The Garden of Books discussion

How it works?
You take away 2 points from a character you dislike, and give them to one you like. Every time a character ends up with 0 points, they are kicked out of the game. At the end, only one will be left, who will be the winner.


Let's start!
Tessa Gray - 20
Will Herondale - 20
Jem Carstairs - 20
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 20

Tessa Gray - 22*
Will Herondale - 20
Jem Carstairs - 20
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 18*

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 20
Jem Carstairs - 22*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 16*

jem gets all my love <3

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 22*
Jem Carstairs - 22
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 14*

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 22
Jem Carstairs - 24*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 10*

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 24*
Jem Carstairs - 24
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 8*

Personally, I am on Team Will, but I love Jem too.

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 24
Jem Carstairs - 26*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 6*

idk what team I'm on, I'm currently reading clockwork prince for the first time. i just know I love jem with all my heart haha

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 26*
Jem Carstairs - 26
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 4*


It's your first time? Nice. I've read this series many times and loved it. I love Jem, but I'll always be on Team Will.

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 26
Jem Carstairs - 28*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 2*

I've been loving the series so much. which is shocking, both from where my tastes usually lie and just what I've heard about cassandra claire. the consensus seems to be that this is better than the mortal instruments, so I'm glad I chose this series over that one. I'm listening to them as an audiobook and it's been awesome.

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 28*
Jem Carstairs - 28
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20
Axel Mortmain - 0*

Nice. What have you heard about Cassandra Clare?

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 28
Jem Carstairs - 30*
Jessamine Lovelace - 18*
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

well, first of all, the ""you're my blood," he said soundlessly and without any humor" thing...yeah...not loving the incest adjacent plot. also just that her writing was poor and the plots and characters were basic and lacking. I'm delighted that the writing is actually much better and most (tessa's a little...ehh) characters are very well done.

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 28
Jem Carstairs - 28*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20*
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20


Personally, I kind of don't agree, but we all have our opinions.

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 28
Jem Carstairs - 30*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -18*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 30*
Jem Carstairs - 30
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -16*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 32*
Jem Carstairs - 30
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -14*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 34*
Jem Carstairs - 30
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -12*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 34
Jem Carstairs - 32*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -10*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 36*
Jem Carstairs - 32
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -8*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 36
Jem Carstairs - 34*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -6*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 38*
Jem Carstairs - 34
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -4*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 38
Jem Carstairs - 36*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -2*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40*
Jem Carstairs - 36
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Nate Gray -0*
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40
Jem Carstairs - 38*
Jessamine Lovelace - 18*
Sophie Collins - 20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 20
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40
Jem Carstairs - 38
Jessamine Lovelace - 20*
Sophie Collins - 20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 18*
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40
Jem Carstairs - 40*
Jessamine Lovelace - 18*
Sophie Collins - 20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 18
Gideon Lightwood - 20

I can't remember which lightwood brother I don't like lol

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40
Jem Carstairs - 38*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20*
Sophie Collins - 20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 18
Gideon Lightwood - 20

Tessa Gray - 22
Will Herondale - 40
Jem Carstairs - 40*
Jessamine Lovelace - 20
Sophie Collins - 20
Charlotte Branwell - 20
Gabriel Lightwood - 20
Cecily Herondale - 20
Henry Branwell - 18
Gideon Lightwood - 18*