Play Book Tag discussion

Non-fiction about numerous Americans who lived in Paris during the period 1830-1900. It fits my definition of a 3-star reading experience: overall, I liked it but didn’t care for certain aspects. The author covers a lot of ground here– artists, musicians, sculptors, diplomats, authors, doctors, entertainers, and socialites. It reads like a series of short stories of interesting people.

What I liked a lot:
• It was well-written
• Gave some very interesting observations about the work of artists such as Samuel Morse (before the telegraph), George Healy, Mary Cassatt, John Singer Sargent, and Augustus Saint-Gaudens (sculptor), which was one of the primary reasons I read the book
• Provided insight into medical history I had not previously known
• Inclusion of photos of people, artwork and architecture of the period

What I didn’t particularly care for:
• Due to the number of people, and the passing of time, it seemed a bit unfocused – it was difficult to tie together the lives of so many, some of whom received very little attention to the point one wonders why they were even included
• It ventured a bit far afield into the history of France during this era
• Covered what happened, but very little of WHY (which to me is rather important)

If you enjoy glimpses into the lives of people of a specific time-period, you may enjoy this book.

Ah, McCullough. I need to read more by him. I actually think I may give The Johnstown Flood a whirl next. I just learned a little more about the flood and am intrigued...

The Johnstown Flood is on my TBR as well. A few of my friends have recommended it.

Joy D wrote: "The Johnstown Flood is on my TBR as well. A few of my friends have recommended it."

We just read a case in law school and there was an editorial footnote about Johnstown. It was only like two sentences but it piqued my interest for sure!

Plus, it is narrated by Edward Hermann so I am ALL OVER IT!