⋆.ೃ࿔࿐ྂfaith & fantasy⋆.ೃ࿔࿐ྂ discussion

On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness (The Wingfeather Saga, #1)
42 views
✯Games✯ > ⭒Elimination Game (Feat. On the Edge of the Dark Sea of Darkness)⭒(Completed)

Comments Showing 1-50 of 220 (220 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5

message 1: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (last edited Feb 21, 2024 05:17PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
(While the Elimination Games do not seem to be as popular as they used to be, I had a request for this one, so I am going to give it another shot.🙃)

How to Play

For each comment you make, you may take away two points from a character you dislike (or at least do not want to win) and give the two points to a character you do like.

You may not make two comments in a row.

Each time a character reaches zero points, they will be kicked out of the game. At the end, three characters will remain, and based on how many points they have, they will be given first, second, and third-place prizes!

(Note: Due to the ability to copy and paste the list, this game is easier to play on the website.)

(Spoiler Note: Due to the nature of this game, spoilers for this book and the rest of the series are likely. Play at your own risk. :D )

May the Maker be with you!😊


message 2: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Here's the List:

Janner - 20
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 20
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 20
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20


message 3: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (last edited Feb 21, 2024 10:01AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner - 22*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 20
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 18*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20


message 4: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
(Thanks btw!)


message 5: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner - 24*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 20
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 16*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20

(Of course! I love this series and this game.😊 Looks like we have the same idea as to who should win and who should be taken out first!)


message 6: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner - 26*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 20
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 14*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20

(Absolutely! Janner is my favorite, probably because I'm also an oldest so i really relate to him. And yeah, my most hated villains are the betrayer/traitor type. Also I don't know what all happens in which books but we should be careful not to give away spoilers that we know come in later books. lol)


Bella off hiatus | 802 comments Janner - 26
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 22*
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 12*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20


message 8: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (last edited Feb 21, 2024 11:05AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner - 28*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 22
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 10*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20

(I love how much love zouzab is getting 😂)


message 9: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner - 30*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 22
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 8*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20

(I just edited my original post to remind people that this game is a spoiler minefield.)


message 10: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner - 32*
Tink - 20
Leeli - 20
Nia - 20
Podo Helmer - 20
Peet the Sock Man - 22
Oskar N. Reteep - 20
Commander Gnorm - 20
Nugget - 20
Zouzab - 6*
Gnag the nameless - 20
Slarb - 20

(Sweet. Now that they are forewarned. What are your thoughts on gnag once everything is known about him? tbh I feel really bad for him, what happened to him absolutely does not justify what he did but my anger is all directed at Bonifer now)


Isabella | 33 comments Janner-34*
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-20
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18*
Nugget-20
Zouzab-6
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20


message 12: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-34
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-22*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Zouzab-4*
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20

Zouzab is getting what he has coming!😤

I cannot believe my horrible memory! I knew that Bonifer was a bad dude, but I completely forgot Gnag's backstory. (I honestly still forget.🤦🏽‍♀️)


message 13: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-36*
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-22
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Zouzab-2*
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20

Ha ha ha *evil laugh* Zouzab, enjoy going out of existance.

Here Sharon,
(view spoiler)


message 14: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Sharon wrote: "Janner-34
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-22*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Zouzab-4*
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20

Zouzab is getting what he has coming!..."


Did you mean to give Peet the Sockman more points? Because somehow points were done wrong here


message 15: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (last edited Feb 21, 2024 06:08PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Elisabeth wrote: "Sharon wrote: "Janner-34
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-22*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Zouzab-4*
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20

Zouzab is getting what..."


Uh oh, what did I do wrong? It looks ok to me.🤷‍♀️ Yes, I gave Peet points.

Wow! Thank you for that refresher! I remember now.😊


message 16: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Oh I see what happened. Pest should be at 24 now. Isabella accidentally took away his extra 2 points. Someone else had already put him at 22.


message 17: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-36
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-26*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Zouzab-0*
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-20

Got it! Fixed it and gave him 2 more points for his trouble.🤭

Zouzab is outta here!👉🏽


message 18: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Oh yeah!

