points on who caused Romeo and Juliet's deaths, but I do think some of the individual characters did take part. For example, Friar Lawrence, who proposed the plan to fake her death, which led to Romeo not knowing and then killing himself, which then led to Juliet killing herself. The family's feud was a huge part to the cause, but others did contribute to their deaths.
Friar Lawrence causing the deaths of Romeo and Juliet
Romeo and Juliet is a Shakespearean tragedy in which two teenagers, Romeo and Juliet, fall in love with each other in the midst of an enmity of two families, Capulet and Montague. Juliet is Capulet, and Romeo is a Montague. They marry without their families knowing, with the help of Friar Lawrence. Then Romeo kills Tybalt in the middle of a street fight in which he was trying to prevent Tybalt and Mercutio from fighting. For killing Tybalt, Romeo is banished from the city by Prince Escalus. Friar Lawrence comes up with a complicated plan to get them together, which involves Juliet fake-dying, and Friar Lawrence sending a letter to Romeo that Juliet is not actually dead. Romeo does not receive that letter, though, and commits suicide because of grief. Juliet wakes up, and seeing that Romeo is dead, also kills herself. This is one of the most known Shakespearean plays written, and half of the other dramas in the world are based off of this one. But at the play’s close, readers are left wondering who or what is to blame for the death of Romeo and Juliet. Upon further reflection, it is clear that Friar Lawrence is the one to blame for the untimely deaths of the young lovers.
First of all, Friar Lawrence easily could have prevented the deaths of both of Romeo and Juliet by not keeping the marriage private, and announcing it to the public. If Friar Lawrence did that, both the Montagues and the Capulets would have made peace, and then the street fight where Romeo killed Tybalt would not have happened, and consequently, then Romeo and Juliet would not have commited suicide. To quote this, Friar Lawrence says “For this alliance may so happy prove to turn your households’ rancor to pure love.” in act 4, scene 2. In simpler terms, “may this alliance break apart the hatred of both of your families and turn it to pure love.” This means that Friar Lawrence is not acting like a catalyst, he is not taking part in any actions that might have sped up the forthcoming peace of the Montagues and the Capulets. Therefore, Friar Lawrence could have prevented the tragic deaths of both Romeo and Juliet.
Second of all, Friar Lawrence could have written and delivered the letter to Romeo himself, instead of entrusting other people with it to ensure that Romeo received the letter. Friar John, the man expected to bring the letter “could not send it...nor get a messenger to bring it...so fearful were they of infection” (act 5, scene 2, line 2915). Because of the quarantine keeping the information from Romeo, Balthazar sped to Romeo, and told him of Juliet’s ‘death’. If Friar Lawrence had given the letter to Romeo himself, this way, he would have prevented Balthazar from telling Romeo that Juliet was dead, and then Romeo would have not committed suicide. Friar Lawrence might have taken up an action that he didn’t think through. He should have questioned himself and criticized his own statements over and over, since he was taking on the risk of preserving Romeo and Juliet’s marriage, but he didn’t. Therefore, Friar Lawrence could have also prevented the death of Romeo and Juliet this way, but he didn’t, and they both died.
Third of all, Friar Lawrence could have possibly by preventing the deaths of Romeo and Juliet by talking Prince Escalus out of banishing Romeo from the city. That way, Romeo and Juliet could have at least communicated, even if Prince Escalus had given him years in jail or some other punishment. Friar Lawrence didn’t even try to stop Prince Escalus from banishing Romeo. Even if he was busy, and he might have had no time to go there, because he was conjuring up a plan to save the relationship of Romeo and Juliet, he still should have tried. This might have been a risky move, but he had already taken risks with much worse consequences. Having not enough time does not give Friar Lawrence an excuse to not talk to Prince Escalus. This proves that Friar Lawrence could have prevented the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, and he didn’t even try.
