2-3-4 Challenge Book Discussions #2 discussion

Madison’s friends assert that Kaylee was seeing an older guy and Nikki finds a photo where she can see Bobby Vance took the picture. When she meets with him, he downplays their relationship and instead talks about John’s behavior the night of Nikki’s parents murder. He also states that his deceased father had a different version of what happened at that party. What was your impression of Bobby? Did his statements start to raise doubts about John and that party?

I actually thought Bobby was telling the truth. He said that Kaylee had a crush on him, but he wasn't interested in a high school girl. I also thought the statement about John and the party made sense. Bobby was not on my radar at all.

I believed Bobby. It isn't unusual for young girls to have a crush on older men. I also found his information about the night of Nikki's parents' murder to be another clue.

Bobby was believable and same as Robin ~ not on my radar at all

I also believed Bobby and felt sorry for him. The fact that he didn't have access to a car (which was reinforced a couple of times) made me dismiss him as a suspect.

Bobby had me completely fooled. I bought his story.