Flights of Fantasy discussion

This topic is about
Shards of Honor
Archived Group Reads
>
April 2014 - Sci-Fi: Shards of Honor by Lois McMaster Bujold
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Emily
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Apr 02, 2014 02:31PM

reply
|
flag



I do have them all. Yay. :)
So, like with Narnia, there was a debate over Publication vs Internal Chronological Order. I acquiesced with Publication Order for Narnia on the advice from those who have read the series before me, and I have enjoyed doing so.
This time, however, I'm going with my natural tendency, and Ms. McMaster Bujold's recommendation. In her Author's Note, The Vorkosigan Saga Reading Order Debate: The Chef Recommends , she states
I favor internal chronological, with a few caveats.
It is an interesting read with descriptions and explanations, as well as the caveats.
I think I will start as soon as I finish Narnia's The Horse and His Boy.
Edited to Add: My husband agrees with reading it in chronological order, the caveat of not reading Falling Free first, and says you can insert that story at any time before Diplomatic Immunity if you find yourself interested in the Quaddie. Oh and Dreamweaver's Dilemma doesn't seem to actually be a part of the story at all.

I followed the author's reading order recommendation too. I recently finished Barrayar and I'm eager to read the adventures of Miles Vorkosigan next.

I read the whole collection about 4-6 months ago, as we had a copy of 'Cyroburn' that had been calling to me to be read. I love how Shards of Honor just whisks me up and transports me into the splendour of Beta Colony, Barrayar, and beyond.
This series, without a doubt, is the most treasured set of books I own. If I was stranded on an island and I could only pick one author to accompany me, it would be the books of Lois McMaster Bujold.

So... we'll see. Maybe I can do it all?

Including George R.R. Martin.


Yep! Eldest brought it home with him from the Grandparents place over the weekend. I took him to the Doc on Monday, woke up with it myself this morning. Yay! Keeping my fingers crossed that it doesn't go past the two of us.


Its not so much flooring me as pissing me off! It feels like there is "something" in the corner of my eye that can not come out.
Plus I have allergies, so yeah I'm having a fantastic time! /whine

I've started it and I've run into my SF problem: I often can't really imagine some of the tech that they use (in SF). It makes me feel...stupid.
:(
So I put it on hold for a min and started seraphina. I have to have both books at the library in...10 days. I should try to knock these out shortly.
damn my fussy book grumpies

Thanks Nan. :) The drops are working.
As to the book....
I'm reading the omnibus version, Cordelia's Honor, which pairs Shards of Honour with the second chronological book Barrayar. This seems to be a good thing because with just about 2 and a half chapters left in Shards of Honour I have feeling the ending is going to leave me a little anxious to continue the series.
Just as I get used to the pacing, it seems to change. I'm currently having a "Well that escalated quickly" moment ((view spoiler) ).
I'm not exactly sure how I'm feeling about the main characters, as yet. There are moments when I really like them and others when not so much. I think I may have been a bit spoiled by David Webber's Honor Harrington, because I keep trying to fit Cordelia into that mold, but she doesn't fit. My husband assures me that Cordelia is actually much more resilient than Honor, but I have to say, I'm feeling doubtful, at the moment. Then again, I've only read 9 of the Harrington books (plus all of the short stories), where as my husband has read both The Harrington and Vorkosigan series all the way through.

I've started it and I've run into my SF problem: I often can't really imagine some of the tech that they use (in SF). It makes me feel...stupid.
:(
So I p..."
Thank you Mrs.J ! :)
Don't feel stupid. I actually tend to skip over a lot of the tech stuff if it isn't stick with me at first (I had to do that quite a bit in the earlier Honor Harrington books). I might go back and give the section a reread if it seems important, though.

If I decide to give it another go I'll probably pick it up from book 8 instead of starting from the beginning.


Really? I didn't know that!
So... I've been away form the chat awhile, but I tore through this one on audio. Enjoyed it quite a bit, and am curious about where the series DOES go from here.
I agree the writing is less fluid an artistic than I remember from reading The Chalion series, but still very good. And she covers a lot of information seamlessly. She sure does love those honorable types true!
SO let's see... were there favorite parts or things to discuss?
Well, I must admit I was a little shocked and starting to become a bit concerned (view spoiler)
All-in-all, I'm quite happy to have finally read this one and found it an enjoyable quick listen - if not my favorite narrator of all time.
Please forgive my spelling mistakes... the joys of audio.

@ Kara - I agree with you on the (view spoiler) . I remember thinking "Alrighty, then!", especially when it was brought up again at the prisoner camp. I also agree on the lack of background, which basically sums up my main issues with the story - Things happened too quickly and there wasn't enough information.
By itself, I think I'd give this a 2.5..maybe a 3. I'm happy, however, that I've already started Barrayar, which picks up the very next day.


And I notice that he does not tell the same story to Cordelia as he does later to Miles about his wife's death. (view spoiler)

Have you ever heard the story that the original inspiration was an idea for Star Trek fanfic? Featuring a red-haired Federation officer who was shipwrecked on a planet -- with a Klingon?
There are points where that looks like the basic skeleton on which the story grew.
Books mentioned in this topic
Cordelia's Honor (other topics)Shards of Honour (other topics)
Barrayar (other topics)
The Ocean at the End of the Lane (other topics)
A Feast for Crows (other topics)