Readers' Most Anticipated Books for Fall 2025

Listopia > Book Lists Voted on by Loree Madding (13 Lists)



Head Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyThe Elephant Tree by R.D. RonaldGray After Dark by Noelle W. IhliHidden Pictures by Jason RekulakAsk for Andrea by Noelle W. Ihli
Judge A Book By Its Cover!
15,002 books — 16,964 voters
Ask for Andrea by Noelle W. IhliLook Closer by David EllisThe Roommate by Kiersten ModglinThe Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie DonleaNo One Can Know by Kate Alice Marshall
I'm glad someone made me read this book
10,514 books — 10,132 voters

The Elephant Tree by R.D. RonaldAsk for Andrea by Noelle W. IhliHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyGray After Dark by Noelle W. IhliLook Closer by David Ellis
Best Crime & Mystery Books
7,274 books — 15,390 voters
The Roommate by Kiersten ModglinThe Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie DonleaLook Closer by David EllisHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyGray After Dark by Noelle W. Ihli
Best Ending
8,041 books — 6,047 voters

Gray After Dark by Noelle W. IhliLook Closer by David EllisHidden Pictures by Jason RekulakThe Elephant Tree by R.D. RonaldHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van Wey
Must Read Books- Different Genres
13,526 books — 9,734 voters
Ask for Andrea by Noelle W. IhliThose Empty Eyes by Charlie DonleaHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyNo One Can Know by Kate Alice MarshallHidden Pictures by Jason Rekulak
All-Time Awesome Books
11,739 books — 7,356 voters

Look Closer by David EllisThe Club by Ellery LloydNo One Can Know by Kate Alice MarshallHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyThe Roommate by Kiersten Modglin
Best for Book Clubs
14,351 books — 18,177 voters
The Elephant Tree by R.D. RonaldThe Roommate by Kiersten ModglinGray After Dark by Noelle W. IhliThe Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie DonleaAsk for Andrea by Noelle W. Ihli
Books That Were Way Better Than I Thought They Would Be
10,404 books — 7,169 voters

The Club by Ellery LloydHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyLook Closer by David EllisThose Empty Eyes by Charlie DonleaGray After Dark by Noelle W. Ihli
MUST READS!!!
14,274 books — 9,934 voters
The Elephant Tree by R.D. RonaldThose Empty Eyes by Charlie DonleaHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyAsk for Andrea by Noelle W. IhliHidden Pictures by Jason Rekulak
Books You Would Recommend to Strangers
12,130 books — 7,758 voters

Head Like a Hole by Andrew Van WeyAsk for Andrea by Noelle W. IhliThe Club by Ellery LloydThe Roommate by Kiersten ModglinNo One Can Know by Kate Alice Marshall
Books that Blew Me Away and that I Still Think About
14,228 books — 14,344 voters
The Girl Who Was Taken by Charlie DonleaLook Closer by David EllisThose Empty Eyes by Charlie DonleaNot Forever, But For Now by Chuck PalahniukThe Club by Ellery Lloyd
The Most Disturbing Books Ever Written
3,168 books — 11,097 voters

The Club by Ellery LloydThose Empty Eyes by Charlie DonleaLook Closer by David EllisHidden Pictures by Jason RekulakHead Like a Hole by Andrew Van Wey
Recommended Thriller/Suspense
2,356 books — 2,095 voters