2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #1 discussion

Frank and Sarah were convinced Letitia killed Edmund. Did you have a clue that Granger was the killer? How about that finesse move of Sarah’s where she told Symington and Letitia that they’d only accused her to flesh out Granger’s confession?

I had toyed with the idea that it might have been Granger because he was behaving so oddly but I couldn't think of a reason for him to have done it.
And Sarah is one smart cookie - she always thinks of ways to mould the truth to suit:)

Granger never entered my mind. That caught me completely off guard.

Sarah really is quick on her feet. That could have been disastrous for Frank.

When Granger was sick, I thought he had poisoned Calvin and accidentally ingested a little bit of the arsenic himself (enough to make him ill). Another idea I had was that whoever killed Calvin was now trying to kill Granger. But, I couldn't figure out why anyone would want to kill Granger, so I kind of gave up on that idea. I never thought that Granger killed Edmund.

At least you had Granger in the mix!

I never thought about Granger, mostly because having the butler as the culprit seems kind of against the rules.

I never suspected Granger but there were clues to his devotion to her early on. I actually was getting tired of hearing about how Letitia could practically mesmerize men with her beauty and feminine ways. So I'm not completely surprised Granger killed her husband but I still though Amos was a more likely culprit.

I think, by the end, we were HOPING it was Amos😉