Readers' Most Anticipated Books for Fall 2025

Firsts and Forever Series

16 primary works • 23 total works

Book 1

Way Off Plan
by
3.96 · 2251 Ratings · 253 Reviews · published 2012 · 6 editions
Jamie Nolan is a young cop. Dmitri Teplov is a sus…

Shelve Way Off Plan

    • Rate it:

    Book 2

    All In
    by
    4.07     · 1882 Ratings · 144 Reviews · published 2013 · 5 editions
    Even though he's not really over his ex-boyfriend …

    Shelve All In

    • Rate it:

    Book 3

    In Pieces
    by
    4.18     · 1756 Ratings · 113 Reviews · published 2013 · 4 editions
    Twenty-year-old Christopher Robin Andrews lives hi…

    Shelve In Pieces

    • Rate it:

    Book 4

    Gathering Storm
    by
    4.20     · 1736 Ratings · 135 Reviews · 5 editions
    Working as a gay porn star has brought twenty-two-…

    Shelve Gathering Storm

    • Rate it:

    Book 5

    Salvation
    by
    4.18     · 1533 Ratings · 125 Reviews · published 2014 · 4 editions
    Can two men from wildly different worlds prove to …

    Shelve Salvation

    • Rate it:

    Book 6

    Skye Blue
    by
    4.27     · 1464 Ratings · 129 Reviews · published 2014 · 3 editions
    Sometimes, the road to happily ever after takes yo…

    Shelve Skye Blue

    • Rate it:

    Book 7

    Against the Wall
    by
    4.37     · 1437 Ratings · 140 Reviews · published 2015 · 3 editions
    Don’t start something you can’t finish. It’s a cli…

    Shelve Against the Wall

    • Rate it:

    Book 8

    Belonging
    by
    4.24     · 1242 Ratings · 115 Reviews · published 2015 · 3 editions
    Can two damaged men build a future together from t…

    Shelve Belonging

    • Rate it:

    Book 9

    Coming Home
    by
    4.30     · 1556 Ratings · 171 Reviews · published 2015 · 5 editions
    For twenty-six-year-old rent boy Chance Matthews, …

    Shelve Coming Home

    • Rate it:

    Book 10

    All I Believe
    by
    4.25     · 1174 Ratings · 121 Reviews · published 2015 · 4 editions
    Nico Dombruso has learned to keep the world at arm…

    Shelve All I Believe

    • Rate it:

    Book 10.5

    Hitman's Holiday
    by
    4.20     · 799 Ratings · 72 Reviews · published 2015 · 3 editions
    It’s Christmas Eve at Nana Dombruso’s house, and a…

    Shelve Hitman's Holiday

    • Rate it:

    Book 11

    The Distance
    by
    4.35     · 1092 Ratings · 118 Reviews · published 2016 · 4 editions
    What if everything you think you know about someon…

    Shelve The Distance

    • Rate it:

    Book 12

    Who I Used to Be
    by
    4.31     · 813 Ratings · 94 Reviews · published 2016 · 3 editions
    Zachary’s life is careening toward disaster.

    At j…

    Shelve Who I Used to Be

    • Rate it:

    Book 13

    Worlds Away
    by
    4.30     · 715 Ratings · 73 Reviews · published 2016 · 3 editions
    Does love stand a chance between two men from diff…

    Shelve Worlds Away

    • Rate it:

    Book 13.5

    Armor
    by
    4.40     · 582 Ratings · 51 Reviews · published 2017 · 3 editions
    Dante Dombruso has always been his family’s armor.…

    Shelve Armor

    • Rate it:

    Book 14

    All I Ever Wanted
    by
    4.31     · 642 Ratings · 56 Reviews · published 2017 · 3 editions
    I’ve been given this amazing gift: a second chance…

    Shelve All I Ever Wanted

    • Rate it:

    Book 15

    Take a Chance on Me
    by
    4.44     · 713 Ratings · 69 Reviews · published 2017 · 3 editions
    Free-spirited ballet dancer Quinn is sure he made …

    Shelve Take a Chance on Me

    • Rate it:

    Book 15.5

    Once Burned
    by
    4.27     · 529 Ratings · 41 Reviews · published 2018 · 4 editions
    Cameron Doyle is an arson investigator who’s learn…

    Shelve Once Burned

    • Rate it:

    Book 16

    The Rest of Forever
    by
    4.35     · 692 Ratings · 78 Reviews · published 2018 · 4 editions
    Does love stand a chance between two very differen…

    Shelve The Rest of Forever

    • Rate it:

    Book 16.5

    Making Merry
    by
    4.53     · 344 Ratings · 43 Reviews · published 2018 · 3 editions
    These five interconnected holiday stories feature …

    Shelve Making Merry

    • Rate it:

    Book 16.6

    Comfort and Joy
    by
    4.30     · 401 Ratings · 46 Reviews · published 2019 · 2 editions
    Jed and Dakota couldn’t be more different.

    One’s …

    Shelve Comfort and Joy

    • Rate it:

    Book 1-3

    The Firsts & Forever Series: Box Set: Volumes 1-3
    by
    4.54     · 61 Ratings · 1 Reviews · published 2013 · 1 edition
    This box set includes 3 full-length novels: Way Of…

    Shelve The Firsts & Forever Series: Box Set: Volumes 1-3

    • Rate it:

    Book 4-6

    The Firsts & Forever Series: Box Set: Volumes 4-6
    by
    4.61     · 61 Ratings · 2 Reviews · published 2014 · 1 edition
    This box set includes 3 full-length novels: Gather…

    Shelve The Firsts & Forever Series: Box Set: Volumes 4-6

    • Rate it:

    Related series

    Series
    First & Forever Stories
    13 primary works • 15 total works
    Series
    California Obscura
    4 primary works • 4 total works
    Series
    Castaways
    3 primary works • 4 total works
    Series
    His Chance
    3 primary works • 3 total works