Reading the Chunksters discussion

15 views
Our Mutual Friend > Our Mutual Friend - Week 5

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Hugh (new)

Hugh (bodachliath) | 316 comments Mod
We are now into Book Two, and this section covers the first four chapters.

My chapter summaries:
(view spoiler)


message 2: by Xan (new)

Xan  Shadowflutter (shadowflutter) Chapter 1

Tommy Twopence and schoolmaster Headstone. I nearly split a gut when Headstone played with his buttonhole and stopped in mid sentence to stare at his finger.

There's more than a little of Pip in Charley in this chapter. Perhaps the school or his rising "expectations" has done it to him, worrying aloud to his sister how she may hold him back living with whom she lives, after all she's sacrificed for him.

Well, I think we know where Eugene disappeared to after learning of Gaffer's death.


message 3: by Brian E (last edited Jan 04, 2022 11:17AM) (new)

Brian E Reynolds | 148 comments In this section, I enjoyed the Lammies scene the most. They may turn out to act as a lightly connected and slightly humorous sideshow to the activity operating on the main stage. Trollope also often has such characters in his longer novels.


message 4: by Xan (last edited Jan 07, 2022 10:05AM) (new)

Xan  Shadowflutter (shadowflutter) Part II, Chapter 4

The Lammles, those devils. They get along so well -- whether complimenting one another in public or tearing one another's throat out in private -- that they are just too perfect. If only they recognized this, they might become husband and wife for real. I mean what other man or woman could match the other's wit witticism for witticism?

Oh, and another point regarding our Lammles. They do wine and dine for a couple without money, don't they? However do they manage it? And then there is the carriage. For two people who don't have a shilling between them, they spare no expense. Whose pocket is it coming out of?

Oh, and before I forget, I love how Mrs Lammle returns her husband's affectionate kisses on her hand with affectionate kisses on his pocket watch chain. She's going to get silver poisoning. But overall she performed so well that her husband sent her to bed early.

Fledgeby (Fledgling?) and Georgina are another couple too perfect for one another. If they were to marry, they would consummate the marriage in, oh, say, some time in the first 5 years. No, strike that. It will take 5 years to look at each other.

That's it!! That's the Lammle's game. Georgina and Fledgeby are so incompetent together, that if they were to marry, the Lammles would have to move in with them.

I had a lot of fun reading this chapter.


message 5: by Jess (new)

Jess Penhallow | 20 comments The story is really getting going for me now (despite the political chapter which I really couldn't follow). I love the character of Jenny Wren, a true Dickensian character who just jumps off the page and I'm enjoying the back and forth sniping of the Lammles. I think they actually quite like each other really.


message 6: by Hugh (last edited Jan 09, 2022 02:07AM) (new)

Hugh (bodachliath) | 316 comments Mod
The way Fledgeby is introduced is interesting in retrospect, but to say more would be spoilerish.


message 7: by Linda (new)

Linda | 1425 comments Chapter 1
I'm still not sure what to think of schoolmaster Headstone, and probably partly because Dickens doesn't seem to have a lot of caring schoolmasters, many or most tend to be strict and simply part of the system. But, he seems to have had a bad upbringing but is now looking out for students like Charley, so maybe he is doing the best he can. Also, he appears to maybe fancy Lizzie, but is totally oblivious to Miss Peecher.


Xan wrote: "There's more than a little of Pip in Charley in this chapter. Perhaps the school or his rising "expectations" has done it to him, worrying aloud to his sister how she may hold him back living with whom she lives, after all she's sacrificed for him."

Yes, I cringed when Charley started speaking to Lizzie about her holding him back.


message 8: by Linda (new)

Linda | 1425 comments Yes, the Lammles chapter was great. I was also curious about where their money was coming from. And I love how everyone is jealous of the house they have yet to build.

Xan - I’m laughing at your timeline for Georiania and Fledgeby’s marriage to be consummated if it were to occur. 😂


back to top