Camp Half-Blood discussion
Debates!
>
Percy or Jason?
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Jun 17, 2013 07:51PM
Hmmmm?
reply
|
flag
No doubt about it: Jason.haha. Who believed that? I was totally kidding. PERCY JACKSON FOREVER!!! XD
Mod
Mod
HELL YEAH... TEAM LEO bcoz he is "LEO VALDEZ, Bad Boy Supreme"(MoA).
Percy! He's our Seaweed Brain! We watched him go through the Underworld and back to stop a war between the gods. He fell in love with Annabeth (he even fell into Tarturus for her!). He stood by Tyson and stood up for Grover. He has a wonderful sense of humor and reminds us all that sometimes you don have to know exactly what you're doing to be a hero, and sometimes a burrito can be a good a projectile as any.
I need to do this. PercyPercyPercyPercyPercyPercyPercyPercyPercy
Aw, I kind of feel bad for Jason now :( Haha, but yeah, team Leo for the win! :D
Thegotenza wrote: "CJ stop making jokes"I am not joking, dude! Jason is better!
To you, maybe. I believe that people are always entitled to their opinions, and mine just isn't the same as yours, that's all.
Mod
I can't tolerate Percy's stupidity, sometimes.
Mod
That's what I favor about him.
Mod
Mod
Good point! I don't really think of it that way, but you are definitely right.
Mod
Dude. You don't even understand the concept of Water and Electrical conduction with a DC. -facepalm- how old are you anyway?
Water being lifted up in the Air and the lighting crashing through it giving PERCY enough time to get out
I think that Jason could beat up Percy, but Percy would definitely prove a worthy adversary. You should remember though, Ventus, that it is very difficult to harm Percy whilst he is submerged in water, for he can heal himself easily.
You can't block lightning with water. Its physically impossible.
Oh yeah hitting PERCY with lighting in water wouldn't work
Thegotenza wrote: "Water being lifted up in the Air and the lighting crashing through it giving PERCY enough time to get out"Chiron facepalmed. Thegotenza, I'll handle this argument for you. I'll side with Percy if it means I get to make better accusations than you.
I wonder something, since the human body is made up of 90% water can Percy control humans???
Lunnylovegood/Percabth Lover/AJ wrote: "I wonder something, since the human body is made up of 90% water can Percy control humans???"He could probably control the water in humans. Not impulses or anything, though.
Ventus wrote: "You can't block lightning with water. Its physically impossible."It's a fictional series, It doesn't all have to make sense.
Well, he's getting technical. I was too. I'm aware. :P
Ventus wrote: "Well, he's getting technical. I was too. I'm aware. :P"So I type up that whole comment, and I don't even get a reply?
I don't really understand the whole 'Percy vs Jason' debate thing! take Percy, make him slightly more of a rule follower and blonde and you''ve practically got Jason! People keep comparing the two characters (who are very alike but also very different) and choosing Percy because of the character history. I understand if you genuinely don't like Jason for any other reason other than the fact that he isn't Percy or 'doesn't have any flaws' or' is too distant' good for you but if you just never gave him a chance, then try rereading lost hero and see what you think then
Cathleen wrote: "I don't really understand the whole 'Percy vs Jason' debate thing! take Percy, make him slightly more of a rule follower and blonde and you''ve practically got Jason! People keep comparing the two ..."I can see where you are coming from, definitely.
Percy's my favorite for sure. Personally I find his stupidity easy to look over because he always makes up for it by doing something so stupid it saves the world. Jason's too serious and soldier like. He wasn't characterized very well, so he doesn't have much of a personality. Whereas Percy's... Percy. My rule is: if you can use someone's name as an adjective, they're well characterized.
Nicole di Angelo wrote: "Percy's my favorite for sure. Personally I find his stupidity easy to look over because he always makes up for it by doing something so stupid it saves the world. Jason's too serious and soldier li..."XD!
Cathleen wrote: "I don't really understand the whole 'Percy vs Jason' debate thing! take Percy, make him slightly more of a rule follower and blonde and you''ve practically got Jason! People keep comparing the two ..."
You have a good point. My main problem with Jason's character itself is that while I was reading the Lost Hero, he kept saying things that I would totally expect Percy to say. It's like Uncle Rick had made Percy blonde and a bit more strict, which just doesn't work. Percy came first, and Jason seemed like more of a lousy replacement.
You have a good point. My main problem with Jason's character itself is that while I was reading the Lost Hero, he kept saying things that I would totally expect Percy to say. It's like Uncle Rick had made Percy blonde and a bit more strict, which just doesn't work. Percy came first, and Jason seemed like more of a lousy replacement.
I agree. Jason did kind of seem like a replacement for Percy at first but I feel like he developed a better character in MOA
