Ashley’s Comments (group member since Feb 14, 2008)

Ashley’s comments from the Edward vs. Jacob group.

Yea, but the ending was pretty pathetic still. She needed action or something in it but she said she didn't want any of her characters 2 die or anything but 2 me, having characters in books die or make choices that could leave them in pain or something, it makes the book seem so much more real and then it also brings out inner feelings. In Breaking Dawn, the end had no affect on me. They all just walked away. No excitement! Books = excitement & problems, otherwise it wouldn't be very interesting!

Jacob didn't exactley run away. He just needed some peace & quiet. He needed to be away from everyone, let his emotions all come out without anyone watching him. He'll come back.

Edward might be better for Bella, i can agree on that because Edward is always trying to help Bella & everything now is about Bella. He has never had a girl that he's loved as much as Bella but then neither has Jacob. I agree that Jacob should just be the friend but then i feel REALLY bad for him. Imagine being in his place: 'You have saved this girl from completley losing it & have discovered that you love her when suddenly she has gone away to go save Edward. You still love her but now you know that you've been pushed almost completley out of her "love" mind so it's all about Edward & not you. You're still young so you make up stuff & you're not as perfect as Edward. You don't want Bella to become a vampire because you think that she will not remember you. She will be like all vampires, against werewolves & trying to kill them.' You cannot imagine every emotion running through his head. But then Edward is maddly in love with Bella & wants to get married. The one thing that Edward & Jacob can relate to is Bella. One thing they both don't want is for her to become a vampire. Edward likes Bella how she is. I know you guys say that she will be the same once she gets used to the vampire thing just like Edward did but how do we know what Edward was like before he became a vampire. Maybe he was a bad kid but when he became a vampire the Cullens trained him how to be good. Maybe he couldn't remember what he was like before he was a vampire. Alice couldn't. Bella might still be good but she will not be the SAME. I like Bella how she is! She can't become a vampire!

Ya but as u also saw in Twilight, the Culluns didn't really EAT the food. The just threw it away. Remember how Bella asked Jessica if the Culluns ate and Jessica said rarely or something like that. Even when the did eat, the said it was like eating dirt! They never enjoyed it or anything! They never even showed that they were chewing OR enjoying the food they ate! Also, are u even thinking about POOR Jacob! I mean, I want Bella to end up with Edward (mostly) but everyone is always saying how bad Jacob would be for Bella! How would u feel if u were Jacob?! Also, Edward isn't completely perfect, and besides, he's had more years of practice than Jacob has!

But then she'll be cold, visious, and not, well, Bella! She'll be different!

I just don't want Bella to become a vampire! Come on! Her personality will completly change and who knows what else will happen! I LOVE Edward but still, Jacob is also really nice! He's good so I don't really care who Bella picks as long as it makes her REALLY SUPER happy!

Bella might have picked Edward but she doesn't really stick to her decisions very much. She always changes her mind. So she just might end up with Jacob!

Edward's heart WOULD be broken but so would Jacob! Jacob's IS broken right NOW!!!! He thought Bella loved him! No one really thinks about Bella's feelings! It's all about EDWARD'S feelings! What if you were Jacob! How would you feel?

Jacob and Billy did a lot for Bella too you know! Whose the one who told about Edward being a vampire in the first place. If Jacob never said anything than Bella could be still trying to figure out what Edward was or Edward could be in another state, city, country, etc. Without the wolf pack's help, Bella would be dead right now! Either by Victoria or by her trying to do a lot of crazy things like the motercycles or jumping off the cliff!

If Bella has to be with Edward forever, I would simply be so mad if she became a vampire! Come on! She would be cold, a vicious killer for a while, and what if her heart gets cold so she doesn't like Edward anymore? She also won't be able to see Charlie or Renea! Imagine being a parent of a girl who runs away and no matter how much you contact her, she won't come to visit you. When or if she every does, she's cold, hard, strong, beautiful, and acts discusted with the food you give her. When its night, you watch her and discover that she doesn't sleep! How would you feel if you were the parents?! She would be so different from the daughter you gave birth to! Jacob just might be a better choice for her in some ways!

Another thing is that Jacob didn't run away! He was mad and needed to be away from everyone so he could have some peace! He didn't want to get really angry and hurt someone!

I know that you said that Bella would be more safe with Edward than with Jacob but is that true? Jacob is really protective too you know! Besides, what will happen if Edward bites into Bella to make her a vampire and can't resist the blood? He'll KILL her! You might not think he will but think about that first chapter of Twilight in Edward's point of view, he was going to kill the WHOLE class and leave her cowering in a corner! He couldn't resist the scent of her blood! You never know!

OK! Everyone has different ideas and I'm in the very middle! You have to think about how the characters feel! Imagine Jacob! He helped Bella through the hard times and almost all she talks about is Edward. She starts to like him a lot and then Edward comes back! Bella just dumped him and left him hanging! Jacob said he would kill Bella if she became a vampire because he was mad! Don't you ever say something without meaning to say it because your mad? I do! About the soul mate, it doesn't mean Jacob won't love Bella, it just means he'll love someone else without TRYING too. That mate might not even ever come! Remember that story Billy told in Eclipse about the wolf cheif and his wife, how the wife killed herself to save her husband or sons? Bella could be like that wife minus the killing herself. She could have kids! Edward is really nice and perfect but so is Jacob! I mean, Jacob isn't like a mad ferosious beast! Even Charlie wants Bella to be with Jacob more than Edward!