Book Nerds :D discussion

55 views
☉Big Debates☉ > Is Being Immortal a Blessing or a Curse?

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by [deleted user] (new)

What do you think? I think it’s a curse. I, personally, would never like to live forever but that’s just me!


Astra - Halloween Wendigo (No more groups unless I'll like it please) | 19 comments I would think it's a blessing but that's because then I would know what happens in the future


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

That’s a good point!


message 4: by Luna (new)

Luna (luna13) A curse. Everyone you know will die at one point and you’ll be left lonely. And it’ll be pretty scary if some sort of asteroid crashes and you’re all alone.


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

blessing, but I'll probably run away from my family's at a young age cause I don't want to feel sad when the die, so better no emotional connection.


Wren (Fariywren) Hiatus❥ | 528 comments •JMCDC• wrote: "i just personally think that, although being human is our nature, i can't handle pain forever. emotional pain or whatever. i don't really mind much if i don't live to see slides from buildings and ..."

good point!


message 8: by [deleted user] (new)

ohh, ya I get you ....I just didn't think of it that deeply xD I'm scared of dying so..


message 9: by Amrita (new)

Amrita | 74 comments I think both.

A Blessing: To live forever. See the changes that occurs in the society, the improvement. I would get to meet and talk to people of different generations. If I live forever, I'd have enough time to see the entire world, explore, take part in various things in various ages. To know the world like no one else.

A Curse: All these things I mentioned will only be possible if I don't get attached to things. Like I get attached to a person, they'll die one day. Things I love, will change, maybe for worse. Maybe I won't see good things in future, maybe I'll witness an apocalypse.

So, you see, if I got the chance I would love to live forever only if I have the ability to end my life whenever I want to : )


message 10: by Samiksha (new)

Samiksha Bhattacharjee (samiksha23) | 72 comments It's a curse if you're the only immortal


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

I think it's a curse.


message 12: by Alexandria, The Third Book Nerd (last edited Oct 07, 2021 07:00AM) (new)

Alexandria K (percabethprincess8729) | 5309 comments Mod
Curse because then you have to deal with people's stupidity and rudeness for all eternity. No thank you.


message 13: by [deleted user] (new)

Alexandria wrote: "Curse because then you have to deal with people's stupidity and rudeness for all eternity. No thank you."

lol exactly


message 14: by vi (new)

vi (aashvi) till now everyone looked at it from a smaller perspective and I agree with everyone that says it's a curse. but if we also look at it from a larger perspective, immortality would mean an increase in human population which is already a problem causing multiple other global issues. if anything human civilisation would be doomed and the world would end sooner, so immortality wouldn't do any good.

and to anyone saying it's a blessing because you can explore the world, that is only possible if you have a lot of money.


camilla(taylor's version) (camillareadings) | 709 comments It depends, because for some people that would be a godsend! But for others who would actually kind of do anything to live forever it would make perfect sense.
But for me, this is not good because everything has its time so living longer than expected is not good in my opinion!


message 16: by [deleted user] (new)

Here's the thing. Do you mean immortal as in stuck on Earth, immortal? Or as in when we die we go up to live in Heaven immortal?
Because:
Stuck on Earth: CURSE
Go to Heaven: BLESSING


message 17: by Alexandria, The Third Book Nerd (new)

Alexandria K (percabethprincess8729) | 5309 comments Mod
Maura wrote: "Here's the thing. Do you mean immortal as in stuck on Earth, immortal? Or as in when we die we go up to live in Heaven immortal?
Because:
Stuck on Earth: CURSE
Go to Heaven: BLESSING"


THIS!! 😄


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

Maura wrote: "Here's the thing. Do you mean immortal as in stuck on Earth, immortal? Or as in when we die we go up to live in Heaven immortal?
Because:
Stuck on Earth: CURSE
Go to Heaven: BLESSING"


I mean earth, but I guess you could go to the moon or something. You could also probably go to other planets because you can’t die, you can service I guess. But good point!


message 19: by Hailey (new)

Hailey  (hva333) I think it's a curse. Some of you guys might think being immortal is a blessing, but I personally would not want to keep on living if everybody that I know and love is dead. It'd just make living pointless.


message 20: by Nix (new)

Nix both kind of, a blessing because you get to live many years and see many things and a curse because you watch all the people you love die and what if you wanna stop living and you can't so you'd be miserable


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

(im gonna elaborate on why I think its a curse :) )

Although yeah you get to live to see all the things, would you really want to? Like one, you're gonna be alone. Two just because you're alive doesn't mean you're thriving. Realistically, you would have an elderly body, so you can't just run around traveling and experiencing life around you. Three, Life is a journey, a book. All books have an end, so if you are immortal, you're become kinda stuck. Bonus: (this part is more religious so if your not into that my elaboration ends here) You're still gonna die when Jesus comes back soooooo.


message 22: by Ayathma (new)

Ayathma | 607 comments Luna wrote: "A curse. Everyone you know will die at one point and you’ll be left lonely. And it’ll be pretty scary if some sort of asteroid crashes and you’re all alone."
I Agree too


✨ tazannah - not accepting friend requests ✨ (tazannahgresheld) Yeah I agree with Luna- everyone you love dies and if you live forever you'll just watch people come and go-


message 24: by Emily (new)

Emily (emilythegoatnerd) | 25 comments It's a curse cause then while everyone dies and go to Heaven, you are stuck here on earth.


message 25: by Shawna (new)

Shawna Finnigan (sugoishawn) | 389 comments It's a curse because you have to experience everyone you love dying


message 26: by Alexandria, The Third Book Nerd (new)

Alexandria K (percabethprincess8729) | 5309 comments Mod
Shawna wrote: "It's a curse because you have to experience everyone you love dying"

Oooof


✧˚*̥ Kamryn *̥˚✧ | 60 comments Both tbh


message 28: by ●tk●, The First Book Nerd (new)

●tk● (thenonexistentchild) | 2066 comments Mod
It’s a blessing if everyone became immortal but a curse because the world would be overpopulated. And if your the only immortal person, it would be a curse to see all your loved ones go away but a blessing because you get to experience history and the future as well.


message 29: by [deleted user] (new)

Definitely a curse


message 30: by Princess (new)

Princess Night | 100 comments curse


back to top