Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2015 Challenge Prompts
>
Prompt 20: A book at the bottom of your to-read list
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Ann
(new)
Dec 26, 2014 10:24AM

reply
|
flag

You could choose a book that you have had for a long time, but haven't read yet.





Did you ever read it?
I just finished Slaughterhouse-Five. I didnt like it. But after reading the reviews I see it was mostly me. And I feel a little bad because Vonnegut was actually at Dresden. But I cant help it if it bored me to death. It was at the bottom of my TBR list for a reason.







Anyway, I decided that a book qualifies, that I purchased more than ten years ago with the firm intention to read it promptly and which, for some reason, have stayed untouched since. Unfortunately several books qualify in that way...
So anyway for that prompt I read The Sportswriter by Richard Ford. Quite a depressing book, which suited me fine; a good novel once you get into it.
And by the way I was quite surprised by the number of reviewers on Goodread that stated they didn't like the book because the main character wasn't likable. Wow! 19th Century called; they want their reviewers back. Is the requirement that all characters be likable? Only the main one? Only the narrator because since he says "I" it's just like I was him? Or what..?

Though of course the book you read is a literary character study (from what I can glean from the Goodreads page). It's possible people who typically like reading sports genre fiction - books about athletic heroes - were misled by the title of the piece. They came looking for a read about the glamour of sports writing to find a meditation on life by a not so glamorous protagonist. Or maybe they just didn't like the guy. Sometimes a work isn't interesting enough to people to justify the actions or tone of the characters. If an unlikeable protagonist doesn't seem to be saying anything new or important with his unlikeablenesss than he's just kind of a jerk for no reason. Sometimes authors can pull off characters like that and sometimes they can't, and even so your mileage may vary based on your own personal experiences interacting with people and stylistic proclivities.
But I also totally get what you are saying. Sometimes people definitely dismiss books or characters too easily. They don't peel back enough layers of the onion.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Sportswriter (other topics)The Lying Game (other topics)
Looking for Alaska (other topics)
The Wings of the Dove (other topics)
Beyond the Storm (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Richard Ford (other topics)Michael Stanley (other topics)