Flights of Fantasy discussion

This topic is about
On a Red Station, Drifting
Archived Group Reads
>
April 2019 Mod's Choice BotM: On a Red Station, Drifting

The History:(view spoiler)
Stories in Publication order:
(view spoiler)
Chronological Order (plus details from author) (view spoiler)

By the way, thanks for choosing the better of the English edition covers for the linked edition. The other one is... not appealing to me at all. My favorite though is this one:


Right?? I'd pick that up from a bookstore shelf. I wouldn't with any of the others. I'm not into anime, so this cover does nothing for me, and the other one looks like it was slapped together in photoshop, so... no.
ETA: I do know that anime is Japanese and this is Chinese based, but the style looks anime-ish to me, so I'd still pass it by. LOL

But first, a series order question, is it necessary to read the shorter works published prior to Red Station or can I go back and read it later?


But first, a series order question, is it ..."
You're welcome!
And what Becky said. The shorts are more interconnected stories + alternative history worldbuilding.

Me, too!!!!! That would be amazing, tbh


:-D


But, I did read a few pages of this, and I'm intrigued and liked what I read, so... I'll be reading this next I think. :)


https://www.audible.com/pd/On-a-Red-S...



WOOT! This would make a good combo.
I just don't know why they don't sell edition packages. It's an easy money maker. 1 HB, 1 ebook, 1 audio for 1 purchase. I'd do it for a lot of books. Roughly, everything Ilona Andrews ever wrote...

I'm guessing because they probably don't have ebooks and audio versions available to release at the same time. I'm looking at a book now that's been out since August of last year, but ebook (at least kindle) and audio format (at least through Audible) isn't available until April 30th.
LAME. I GOT CREDITS TO BURN, PEOPLE! :P
And, I don't think that most people are like us and would multi-format it. I LOVE doing that when the book is good... total immersion. Sigh.

Right? Like, let's plan ahead, people! You know that you're going to release the book on X date, so let's make sure to have ebook and audio versions available that date as well to maximize sales and readership.

OMG, Becky. I loved so much reading while being read to. It was amazing and it felt like I was watching a movie.

.."
Have you ever read the Brainship Series before? That's actually how I think of the Mindships (even though they are not the same).

This novella was my first exposure to it--imo de Bodard does a good job giving the reader enough basic info to understand the situation with the war, and to hang the characters' story on.
MrsJoseph wrote: "Have you ever read the Brainship Series before?"
I've heard of them but not read them. The couple of other things of McCaffrey's I've tried were fun, especially the first Crystal Singer.
Book 2:
(view spoiler)


That's on my list, too. I have a hardcopy of it.

(view spoiler)
Here's a question for those who've finished: (view spoiler)
I don't disagree with MrsJ that (view spoiler)
A few too many similes imo. She and/or her editors could've pared out a few instances of (view spoiler)

[spoilers removed]
Here's a question for those who've finished: [spoilers removed]
I don't disagree with MrsJ that [spoilers removed]
A few too many similes imo. She and/or her editors co..."
DONE!
Quyen & Lihn (view spoiler)
HA: (view spoiler)
I do agree that de Bodard's writing can be almost too lyrical. Sometimes too much is too much.

I think that this review aptly sums up a lot of my feelings toward Quyen/Lihn's relationship. (spoilers for story)
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

That's my basic take on their relationship through most of the story. I agree with your interpretation that they each made missteps (view spoiler) .
On the Honored Ancestress: (view spoiler) ;)

Much like you, and the writer of this review, I didn't get it either. It's a tricky thing because I'm really not strong when it comes to (view spoiler) . So it's hard to say if the examples of it in the story are kinda weak, or if I'm just dumb.
Ha, Olga really has a hate-on for Quyen.

I'm glad you enjoyed it! What was your favorite part?
I can honestly say that one of the things I enjoyed was the description of the tech and the fraught relationship between Quyen. In an odd way, of course. I liked it because while there was such extreme jealously and dislike on both sides, it was related only to their relationship with each other (instead of who was prettier or a man).

I could understand the relationship in its early stages: (view spoiler) But that isn't stated in the story itself so I'm just guessing.
The scene/conversation after (view spoiler) lost me. I wasn't sure what had changed or what was trying to be conveyed in the dialogue. And you don't see them together after that iirc.

I could understand the relationship itself in its early stages: [spoilers removed] But that isn't stated in the story itself so I'm just guessing.
The scene/co..."
Right. That's how I felt. Like, I got them being friendly and talking to each other - (view spoiler)
That conversation (view spoiler)


A triumph here is a decimation there.
I get the whole "thread of sorrow" thingy that Tolkien encouraged and put forth as required...but I admit that it's not particularly fun.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Citadel of Weeping Pearls (other topics)The Tea Master and the Detective (other topics)
The Tea Master and the Detective (other topics)
Stazione rossa (other topics)
The Lost Xuyan Bride (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Aliette de Bodard (other topics)Aliette de Bodard (other topics)
Aliette de Bodard (other topics)
This book has been in print since December 2012 so there should be many different editions available. Please check your local library and/or favorite book retailer.
This book is the first [book/novella length] entry in Xuya Universe series. There are a lot of shorts that precede this book but this book stands alone as a first in series. The history (from the preceding short stories) is enriching but not required to enjoy On a Red Station, Drifting.
Please remember to use spoiler tags < spoiler > < /spoiler > when discussing.