Lastly, Friar Lawrence gave the sleeping potion to Juliet. This was a risky move, and Friar Lawrence knew that risky moves could cost Juliet and Romeo their lives. Even though, he still made the decision for Romeo. Romeo didn’t know any of this was even happening, and Friar Lawrence took the risk: “Hold, then; go home, be merry, give consent to marry Paris: Wednesday is to-morrow:to-morrow night look that thou lie alone; Let not thy nurse lie with thee in thy chamber: Take thou this vial, being then in bed, And this distilled liquor drink thou off...” (act 4, scene 1, line 89) This quote , in shorter words, means that Friar Lawrence is telling Juliet to tell Count Paris that she will marry him. Then, at night, when she will be going to bed, she must drink the vial that he will give her. Friar Lawrence is using imperative tense, therefore he is commanding Juliet to tell Count Paris that she will marry him, and then to drink the vial that will make her seem dead. This way, by giving Juliet the vial with the sleeping potion in it, Friar Lawrence is at fault for the death of Romeo and Juliet.
To conclude, Friar Lawrence is at cause of the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. He had made many mistakes and had taken too many risks, which caused Romeo and Juliet to commit suicide. Friar Lawrence may have not been the only factor that contributed to the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, but he was the most influential one.
I agree with your claim that no one truly is responsible for Romeo and Juliet's death. The tragedy was just an accident and it was never meant to happen. The plan made by Friar Lawrence might have worked, but the events that followed resulted in their deaths. It was simply a lack of thought and bad luck.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Andrewfink
(new)
Jun 10, 2014 08:22PM
I agree. I think it was the wrong love in the wrong time. A combination of hate and love that led to the suicides of Romeo and Juliet. Yes, the lovers may have been a bit over the top and quick, but say they did truly love eachother. This love and relationship between Romeo and Juliet would've been fine in most families and circumstances; not with the Capulets and Montgues, too much hate. So sad. If only this world was capable of harvesting such love.
reply
|
flag
I believe that Romeo Montague is to blame for the deaths of both Romeo and Juliet. I believe that Romeo is the cause of death for Juliet and himself because of his recklessness. When Romeo sees Juliet he immediately assumes that she is dead and kills himself which results in Juliet realizing he has died which results in her death. If Romeo had not drank the potion both him and Juliet would be reunited and safe. The quote in act 5 scene 3 supports my claim by stating, “? O no! a lantern, slaughter’d youth, For here lies Juliet, and her beauty makes This vault a feasting presence full of light. Death, lie thou there, by a dead man interr’d.” Romeo states the death of Juliet in the texts without analyzing his situation, he kills himself which leads to Juliet’s legitimate death.
In my opinion, you make some valid points on who caused Romeo and Juliet's deaths, but I do think some of the individual characters did take part. For example, Friar Lawrence, who proposed the plan to fake her death, which led to Romeo not knowing and then killing himself, which then led to Juliet killing herself. The family's feud was a huge part to the cause, but others did contribute to their deaths.
Friar Lawrence causing the deaths of Romeo and JulietRomeo and Juliet is a Shakespearean tragedy in which two teenagers, Romeo and Juliet, fall in love with each other in the midst of an enmity of two families, Capulet and Montague. Juliet is Capulet, and Romeo is a Montague. They marry without their families knowing, with the help of Friar Lawrence. Then Romeo kills Tybalt in the middle of a street fight in which he was trying to prevent Tybalt and Mercutio from fighting. For killing Tybalt, Romeo is banished from the city by Prince Escalus. Friar Lawrence comes up with a complicated plan to get them together, which involves Juliet fake-dying, and Friar Lawrence sending a letter to Romeo that Juliet is not actually dead. Romeo does not receive that letter, though, and commits suicide because of grief. Juliet wakes up, and seeing that Romeo is dead, also kills herself. This is one of the most known Shakespearean plays written, and half of the other dramas in the world are based off of this one. But at the play’s close, readers are left wondering who or what is to blame for the death of Romeo and Juliet. Upon further reflection, it is clear that Friar Lawrence is the one to blame for the untimely deaths of the young lovers.
