SHERlocked discussion

56 views
Other Fandoms > Benedict Cumberbatch as the Doctor?

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Emily, Heichou (last edited Jan 05, 2014 03:59PM) (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
It has been rumoured that Benedict Cumberbatch had been offered a job as the Doctor, but Ben has said that this is not true in an interview. *sob* Still, it's a nice thought.


message 2: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
OMS!!! This would be the most watched show in existence if it was real.
http://adamantiumbullet.com/wp-conten...


message 3: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
Well, it is real, but if Ben was in it.


message 4: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
People this is a Swoon City alert! Please comment coz I don't want to talk to myself here!!


message 5: by Mitchell (new)

Mitchell Fobbester (the-mad-king) | 40 comments I think that he’s too well recognized as Sherlock and should stick to that, you wouldn't be thinking “oh look, its doctor who”, you’d be thinking “look, isn't that Sherlock, what’s he doing in the TADRIS”. two good things don't always make a great thing, sometimes they ruin each other and i think that would be the case here


message 6: by Angelique (new)

Angelique (angelique682) Yes I would love another opportunity to drool at Ben, but not as the Doctor


message 7: by Innaya (new)

Innaya | 394 comments Agreed!!!!


message 8: by Jessica, sie sind das essen und wir sind die JAGER (new)

Jessica (jesskingxoxo) | 552 comments Mod
Same here!!!


message 9: by Channa (new)

Channa Although wouldn't it be fun if he showed up for one of the DW episodes as a different character, like Rupert Graves (Lestrade) did?


message 10: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
OOh, yes. Or a wholock episode, like if it was just one off that was completely set aside from the series(s). Hmmmmmm. *thinking*


message 11: by Jessica, sie sind das essen und wir sind die JAGER (new)

Jessica (jesskingxoxo) | 552 comments Mod
We should make a Wholock!!! But with slightly more Sherlock in it because this is a Sherlock group.


message 12: by Mitchell (new)

Mitchell Fobbester (the-mad-king) | 40 comments i did hear that there where plans to make him the new regeneration of the master but i think that is was more like wishful thinking than fact, he is playing the villain in the new Star Trek so maybe he would be good as the bad guy for a change.


message 13: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
I've seen the ad and it does look good.


message 14: by Jessica, sie sind das essen und wir sind die JAGER (new)

Jessica (jesskingxoxo) | 552 comments Mod
I shall have to watch the trailer ad


message 15: by Finley (new)

Finley Mac | 3 comments Honestly, I don't think he would be a very good doctor. He might be a better master, but I don't think either of the characters really fit him. Also, Sherlock is already a similar character to the doctor, so it would be nearly the same thing except with more aliens and time travel.


message 16: by Angelique (new)

Angelique (angelique682) Agreed!


message 17: by Mitchell (new)

Mitchell Fobbester (the-mad-king) | 40 comments I think he would make a good 'Omega' or 'Rassilon' if they decide to bring them back. i'm not sure what more they can do with the master character.


message 18: by Emily, Heichou (new)

Emily (emilydodd221) | 620 comments Mod
It would be good to bring the Master back though, since he was in classic Who too.


message 19: by [deleted user] (new)

YES! he would be sooo funny :D


message 20: by Megan (new)

Megan (megan720) | 33 comments I would love to have Wholock, but I think Benedict should remain Sherlock. Please do nothate me when I say that.

Dont get me wrong though! Benedict would be cute in ANY show!


message 21: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 36 comments Megan wrote: "I would love to have Wholock, but I think Benedict should remain Sherlock. Please do nothate me when I say that.

Dont get me wrong though! Benedict would be cute in ANY show!"

I agree!


message 22: by Megan (new)

Megan (megan720) | 33 comments HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!

Super bored right now lol


message 23: by Monica (new)

Monica Yelizaveta | 1 comments I hopeeeeeee sooooooooo!!! That would be sooooo awesome!!!!!


message 24: by Chelsea (new)

Chelsea B | 36 comments I hate that we have to wait so long! I need more Sherlock :(


message 25: by Rachel (new)

Rachel (rjscottie) I think we all need more Sherlock.


the Whovian Bookworm | 2 comments I don't know how much I would like Benedict as the doctor. IK all for wholock but to be honest I like Benedict in Sherlock and who ever is the doctor as in doctor who. It would be great as a movie though, Sherlock and the doctor meeting each other, like one of those old Disney channel mash ups that used to be the biggest thing when I was a kid ;), but even that seems extreme.


back to top