2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

After learning Sandra was a professional psychic (Psychic Sandy) and had a session the night before, Kim and Bryant visit the host who wasn’t all that truthful about what happened. In fact, all the participants initially lied about some part of their circumstances or behavior at the session. Did any of them get added to your suspect list? Why did they all choose to be so secretive?

I added all of them to my list. There was something suspicious about each one. I knew they all needed to be examined closer. I think they all lied because they didn't get what they wanted from the session.

The host was at the top of mine. I didn’t include Betts but I sure added her husband! Emily the cancer survivor was the least likely. Strangely, I was ambivalent about Rose. Lisa, the business executive was only on there because of the violence in her past.

I found it bizarre that they were all lying about something.

I agree Emily was low on the list, but I thought maybe a psychic said she would beat the cancer. When she came out of remission, I thought that revenge was possible. If she didn't have long to live, she would never serve time for the murders. It was lame, but this was a strange group.

Thanks for that perspective. It is indeed logical!