Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion

This topic is about
The Plot Against America
Specific List Books
>
Philip Roth: The plot against America
date
newest »


Completed reading this again for the third time(?) and continue to not be sure of Roth's original 'intent' with this work. It is far to political to just have been the setting for youthful angst or ethnic fear and loathing.
Powerful story if not entirely conclusive or completely entertaining.


The Plot Against America by Philip Roth - 4 stars - My Review
Books mentioned in this topic
The Plot Against America (other topics)The Dispossessed: An Ambiguous Utopia (other topics)
Of the handful of older books that has surfaced in the stores and on bestseller lists, due to the situation in the US, I think this one it the one that is most relevant to read. I can understand why some people say 1984, but Trump is not trying to undo the meaning of words, he it just flat out lying.
The book: The conflict between values is very well written. Should you do what is best now (Sandy and aunt Everlyn) - or best for every ones protection short term – or be uncompromisingly true to higher values and the big picture (Philip's father). It is so much easier to be quite and not create embarrassing situations (as the Washington visit).
I recently read the The Dispossessed “They think that if people can possess enough things they will be content to live in prison.” (about Urras government). The idea is that people can be bribed to let go of ideals by material goods. The whole thing about the visit to the White House is about the same: People are bribed to to let go of ideals by celebrity dust. If you were invited to dinner at the White House – would you go? It I so hard to say 'no' to that invitation.
I really liked the different moral conflicts, and how the book was written, so it wasn't obvious what was going to happen and how bad the situation would become. I think normally I would have given it 3 stars, but there are some many extra though provoking points right now that I have to give it 4.