forever and evermore swifties discussion

87 views
bookish things:) > Books you won't accept criticism on... but understand why people criticise them

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by grace , oh my god, shes insane (new)

grace  (thestateofgraceee) | 1383 comments Normal people and the love hypothesis 😭


autumn ✶ (ia) | 77 comments if he had been with me! I totally get why people don't like it but it's perfect in my eyes


mona ♡ (wishbone edition) (mona_tv) we were liars

everyone hates on it so much but to me it was really interesting


message 4: by vivie♡ {hiatus} (last edited Sep 14, 2023 02:25PM) (new)

vivie♡ {hiatus} (ucymz9tq_kat6nzetrd1a-ag) A Court of Thorns and Roses and Shatter Me
I love them both sm but I understand they might have flaws


message 5: by kitcantspell (new)

kitcantspell ( semi hiatus ) | 11 comments percy jackson and the olympians ( its a comfort book series and i wont stand for slander )

they both die at the end ( why is this getting hate )


message 6: by millie, lovermore (new)

millie (milliee_rose) | 1317 comments the hating game and book lovers


mona ♡ (wishbone edition) (mona_tv) kit !! wrote: "percy jackson and the olympians ( its a comfort book series and i wont stand for slander )

they both die at the end ( why is this getting hate )"


honestly i agree with they both die at the end i loved it why do ppl hate it?


A_Reading_Obsession | 167 comments King of Pride (people find it boring), Stalking the Jack the Ripper (it's called character development), The Hunger Games (if you hate it, I don't want to understand why 😭)


message 9: by millie, lovermore (new)

millie (milliee_rose) | 1317 comments ♡ mona ♡ (taylor's version) wrote: "kit !! wrote: "percy jackson and the olympians ( its a comfort book series and i wont stand for slander )

they both die at the end ( why is this getting hate )"

honestly i agree with they both d..."


i didnt like it but i think its because the ending was a given, and since they only had a day the plotline didnt have tine to develop in such a short space of time so it was a bit boring


Scarlett (Taylor’s version) | 12 comments A court of thorns and roses. Personally I rlly loved it and it’s one of my favourite books, but I 100% understand the criticism on it and I get why people dislike it. There r definitely far better series’ out there, but it’s one of the books that got me back into reading so I love it


message 11: by Arianna (new)

Arianna | 212 comments Six of crows & shatter me:)


vivie♡ {hiatus} (ucymz9tq_kat6nzetrd1a-ag) Scarlett (Taylor’s version) wrote: "A court of thorns and roses. Personally I rlly loved it and it’s one of my favourite books, but I 100% understand the criticism on it and I get why people dislike it. There r definitely far better ..."

Yessss literally


message 13: by molly (new)

molly | 237 comments One of us is lying, I love it so much but it’s not everyone’s cup of tea


message 14: by kitcantspell (new)

kitcantspell ( semi hiatus ) | 11 comments to bounce off of millie , totally understand that !! what doesnt make sense to me though is people saying that that book was bad when they love if he had been w me , cause theyre similar but its a given death ykyky


message 15: by zia b (new)

zia b | 50 comments conversations with friends
The summer I turned pretty trilogy

I won’t accept any harsh comment on agggtm either and I don’t understand why it’s hated.. 😭


message 16: by Fiona (new)

Fiona Broward | 99 comments zia b wrote: "conversations with friends
The summer I turned pretty trilogy

I won’t accept any harsh comment on agggtm either and I don’t understand why it’s hated.. 😭"


same with agggtm, i love it so much


message 17: by Malu (new)

Malu Novaes | 1 comments Daisy Jones and the Six and The Midnight library 🥹


message 18: by Aarjavi (new)

Aarjavi | 88 comments Harry Potter
shatter me


message 19: by Aarjavi (new)

Aarjavi | 88 comments Harry Potter
shatter me


message 20: by samantha (new)

samantha aly | 10 comments ♡Vivie♡ (Taylor’s Version) wrote: "A Court of Thorns and Roses and Shatter Me
I love them both sm but I understand they might have flaws"


yessss my two favorites


Lexi ✨(Taylor‘s version)✨ | 85 comments Harry Potter (literally grew up with it and I don’t quite understand the criticism but I understand that people don’t like it)
Shatter me (idk I can see why people don’t like it but I LOVE it)


message 22: by McDoodles (new)

McDoodles | 18 comments Hunger games for sure! Also selection series


message 23: by grace , oh my god, shes insane (new)

grace  (thestateofgraceee) | 1383 comments Lexi ✨(Taylor‘s version)✨ wrote: "Harry Potter (literally grew up with it and I don’t quite understand the criticism but I understand that people don’t like it)
Shatter me (idk I can see why people don’t like it but I LOVE it)"


I get people hate jkr which i understand, but honestly i cant find many faults with the writing and story telling of hp


Bailey(not super active lol)  | 1824 comments Kotlc , hunger games , and maze runner , these three series have helped me so much through so much! I get why people may not prefer them but if you insult them in front of me you will get no body no crimed


mona ♡ (wishbone edition) (mona_tv) Bailey(newts version) wrote: "Kotlc , hunger games , and maze runner , these three series have helped me so much through so much! I get why people may not prefer them but if you insult them in front of me you will get no body n..."

honestly maze runner is an acquired taste ik a lot of people that don't like it


message 26: by Averie (new)

Averie | 5 comments Throne of Glass. I will not accept criticism because they are just simply wrong. It is perfect lol.


message 27: by [deleted user] (new)

twilight (it is cringe but it's so good) idk why so many people hate it but i love it it's basically my fave


message 28: by vi (new)

vi | 54 comments grace (taylors version) not very active atm lmao wrote: "Normal people and the love hypothesis 😭"

you named the two books i would endlessly criticize lol-


back to top