The Serpent's Shadow (The Kane Chronicles, #3) The Serpent's Shadow discussion


112 views
Walt or Anubis

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Hannah;) (new)

Hannah;) Spoiler alert. I can't believe Walt is hosting Anubis . I loved them separately, and to be honest I really liked Anubis better. What do you think is better, when there merged or separate?


Lani I liked them better separate, and I liked Anubis way more. I knew Walt wasn't going to die, but I hoped he would.


message 3: by Hannah;) (new)

Hannah;) I also hated how in decisive sadie was. It's seems a bit too perfect for her to have both of them


Lani If I was Rick Riordan I would have killed off Walt, but not have Sadie date Anubis, because she's too emotional over Walt. Also Sadie is only thirteen how long is this relationship going to last, not for the rest of her life.


Alex There should be something really terrible happening, to where Walt gets infected with a disease that can kill immortal gods too, and Anubis had to get out to save himself. Then as soon as he leaves, Walt dies because he isn't strong enough. Sadie would be so sad that he died and so mad at Anubis for wimping out that she can't love him. And then us fans get Anubis all to ourselves.... :D

Let's get real though. None of our ideas will work. Unless Rick Riordan is magically reading this thread. Which I doubt too. So our best luck is fan fiction!! :(


Lani I agree with you Alex. There would have to be another book though. Which wouldn't be so bad.


Natalia Padilla I really for some reason didn't like Walter and knew that the author wasn't going to kill him!!! i think Anubis was way cooler.


message 8: by Lani (last edited Aug 13, 2013 08:51AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lani Natalia wrote: "I really for some reason didn't like Walter and knew that the author wasn't going to kill him!!! i think Anubis was way cooler."

His full name was Walter! That makes sense actually.


Alex Anaya wrote: "I agree with you Alex. There would have to be another book though. Which wouldn't be so bad."

YES! Let there be another book in which us fans can tackle the new lonely Anubis!!!


message 10: by Lani (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lani Alex wrote: "Anaya wrote: "I agree with you Alex. There would have to be another book though. Which wouldn't be so bad."

YES! Let there be another book in which us fans can tackle the new lonely Anubis!!!"


And if that doesn't work out, he can always add a new character. I really wish Rick Riordan could see this discussion.


message 11: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex Wait a second... Let me see if he's got a goodreads account or his author page!


message 12: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex The only way to reach him and it's guaranteed he'll read it is mail him the transcript of this discussion to this address:
Rick Riordan
c/o Disney-Hyperion Books
1133 Avenue of the Americas
33rd Floor
New York, NY 10036


message 13: by Lani (last edited Sep 16, 2013 04:54PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lani Alex, you can do that if you want, but I know my parents wouldn't let me :)


message 14: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex LOL I'll try. I'll just wait for me to finish my fantastic book and then when I get all famous and such he'll listen even more! Hopefully. If my book is good enough to be accepted by this publishing company I found..


Kathryne Kole Honestly, I like that they're both together.


message 16: by Abby (new) - rated it 4 stars

Abby S. I honestly didn't like either, but Walt was better.


Sarah Tringali YES ALEX! I love how u come up with this crazy stuff.


Sarah Tringali I like Anubis better but I also didn't really like how Walt is now hosting Anubis. It just doesn't work for me.


Pricillia Moman I prefer Anubis, Walt and his story always felt too tacked on for me.


Kathryne Kole Harrypotterfan2468 wrote: "I honestly didn't like either, but Walt was better."

That's how one of my friends feels about it.


message 21: by Hannah;) (new)

Hannah;) I really think that Walt should have just died and that Anubis and her could have been.


message 22: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex YES!


message 23: by Lani (new) - rated it 3 stars

Lani Hannah;) wrote: "I really think that Walt should have just died and that Anubis and her could have been."

The only problem with that is that Sadie would probably be so emotional that she would blame Anubis for not saving him.
I really don't like Sadie.


message 24: by Alex (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alex Yeah. Nor do I. Never really did.

