Play Book Tag discussion

To Kill a Mockingbird
This topic is about To Kill a Mockingbird
18 views
November 2017: African American > To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee- 4 Stars

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Joi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Joi (missjoious) | 3970 comments Somehow, I've made it 26 years without reading this. Finally made it to the classic, and it was great. Not AMAZING OMG BEST BOOK EVER. But solid, great moral, I can see why this is a classic and how it shaped others opinions and feelings about the subject of racism over time. I do think that if I had never read any other book about race relations- it could be seen as revolutionary (as it probably was in 1960) - but now we are spoiled with amazing options for the subject who do the subject a bit more justice.

We see Scout's personal life- so some coming of age aspects (be courageous, whatnot), we see Atticus' trial- so part courtroom drama, and part moral compass-ethics and prejudice themes. Seems like a lot to cover in a 300 page book-but it does it well, and weaves the these and characters seamlessly together. The book and characters are quintessentially 'Southern'. Plus listening to the Sissy Spacek audio had a young, accented drawl to add to the fun.

I do think the entire subject of racism is over-simplified in the book. Yes, it's because the narrator is 8 years old. But also, that 8 year old had an abnormally large (almost unbelievable) vocabulary. I liked Scout, and enjoyed watching her grow up and become braver. However, I personally thought the courtroom plotline was the most interesting part in the book- and that took more of a backseat role-despite being the whole point of the book.


Book Concierge (tessabookconcierge) | 8422 comments I have never thought this book was about racism. Rather, I think it is more about personal integrity, about doing what is right when those around you disagree, even to the extent of risking your safety (and that of your family) to stand for the principles in which you believe.

Racism is the vehicle Lee uses to explore these issues.


Jgrace | 3944 comments Book Concierge wrote: "I have never thought this book was about racism. Rather, I think it is more about personal integrity, about doing what is right when those around you disagree, even to the extent of risking your sa..."

I agree with you about Mockingbird, BC. (at least somewhat, it's also about racism) But, I also think Jane Eyre is about personal integrity. I've always loved her. I don't need to like St. John or Rochester. I'm so sad that you don't like Jane as much as I do :(


message 4: by Joi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Joi (missjoious) | 3970 comments I think my interpretation of the book before I ever read it- was about the subject of racism- which is why my thoughts and review was geared much more towards that subject. That's the one negative about the classics- there are so much preconceived notions before even reading it because of everything you hear. The general public doesn't talk about Scout's progression, coming of age, and personal integrity as much as it does about the trial.

Definitely need to read Jane Eyre- and keep that in mind!


Karin | 9232 comments I'm glad you enjoyed this! I went longer than 26 years before I read this book, so I understand! I was over 40 when I finally read it and wondered why, even though I'd heard of it so often, I'd never read it.


back to top