2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

As Garrett is walking through a rough neighborhood to visit a patient, she’s confronted by three soldiers who threaten to rape her. As she begins her own assault on them, Ethan Ransom emerges and helps to finish them off. Do you think she could have handled them on her own, despite the challenge?

I thought she could have given them a good fight, but three men, even drunk, would have been hard to completely overcome. I was glad when Ethan intervened.

My feelings exactly. I believe Garrett was in trouble. One, maybe two men. But three soldiers? She needed a gun.

Exactly! Her cane wasn't going to completely incapacitate all three of them. Her best bet would have been to get them all down and run like crazy. But I didn't see that happening because she believed in her skills and that she could take them all on.

I loved her self confidence but…

I agree with you guys. She may have been lucky enough to take down one or even two. Three just seems like too many for one person to handle.

I agree with all of you. She would have given them a good fight, but I don't think she would take all three down.

I agree with all of you also. I don't think she could have taken on 3 men. She definitely would have tried...