Poll

Do you like Rosalie after reading Breaking Dawn?

She's ok...
 
  24 votes, 40.7%

Yes
 
  23 votes, 39.0%

No
 
  12 votes, 20.3%

Who is Rosalie, again?
 
  0 votes, 0.0%


Poll added by: Stephanie



Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sella (new)

Sella Malin GAH I HATED HER IN BD!!!! B!#@($#(P%P#%#!!!!!!!!!!

lol sry. XD


message 2: by Haley (new)

Haley Mathiot Bella "Redeemed herself" for her 'poor choice' of becoming a vampire, they "fought the same war for long enough" so that now they are friends in the end.

I think it's good. cuz deep down, Rosalie is really a good vampire. and i thought it was good that they could live in some kind of peace for the next few decades... at least until Rosalie gets all pig-headed-ly stupid again.


message 3: by Immortal (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:54AM) (new)

Immortal Fiction She never did do anything for Bella, just for the baby, assuming Bella would die and she could raise the baby. I'm happy she helped keep Renesme alive but she stayed selfish all the way through. I did soften towards her in ECLIPSE when she shared her gut wrenching story with Bella (ultimate betrayal rape death!) but even THEN she said she didn't want to be friends (just wanted to be understood?) She was a spoiled rich-bitch before death and hadn't improved in 50+ years even in death? To still be so self-absorbed that she can't be happy for Edward finally finding love even though she knows what that's like with Emmet? Even after provoking Edward's suicide attempt at the end of New Moon and asking Bella's forgiveness she still didn't warm up to Bella? And we're not guessing here.. Edward could read her mind and confirmed Jacob's guesses several times in Breaking Dawn that she cared nothing about Bella and would have let her die anytime if it didn't matter to saving Renesme. Rosalie may do Bella's hair, etc. for the wedding but did Alice make her? lol She helps her stay alive for the baby but she is never affectionate or truly sacrificing for another person except Emmet. She doesn't even respect Carlisle in several arguments across 4 books.

BUT THAT's what makes her a great antagonist! The actress played her role VERY WELL! lol


message 4: by Cat (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

Cat i liked her before breaking dawn. i've always liked her, even in twilight!


message 5: by Abby (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

Abby i liked her in eclipse and a bit in breaking dawn, but that changed throughout the book, she only cared about the baby, but bella was kinda dumb and warming up to Rosalie when she was pregnant, but she was being clueless in general when she was pregnant

i thought the actress was good and portraved her well but she did not look right in my opinion (she had to get her hair dyed and a skin bleach!!!!!!!)


message 6: by Immortal (new)

Immortal Fiction yeah I'm sure it was tough to get fictionally perfect featured actors who could really act but then again life isn't fair and some folks do get it all. lol. normally the esquisitely beautiful actors can't act though; just pose. that's even what kristen said about the other guys who tried out for Edward. Only Rob had brought any depth to the role during audition and the rest were models striking poses. lol


message 7: by [deleted user] (last edited Feb 25, 2009 02:18AM) (new)

I found that the more I read into Breaking Dawn I was amazed that such a hard core self perserved famale could be succombed to the more powerful energy of a human event (giving birth and motherhood). I think this gave Rose a chance to redeem herself and show her true colors of just being a jealous vampire that envies any human that can procreate.


message 8: by Camisha (new)

Camisha I hated her MORE


message 9: by Noah (new)

Noah I think Rosalie has some serious issues because she cant even be happy for edward who finally found someone to be with. Edward is always there for everyone but rosalie wont be there for anone but herself, she would only help if carlisle forces her to. I think she needs to appreciate her family. She is only using bella for renesmee hopping she would die and the baby would be hers. She is a spoiled bitch. She has no respect for Carlisle or Esme. Esme is really kind to her. I dont know why emmett wants to be with her.


back to top

Members can create polls
widget

4500

Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer


Noah 1 book
0 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Maggi 129 books
25 friends
voted for:
Yes


Angela 6508 books
980 friends
voted for:
Yes


Bella1 33 books
1 friend
voted for:
She's ok...


Hannah 70 books
103 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Liz 581 books
11 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Katy 261 books
14 friends
voted for:
Yes


Joanne 38 books
109 friends
voted for:
Yes




Nicole 276 books
18 friends
voted for:
No


ⓑⓔ©©ⓐ 280 books
44 friends
voted for:
Yes


Hannah 235 books
7 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Aimee 326 books
10 friends
voted for:
Yes


Ashley 735 books
65 friends
voted for:
No


Ms. Vicki 357 books
51 friends
voted for:
Yes


Angee 235 books
330 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Stephanie 1482 books
235 friends
voted for:
Yes


Courtney 855 books
86 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Cat 12 books
2 friends
voted for:
Yes


Camisha 162 books
12 friends
voted for:
No


Scarlet 1401 books
71 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Luly 134 books
15 friends
voted for:
No


Raquel 282 books
30 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Immortal 3858 books
149 friends
voted for:
No


Haley 1478 books
512 friends
voted for:
Yes


Ayesha 1429 books
19 friends
voted for:
No


Anna 2950 books
171 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


Cheryl 283 books
489 friends
voted for:
Yes


Jamain 224 books
99 friends
voted for:
Yes


Abby 545 books
66 friends
voted for:
She's ok...


More...