ONE OF US SHOULD KILL HER AND REPLACE HER!! As soon as Rick agrees to my story idea, we convince him to let one of be the new Sadie. After all, he does live only 20 minutes away from my house now..... :)


Parker Does Anubis remind anyone else of Nico? Sadness and death? Anubis is less extroverted, though.


message 26: by Tessa (new)

Tessa Hayden I like Anubis, but I also like Walt just like Sadie. Them both together is like....Woah! I always felt when i was reading about them that they would eventually fight over Sadie...I was actually kind of hoping that. I would be very awesome. It's nice that they get along though to. How does she understand which one is talking to her? I mean they share a body and so how does she know? I guess it really doesn't matter. I really would like Rick to write another trilogy on them...that really would be epic....I even posted on Facebook that i am obsessed..because i am...If rick is reading this i will beg and cry to get you to wright more...ppplllllleeeeaaaassssseee!!!!b:(


Natalia Padilla ANUBIS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Esther Bae ANUBIS~ ROCKS


message 29: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha Anubis AND Walt <3!!!!


Aisha (seetheworldwithbooks) I love the ending. But I don't like the idea annubis and walt become one. I mean, Heck, why can't Walt just die?! I LOVE ANNUBIS, and I'm oke with Walt. Annubis appeared first in Sadie's life in Red Pyramid and he's not afraid to make the first move when he kissed sadie. Walt is just...flat. I think it's kinda like 'insta-love' thing. In thorn of fire, (I know sadie and walt like each other, but Rick explains thousand times that Walt and Sadie don't talk too much! They act just like teacher and student) but suddenly, BOOM, walt kissed sadie after she crashed the stones. And I'm like, Duh.
Walt must die, I think, so that the ending will be bittersweet cause sadie will cry but annubis will be there for her.


Alayna Hannah;) wrote: "Spoiler alert. I can't believe Walt is hosting Anubis . I loved them separately, and to be honest I really liked Anubis better. What do you think is better, when there merged or separate?"

Merged, and I'm the same but with Walt and Anubis merged they are both hot, funny, and sweet.


Alayna Something_personal wrote: "I love the ending. But I don't like the idea annubis and walt become one. I mean, Heck, why can't Walt just die?! I LOVE ANNUBIS, and I'm oke with Walt. Annubis appeared first in Sadie's life in Re..."

Lol that was funny


message 33: by Maya (new) - rated it 4 stars

Maya Anubis. It was quite annoying the way Sadie went on about Walt's muscle shirts.


message 34: by Neha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Neha Lol seriously? I think if I'd be Sadie I'd be hella whining about both of them as much as she did :P


 ■©atherine■ Walt. I don't know why I didn't like Anubis.


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

Dria wrote: "Does Anubis remind anyone else of Nico? Sadness and death? Anubis is less extroverted, though."
Well except for the fact that Anubis is freaking four thousand something years old, it perfectly makes sense!!


Yasamin I feel bad for saying this but I think Walt should have just stayed dead Anubis was way better. And I'm sure he and Sadie would have found a way to be together even with Shu around.


Sami777 Definitely Walt, because he is human, who in their right mind would date a god except of course Sadie Kane


bipasha Anubis. I can't believe this is an actual Q.


Aisha (seetheworldwithbooks) Bipasha{is the designer of her own catastrophe} wrote: "Anubis. I can't believe this is an actual Q."

i know right?! I prefer annubis, i mean he was the one who made a first move. He deserves Saddie :/


Athira ANUBIS OF COURSE!!


Alice (Booksandfreshlybrewedtea) ANUBIS! He's a god duh!
Personally i would be freaked out if two of boys i liked were molded into one!


Vartika Anubis was just PERFECT!!


message 44: by Dani (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dani Dria wrote: "Does Anubis remind anyone else of Nico? Sadness and death? Anubis is less extroverted, though."

Totally! I was just thinking that, and his father is Set, ring a bell doesn't it? Nico's father is the bad guy...well, kinda. Both of their parents were locked in the dark, and so are they...i have an absolute crush on both...but Anubis is better. Nico sounds like he'd kill me in my sleep if I didn't say hi. lol


Alexandra Rain Anubis seemed A LOT less complicated...


message 46: by Jenn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenn I so loved Anubis


Maryclare Fawver Walt is great but Anubis is SOOOOO much better.(sigh)


message 48: by J (new) - rated it 4 stars

J Dria wrote: "Does Anubis remind anyone else of Nico? Sadness and death? Anubis is less extroverted, though."

Since when is Nico extroverted? Did I miss a book or something? (I've read all the books with the exception of Percy Jackson's Greek Gods)


Chaya Um…well, I liked Anubis better than Walt, but it's best that they've merged. Now Sadie doesn't have to choose.


back to top