Everything For a Good Book discussion

This is March BOTM. This is the place where we will discuss what we like, love, hate, or despise.

I rlly liked 'one of us is lying', but (this is stupid) i picked up the book and thought...(after reading the blurb), 'what if simon commited suicide? That would be a nice murder'.

No comments after finishing it lol.

It’s not stupid... it is just ur opinion

No, i mean, i actually managed to guess what happened

skills

Wow, i guess

May I ask when this starts?

In March i guess. Even tho ive already read it twice lol

Lol but yes it starts in March

Any certain date? I won’t be able to read it for another two weeks.

No, just as long as you finish before March 31. Tho u don’t have to read it at all if you don’t want to

My other group I have voted for a book I don’t want to read and I really want to read this one.

Okay 👌🏼 that sounds great! I am glad that you are excited!

It should be good!

Its good

I've already read this book twice and i loveeee it

Same

Awesome!

Forthencho Pacino’s Gal wrote: "Any certain date? I won’t be able to read it for another two weeks."

Same here. My copy is coming in around the same time so I can't start right away

How is this going to go? Do we have to check in at a certain time to discuss? Are there specific q's we have to answer every week? Or do we wait until the end of March to discuss?

I am currently reading it, its good but nothing, in my opinion, is really AMAZING about it. I'm looking at 3.5 stars now, maybe it will change once it starts to unravel.

Abby wrote: "How is this going to go? Do we have to check in at a certain time to discuss? Are there specific q's we have to answer every week? Or do we wait until the end of March to discuss?"

We will check in once everyone who is reading it has finished so that there is no spoilers for people who are a little bit behind.

Genevieve wrote: "I am currently reading it, its good but nothing, in my opinion, is really AMAZING about it. I'm looking at 3.5 stars now, maybe it will change once it starts to unravel."

Let's hope it does Genevieve! I hope that you do enjoy it more as it goes on!

I really did like this book. I liked the twist at the end.

I've read this book and was certainly not expecting that at the end, I was suspecting Janae halfway through the book and once even Bronwyn's younger sister, lol. It was a pretty interesting read, tho.

Yashaa wrote: "I've read this book and was certainly not expecting that at the end, I was suspecting Janae halfway through the book and once even Bronwyn's younger sister, lol. It was a pretty interesting read, tho."

(view spoiler)[ i know...i wasnt actually expecting it to be suicide lol (hide spoiler)]

Oh and if u liked this book try out two can keep a secret:

Its by the same author and very good, a murder mysterey like one of us is lying

Slytherin_Forever23 wrote: "Yashaa wrote: "I've read this book and was certainly not expecting that at the end, I was suspecting Janae halfway through the book and once even Bronwyn's younger sister, lol. It was a pretty inte..."
ikr...was slightly disappointed lol but other things - like the others involved with Simon - sort of topped it off

Yashaa wrote: "Slytherin_Forever23 wrote: "Yashaa wrote: "I've read this book and was certainly not expecting that at the end, I was suspecting Janae halfway through the book and once even Bronwyn's younger siste..."

Overall, it was good tho. I liked 'Two can keep a secret' better tho. The ending was more unexpected.

Slytherin_Forever23 wrote: "Yashaa wrote: "Slytherin_Forever23 wrote: "Yashaa wrote: "I've read this book and was certainly not expecting that at the end, I was suspecting Janae halfway through the book and once even Bronwyn'..."

Haven't read that yet, it's about Bronwyn's sister right?

Can we spoil in this chat?

I read this a couple years back and am going to try to read the sequel this month, but some of the stuff that bothered me is extreme spoilers.

Ummmm I would say no spoilers

I've to try and find a copy first, dunno where I can find it...

I think there is a bunch at Barnes and Noble. There is probably a copy or two at your local library too

Warning, if one of us is lying is your favorite book don't continue to read.

Okay, so I finished One of us is lying yesterday and am currently reading One of us is next. I did not like One of us is lying very much, I don't know if it was because I went into the book with very high expectations or something. If so, that was my fault, but in general, I thought the whole book was slightly boring, even when it started to unravel it was just slow and nothing made me go "Ohhhh myyyy goshhhh" you know? I didn't like the end very much either. I don't know what happened but I am reading the sequel and so far, it's better than the first.

Edit: Finished the sequel and thought I was much better than the first.

Mollie wrote: "I loved One Of Us Is Lying. I tried Two Can Keep A Secret but I didn't like that one as much. I want to read One Of Us Is Next. I feel that it kind of sparked my love for murder mysteries and thril..."

One of Us is Next is like really good, I almost like it better than One of Us is lying though

Well hey that can be April’s BOTM!

Everyone who is reading it... what are ur thoughts?

Trying to get my hands on this book...

I’ve read it and highly enjoyed it, 5 stars!

Slytherin_Forever23 wrote: "Oh and if u liked this book try out two can keep a secret:

Its by the same author and very good, a murder mysterey like one of us is lying"

Isn't that the sequel?

Kiley wrote: "Abby wrote: "How is this going to go? Do we have to check in at a certain time to discuss? Are there specific q's we have to answer every week? Or do we wait until the end of March to discuss?"

We..."

Got it!

Ya! I just finished One of us is Lying!

I've managed to get the book!!! and i have started to read it now,.. already sounds interesting!!!

Yes! It’s very engaging throughout the entire book

It's one of the only murder mysteries that I've liked!

Same!

anyone read One of Us is Next recently?