Janner-38*
Tink-20
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-26
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-18*


message 19: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-38
Tink-22*
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-26
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-16*

Slarb next to go.😊


message 20: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-40*
Tink-22
Leeli-20
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-26
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-14*

I love how we agree on the worse bad guys but than you're being more fair to the other characters, I'm simply giving everything to Janner 😂


message 21: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22*
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-26
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-12*

Janner is extraordinary, especially when viewed over the entire series, but there are so many great characters in this series! It is going to be so hard to get down to just three.🥹


message 22: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-20
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-28*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-10*

Janner, Peet (or arthum since that's why I like him. I'm seeing a pattern here, lol. I seem to like the throne wardens), and I'm not sure who else


message 23: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22*
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-28
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-8*

Peet is actually my favorite character, and my only real complaint about the books is that we don't get enough page time with him.😞


message 24: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-20
Peet the Sock Man-30*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-6*

Yeah i agree, he's not in them much. I think the reason I love both him and Janner so much is the protecter instinct in them


message 25: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (last edited Feb 22, 2024 07:33AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22*
Peet the Sock Man-30
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-4*

Yep! I love that too. I also love their character arcs. Tink's is great too, but Janner and Artham's are dear to my heart.


Isabella | 33 comments Janner-40
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-30
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-16*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-4

Whoops, sorry about taking away Peet's poins earlier! He's actually also a favorite of mine:)


Isabella | 33 comments **Janner 42*


message 28: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (last edited Feb 22, 2024 08:00AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-44*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-30
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-16
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-2*

I just had to give Janner another one. Slarb is basically gone. Honestly his name is one of the worse parts about him 🤣


message 29: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
I sent mine about the same time as your's but i edited it now so it should be accurate. And no problem about Peet. I just was confused. lol


message 30: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-44
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-32*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-16
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20
Slarb-0*


message 31: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-46*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-32
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-14*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20

I feel like once we get rid of the main villians the battle will actually start 😂


message 32: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-46
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-34*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-12*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20

Oh my! I was thinking the same exact thing with my last post!🤭


message 33: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-48*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-34
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-10*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-20


Bella off hiatus | 802 comments Janner-48
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-36*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-10
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18*


message 35: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-50*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-36
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-8*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18


message 36: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-50
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-38*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-6*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18


message 37: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-52*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-38
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-4*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18


message 38: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-52
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-40*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-2*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18

You are right on this game, Elisabeth! As soon as I post, you post right after. :D But I am going to make dinner, so hopefully someone else with go back and forth with you now. (As long as they don't take points from Peet.🤭)


message 39: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-54
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-40
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Commander Gnorm-0* He's done. Not sure how to do the strikethrough
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-18

This isn't fair 😂 I have two people trying to make Peet win and no one to help me save Janner. lol


message 40: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-54
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-42*
Oskar N. Reteep-20
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-16*

Don't worry about Janner! There are three winners in this game--he's sure to be one of them. ;-)

For strikethroughs and other formatting--click the (some html is ok) at the top right of the comment box. There will be a list of options you can look at. Basically, you put the < s > (without spaces) in front of what you want to strike out and < / s > (without spaces) after what you want to strike out.


message 41: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-56*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-42
Oskar N. Reteep-18*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-16


message 42: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Yeah I know their are three winners, there's just also a first, second, and third place winner 🤪


message 43: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner-56
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-44*
Oskar N. Reteep-18
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-14*

Ah, so Janner has to be #1, huh? 🙃


message 44: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner-58*
Tink-22
Leeli-22
Nia-22
Podo Helmer-22
Peet the Sock Man-44
Oskar N. Reteep-16*
Nugget-20
Gnag the Nameless-14

Doesn't have to be, I'm just gonna do my best to get him there. lol I think we both agree that it's janner and peet. and i guess we'll just fight over the other one 😂


message 45: by Lizzy (new) - added it

Lizzy | 402 comments Janner - 58
Tink - 22
Leeli - 24
Nia - 22
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 14
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 14


message 46: by Elisabeth (Bets), ⭒assistant mod⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Elisabeth (Bets) (livingforjesus) | 6875 comments Mod
Janner - 60*
Tink - 22
Leeli - 24
Nia - 22
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 12*
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 14


message 47: by Lizzy (new) - added it

Lizzy | 402 comments Janner - 60
Tink - 24*
Leeli - 24
Nia - 22
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 12
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 12*


message 48: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Janner - 60
Tink - 24
Leeli - 24
Nia - 22
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 14*
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 10*

Poor Oskar!😫 He doesn't deserve to go before Gnag.

But, sadly, I do think he must be next.😞


message 49: by Lizzy (new) - added it

Lizzy | 402 comments Janner - 60
Tink - 24
Leeli - 24
Nia - 26*
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 14
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 8*


message 50: by Sharon, ⭒botm leader⭒ (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sharon Loves to Read | 7288 comments Mod
Lizzy wrote: "Janner - 60
Tink - 24
Leeli - 24
Nia - 26*
Podo - 22
Peet the Sock Man - 44
Oskar N. Reteep - 14
Nugget - 20
Gnag the Nameless - 8*"


Hey Lizzy! Did you mean to give Nia points or Leeli? Leeli had 24, but Nia only had 22. Nia now has 26....


« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top