First of all, Friar Lawrence easily could have prevented the deaths of both of Romeo and Juliet by not keeping the marriage private, and announcing it to the public. If Friar Lawrence did that, both the Montagues and the Capulets would have made peace, and then the street fight where Romeo killed Tybalt would not have happened, and consequently, then Romeo and Juliet would not have commited suicide. To quote this, Friar Lawrence says “For this alliance may so happy prove to turn your households’ rancor to pure love.” in act 4, scene 2. In simpler terms, “may this alliance break apart the hatred of both of your families and turn it to pure love.” This means that Friar Lawrence is not acting like a catalyst, he is not taking part in any actions that might have sped up the forthcoming peace of the Montagues and the Capulets. Therefore, Friar Lawrence could have prevented the tragic deaths of both Romeo and Juliet.
Second of all, Friar Lawrence could have written and delivered the letter to Romeo himself, instead of entrusting other people with it to ensure that Romeo received the letter. Friar John, the man expected to bring the letter “could not send it...nor get a messenger to bring it...so fearful were they of infection” (act 5, scene 2, line 2915). Because of the quarantine keeping the information from Romeo, Balthazar sped to Romeo, and told him of Juliet’s ‘death’. If Friar Lawrence had given the letter to Romeo himself, this way, he would have prevented Balthazar from telling Romeo that Juliet was dead, and then Romeo would have not committed suicide. Friar Lawrence might have taken up an action that he didn’t think through. He should have questioned himself and criticized his own statements over and over, since he was taking on the risk of preserving Romeo and Juliet’s marriage, but he didn’t. Therefore, Friar Lawrence could have also prevented the death of Romeo and Juliet this way, but he didn’t, and they both died.
Third of all, Friar Lawrence could have possibly by preventing the deaths of Romeo and Juliet by talking Prince Escalus out of banishing Romeo from the city. That way, Romeo and Juliet could have at least communicated, even if Prince Escalus had given him years in jail or some other punishment. Friar Lawrence didn’t even try to stop Prince Escalus from banishing Romeo. Even if he was busy, and he might have had no time to go there, because he was conjuring up a plan to save the relationship of Romeo and Juliet, he still should have tried. This might have been a risky move, but he had already taken risks with much worse consequences. Having not enough time does not give Friar Lawrence an excuse to not talk to Prince Escalus. This proves that Friar Lawrence could have prevented the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, and he didn’t even try.
Lastly, Friar Lawrence gave the sleeping potion to Juliet. This was a risky move, and Friar Lawrence knew that risky moves could cost Juliet and Romeo their lives. Even though, he still made the decision for Romeo. Romeo didn’t know any of this was even happening, and Friar Lawrence took the risk: “Hold, then; go home, be merry, give consent to marry Paris: Wednesday is to-morrow:to-morrow night look that thou lie alone; Let not thy nurse lie with thee in thy chamber: Take thou this vial, being then in bed, And this distilled liquor drink thou off...” (act 4, scene 1, line 89) This quote , in shorter words, means that Friar Lawrence is telling Juliet to tell Count Paris that she will marry him. Then, at night, when she will be going to bed, she must drink the vial that he will give her. Friar Lawrence is using imperative tense, therefore he is commanding Juliet to tell Count Paris that she will marry him, and then to drink the vial that will make her seem dead. This way, by giving Juliet the vial with the sleeping potion in it, Friar Lawrence is at fault for the death of Romeo and Juliet.
To conclude, Friar Lawrence is at cause of the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. He had made many mistakes and had taken too many risks, which caused Romeo and Juliet to commit suicide. Friar Lawrence may have not been the only factor that contributed to the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, but he was the most influential one.
I agree with your claim that no one truly is responsible for Romeo and Juliet's death. The tragedy was just an accident and it was never meant to happen. The plan made by Friar Lawrence might have worked, but the events that followed resulted in their deaths. It was simply a lack of thought and bad luck.
