Shiloh discussion

I chose to read Shiloh because every year many of my fourth grade female students choose to read it, and I wanted to to see what all the fuss was about. I am so glad I chose to read it, because this story really moved me. I am an animal lover at heart, and when I read this story and realized that a major topic covered was animal abuse, I started getting teary eyed. I could completely relate to Marty, which is one reason I loved this story so much. The whole time I was rooting for him and Shiloh. I could literally feel Marty's inner struggle with choosing whether he should return Shiloh to his cruel, abusive owner Judd, or whether he should keep Shiloh hidden, free from abuse. I could feel him asking himself if it's ever OK to break the rules, and is this a good time to start. This novel was very well written, and easily draws you into the characters' world.
Looking at this novel from a teacher's perspective, I believe this would be a wonderful guided reading book. This book would be very useful in teaching 4th grade vocabulary, using sensory images, talking about character traits, and discussing what is "right" and "wrong," fairness, and compromise.

I know why you liked it. It was a good book and very detailed

It was good. I can see why you liked it and I agree with you.

Teachers: What book, about the same reading level as Shiloh, would you recommend for an adult level ESL class? Shiloh has too much slang and southern dialect, Holes is too deep with hidden meaning...... Any ideas? I would appreciate it!