Heroes/Readers of Olympus discussion

52 views
This or That! > This or that:Piper or Annabeth?

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Yasmin (new)

Yasmin Silva I like the two SO much
But I think that I like more of Piper!
Because she is Brave ,and don’t care about Beauty!


message 2: by bookishcarli, Group creator/ #1 Percabeth shipper/ Daughter of Athena (new)

bookishcarli | 1392 comments Mod
☀️Yasmin☀️ wrote: "I like the two SO much
But I think that I like more of Piper!
Because she is Brave ,and don’t care about Beauty!"


Good point, but the same could be said for Annabeth. Plus, Annabeth is way smarter and stronger than Piper, and and I think you can can relate with Annabeth more than Piper. So that's why I like Annabeth best.


message 3: by Aimee (new)

Aimee (hufflepuff93) | 16 comments AnnabethChase wrote: "☀️Yasmin☀️ wrote: "I like the two SO much
But I think that I like more of Piper!
Because she is Brave ,and don’t care about Beauty!"

Good point, but the same could be said for Annabeth. Plus, Anna..."


Agreed, Annabeth is the best


message 4: by Gwyneth (new)

Gwyneth Bare (gwenirelandb) I like annabeth better... but tbh both of them aren't really my fav.


message 5: by Rylee (new)

Rylee Me too, I think Annabeth is better.


message 6: by Yasmin (new)

Yasmin Silva Ok😁


message 7: by Kendall (new)

Kendall (kendallruman) | 44 comments I definitely like Annabeth more because she is just a lot more relatable. Like, piper try’s to hide her beauty in the beginning, by cutting her hair choppy and by wearing clothes that don’t make her stand out. I feel like Annabeth is more relatable, and I like that when I’m reading and I can relate to the characters


*·˚elizabeth*·˚ Annabeth, we have many things in common and i feel she's way stronger than Piper. Also since the beggining I had a connection with Annabeth, with Piper I never could have one (just in few moments)


message 9: by Calypso ♡ (new)

Calypso ♡ Annabeth


 ̷R̷̷e̷̷y̷ (detectingeagle310) | 1554 comments AnnabethChase wrote: "☀️Yasmin☀️ wrote: "I like the two SO much
But I think that I like more of Piper!
Because she is Brave ,and don’t care about Beauty!"

Good point, but the same could be said for Annabeth. Plus, Anna..."


I agree. Annabeth !


message 11: by Tayven (new)

Tayven Ross | 540 comments Anabeth but piper is amazing too


message 12: by LyraFirefly (new)

LyraFirefly Annabeth, but both are great characters.


message 13: by Rory Gilmore (new)

Rory Gilmore (artemis1) | 93 comments Hands down Annabeth


message 14: by Ana (new)

Ana (anacristilu) Pipes!!


message 15: by Johanna ♡ (new)

Johanna ♡  | 19 comments I love them both but if I had to choose one it would have to be Annabeth!


message 16: by sophia (new)

sophia | 28 comments They are both comfort characters of mine so this is a hard choice! Annabeth is strong and smart, with logic and wits. Piper is also strong and smart, but has more emotional intelligence and maturity. I can’t choose! I love them both


message 17: by [deleted user] (last edited Apr 06, 2021 05:13AM) (new)

Annabeth


message 18: by Lydia (new)

Lydia | 13 comments I feel like Annabeth is more relatable 😅


message 19: by booklover024 (new)

booklover024 | 6 comments Annabeth but I love love love Piper so that was a really hard choice for me


message 20: by Kat (new)

Kat (kat_hudson) | 2 comments Definitely Annabeth for me. The first series is so nostalgic for me, and Annabeth has been a major fictional role model for me my whole life. Annabeth is definitely more relatable as well. I love Piper but I feel like her character has some internal misogyny, which is just the way she was written but makes me a little mad. But I really love them both, Annabeth has just always been my favorite.


message 21: by Caitlyn (new)

Caitlyn (ghostqueendaughterofhades) | 19 comments Annabeth, Piper is great and all but I just feel like Annabeth is better


message 22: by Queen V™ (new)

Queen V™ I'm honestly not a big fan of either, but between the two it's definitely Annabeth.


message 23: by Kanomi Okina (new)

Kanomi Okina ||Magic always comes with a price|| (goodreadscomkanomi_okina) I can’t decide. I like both of them.


message 24: by Blitzstyle_ (new)

Blitzstyle_ Love Annabeth since her first line (“you drool when you sleep”)


message 25: by stu (new)

stu  (blobmustardsprinkles) Honestly, I don't really like either much... but if I had to pick I'd probably pick Piper... I dunno why....


message 26: by Mpia (new)

Mpia Annabeth


back to top