Dumbledore's Army discussion

This is my favorite movie, but Radcliffe's pretty bad at crying.

I found a flaw with this movie!!!! :D It's a big one!!!

You know how in the beginning, Harry's under his covers working on the spell Lumos? Well later he gets in trouble for blowing up his Aunt Marge(using magic). Why didn't he get in trouble for using Lumos?

Yeah, I know about the Lumos Maxima (not sure why they added the second part). It shouldn't be allowed becuase harry is under-aged, especially before he blows up Marge. Overall, the movie is very good, though.

Sarah wrote: "I found a flaw with this movie!!!! :D It's a big one!!!

You know how in the beginning, Harry's under his covers working on the spell Lumos? Well later he gets in trouble for blowing up his Aunt ..."

Wow..I never realised that!! Interesting!!

Oh, you reminded me Sarah, I'm going to make a "Flaw" topic, where you say all the flaws you found, okay?

I found a few flaws....I'll make sure to post in the Flaws topic.

Good. Now go!

GOGOGO!

GOOOOOOOOOOOOO!

i like the movie...my favorite of the movies...maybe i'll like HBP more...but so far the third movie is my favorite

It's my favorite movie too. It's accurate in the mood and style, but not accurate to the exact events, which isn't too much of a problem.

Confession. I haven't seen the movie we are all talking about here :( I am a new HP fan. I've seen the first 4, but not the 5th and I really want to see the prisoner :)

The Prisoner of Azkaban is the third. I'm confused - didn't you just say you've seen the first four?

Oh yeah, sorry about that. The one I haven't seen and want to see is the the order of the pheonix. Sorry.

No problem.

~☺Jenn☺~ wrote: "Yeah.. Well, I liked it. Especially the Time-Turner scenes! That was awesome!"

I liked the timeturner scenes too!!

Yeah. Lupin looks like a hairless werewolf, though, but the scene where Snape runs in front of the trio is nice - it shows him really fulfilling his promise to Dumbledore.

I also like the bit on the bridge where Lupin talks about Lily. I know it's not in the books and that Snape is the one we are shown Lily really accepets and helps, but it still works to develop her character.

It is probably the best of the movies. Almost.

Courtney wrote: "This one was one of my favorites. They cut out and changed a lot of stuff, but I still liked it."
ME TOO!!!!!!!!!!!

Pandy wrote: "Yeah. Lupin looks like a hairless werewolf, though, but the scene where Snape runs in front of the trio is nice - it shows him really fulfilling his promise to Dumbledore."

OMGS I loved that part too!! But it seems a bit un-realistic to me.

Oh well - didn't seem that un-realistic for Harry Potter. They were just unconscious when he got to them in the book.

I LOVE THIS MOVIE!

It was okay..

Now the 6th is the best...

The best? I guess..

HEY THAT RHYMES!

Wait I don't think it does..*frowns*

Not really.

Pandy wrote: "Not really."

=P

Well, they had to. This book was like, EVERY one's favorite.

I know. The director did a great job, I think. I wish he could have done the fourth one.

One of mine too.

Yeah - Chris Colombus did SS and CoS. Alfonso Cuaron did PoA. Mike Newell did GoF. David Yated did OotP and HBP and he's doing DH I and II.

~☺Jenn☺~ wrote: "CHRIS COLOMBUS IS DOING PERCY JACKSON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 8D 8D 8D 8D TIFFANY!!!!! SWATI!!!! SA- WAIT....... *sniffle*"


I KNOWW! CAN'T WAIT! SA-*sniffs as well* You keep doing that, don't you?

YEAH..

WAHHH!!!! David Yates is good, then...

who is that?