The Sword and Laser discussion

So, i finally finished yesterday and i have to admit I didn't like it very much. Some parts were, in my opinion, really slow and repetitive and bored me.
I would have much more enjoyed the story as a short story.
What are your thoughts? Would you have preferred it shorter or did you want to find out more about the world?

I thought that most of the flashbacks, especially those at the beginning of the sections dealing with characters other than Aster, could have been cut out without losing anything.

Ivi_kiwi wrote: "Would you have preferred it shorter or did you want to find out more about the world?"

I actually wished it could have been just a little longer. I felt that the very end (view spoiler)[(after Lieutenant's death) (hide spoiler)] was a little rushed. I could have used a bit more closure for the characters, but I really enjoyed it up until that point.

Funny, I read this in 2 days... didn't seem long at all :-)

I'm listening to the audio book. I have about 90 mins left and kind of wish it had ended 30 mins ago. It's not exciting me or keeping my interest, which is a shame because I really wanted to like it.

I wish the ending were longer, too. I really enjoyed the book (though it was definitely painful to read a times) and I thought the length was fine overall, but I would have liked even a few more pages added on to the end. I just really want to know what happens after (view spoiler)[Aster makes it to Earth, both to her and to the people on Matilda. They're still slowing down on their way to Earth, right? So do they make it and meet up with Aster eventually? (hide spoiler)]

I enjoyed the book, especially the audio book (I read half, listened to half). I felt like maybe the beginning was too long, the middle was just right, and the end was too short. Just when I really got into the book, it was over.

Jennifer wrote: "I wish the ending were longer, too. I really enjoyed the book (though it was definitely painful to read a times) and I thought the length was fine overall, but I would have liked even a few more pa..."

(view spoiler)[I think they all just kept going past the Earth and she was the only one who made it, which is pretty depressing. I guess it fits though? (hide spoiler)]

I wish it had been longer. I wanted more time with these people, and I really really want to know what happens next.

Ruth (tilltab) wrote: "I wish it had been longer. I wanted more time with these people, and I really really want to know what happens next."

See, I liked the people, but I have no idea what I was supposed to get from the book. I felt confused at the end.

I know what you mean. It isn't a simple story, and I'm not sure there is really a point to it. I was a little confused at the end too. It seemed a bit rushed. I loved the book so much, which is why I would have liked it to be longer. I feel like there was something more that needed exploring for it to be fully satisfying.