The Mortal Instruments discussion

City of Bones (The Mortal Instruments, #1)
This topic is about City of Bones
244 views
City of Bones > Jace and Clary's Relationship

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

Abby (abbykite) | 22 comments Okay, did anyone like not want Jace and Clary to be together after they found out they were brother and sister? Even though it didn't really feel like they were, it was still sorta weird when Jace like proclaimed his love for her even when he was supposed to be her brother. Opinions please!?!


corina (molteneyes) team incest! haha actually, it was a bit awkward, but knowing cassandra clare, i was pretty sure that wasn't actually the truth


Mairead | 309 comments Even if we, the readers, realised they weren't related, Jace and Clary didn't. They full on believed it. And that's what I find skeevy.
They're my least favourite coupling in the series, if I'm honest.


message 4: by silver (new) - added it

silver wombat | 8 comments I totally wanted them to get together still after they found out. It added so much drama to there love and it was exciting. They could' treat each other like bro and sis if they tried and I knew they couldn't really be.


Sheechiibii | 10 comments Mairead wrote: "Even if we, the readers, realised they weren't related, Jace and Clary didn't. They full on believed it. And that's what I find skeevy.
They're my least favourite coupling in the series, if I'm ho..."


I don't think Jace every truly believed it. I remember him specifically adding in a 'possibly' when they were talking about it. To tell the truth I got worried after the first book, looked online, and although I was never told they weren't, I had enough "keep going it all works out"s for me to believe they weren't. It wasn't the brother and sister thing that made me feel bad about it anyway realy, it was that they'd always be shunned if they were together and brother and sister.


Sammie | 4 comments I thought it was odd but is it bad I was still rooting for them to be together some how before I even knew they weren't related .


Teresa (teresa-jiang) | 4 comments I think they're cute together. Clary's bad decisions in ignoring him makes me want to slap her. It's killing him can't you see? But overall, my main otp is Malec ;) then Clace, then Sizzy.


Sarah | 2 comments When I read that they were siblings I was like NO WAY AND SCREAMED CAUSE I HATED IT! INCEST IS BEST! ITS A GAME THE WHOLE FAMILY CAN PLAY!


message 9: by Katlin (new) - added it

Katlin (katlin_jones16) | 6 comments Sarah wrote: "When I read that they were siblings I was like NO WAY AND SCREAMED CAUSE I HATED IT! INCEST IS BEST! ITS A GAME THE WHOLE FAMILY CAN PLAY!"

haha I was honestly really upset too when i found out they were siblings. I was like No!!!! You can't do that!!!


~Hannah~Musicale~ (hhs_piano4ever) | 12 comments I wish Jace and Clary weren't siblings, just because I want them to stay together as a couple. I hope they won't start treating each other differently just because they know they are siblings. Then I would probably become rather annoyed.


Whitney "Love knows no right or wrong."


Allison Janezic (allilj) | 29 comments I don't get the feeling they actually believed Valentine entirely.


Josephine (skyescradle) | 1 comments Ive read the books, but even if I haven't I would still end up saying, "They're not related! i promise!! And that I wanted them to be together! More likely than clary and simon." Here it goes, I like simon, not for clary but for Isabelle..


Claudia | 56 comments I'm currently reading the fourth book in this series and I'm on chapter 8 and they relationship is a little strange...lol


Julia | 1 comments I love Jace and Clary's relationship.... I honestly was so sad to find out they were related........ When I finally started to be okay with the kick butt brother-sister battle team, all of the sudden they aren't related anymore...... I listened to a song called "Warrior" by Beth Crowley trying to make me feel better........ ( Listen to it and you will fall in love with it.) But the 5th book was good ( no spoilers I promise) but I had to listen to "In the End" by Beth Crowley to keep my spirits up because I get a little to attached to the characters in the book :) Although.... Jace and Clary in my opinion belong together you can't help but get annoyed with the way they act sometime!!! :)


Flynn (flynnoleary) I was shipping Clace every second of reading TMI; Brother & sister or not! When I read that they were brother and sister, it felt like Romeo & Juliet to me! It broke my heart! Knowing that they would always be around each other but could never have each other, by the angel, did I cry for ages after finishing CoB!?


Talia Yeah, the brother/sister thing has been a shock for everybody. I've got to say it, I don't actually believe it and it got me a little disappointed too because I don't like this kind of stuff. Reminds me too much of "Beatifull". But I'm going to give CC another chance and read CoA too.


message 18: by Catherine (new) - added it

Catherine | 3 comments I was shocked to hear that they were brothers and sisters but I didnt believe it. They're my favourite couple in the series and I think the truth about their relationship is gonna be said in City Of Glass. But if there isn't a truth then I just wish that no one said about it


message 19: by Addison (last edited Jan 19, 2014 06:17PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Addison (addisonmartin) | 4 comments My top OTP all the way. Sure, I was shocked when I found out they were brother and sister, we all were! But I ship incest and I always will. I loooooove love looooooooove how Jace is fighting so hard not to show his love for Clary, (which from the other characters' point of views he's not hiding it very well), and the same goes for Clary. Clace/incest forever!


back to top