Thief
question
Should Olivia be happy with caleb or her new man?

what do you guys think, is caleb being fair going to ruin her again? yes i know she was totally cowardish by just up and leaving him but shes happy now. i love how she tells Red "I love yours too" AHHHH you go girl! any who... do you think she should be left alone with her new soon to be hubby or does caleb have every right to come in and try to swoop her away. he had his chance, THEY had their chance... maybe its just not meant to be. by trying to do the right thing, Caleb ending up unahppy and miserable but thats not Olivias problem! she should be left to move on... idk mixed emotions here... talk to me baby!
I think the main problem there is the lack of communication. She's to proud to tell him how she really feels and probably he's too scared to face the possibilities of true rejection. Up until now is fate standing in their way. How the 'misunderstanding' between Caleb and that woman in his office drove Olivia, yet again, to act on her impulses; which leads, him to Leah and her, to Noah.
Their relationship is based in raw emotions, they are too impulsive and the fact that they keep their mouths shut when all could be fixed with a simple straight conversation pisses me off.
I truly hope that this last book struck me as Dirty Red did. I got to see Leah's and Caleb's motivations with a new perspective. Don't get me wrong, I still don't like her, but can't but feel sorry for her. Caleb is not treating her right, although it pisses me off when he does.
Their relationship is based in raw emotions, they are too impulsive and the fact that they keep their mouths shut when all could be fixed with a simple straight conversation pisses me off.
I truly hope that this last book struck me as Dirty Red did. I got to see Leah's and Caleb's motivations with a new perspective. Don't get me wrong, I still don't like her, but can't but feel sorry for her. Caleb is not treating her right, although it pisses me off when he does.
i love Caleb......but i want Olivia with Noah!!!!!
I, unlike the majority, think Caleb is a manipulative jerk. I don't hate him per say, they All have their flaws, but he's been let off the hook way too easily. Noah seems like a genuinely good guy. Why should his heart be broken?
I didn't like Caleb in the first two books but in thief you see how many times he went after her but other people kept them apart. I think the only person who didn't get a happy ending was Olivia she never had Caleb's baby and thats what she wanted. Caleb got his daughter and Olivia. Leah got married and had a son that she wanted. Noah didn't want kids so they would never be happy together.
Frannie Cheska
i really hurt for olivia, but i think that was def karma at its finest. she was responsible for the loss of his first baby. even so it was really sad
...more
· flag
· flag
I think if only Caleb had been honest with her it would have saved them years of heartache and misery. I felt bad for Noah but at the same time since he really loves Olivia and he's the sexy Gandhi. Caleb stayed away but in the end Olivia's marriage fell apart.
What I want to know is if Olivia and Caleb end up together? pleaseeee
Aug 16, 2013 02:01PM · flag