Twilight lovers discussion

44 views
Edward or Jacob?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 90 (90 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 I know, I know, probabaly the most-asked question concerning the series, but still! Which one?


message 2: by Molly811 (new)

Molly811 | 21 comments Edward of course!! They are going to get married. And we know that that is true because Jacob got a wedding invitation in the mail. (In the epilogue of Eclipse)


message 3: by Teresa 8-22 (last edited Apr 10, 2008 04:41PM) (new)

Teresa 8-22 I know, but it's so sad! I mean like, Jake loves Bella, and now he's heartbroken! I was so sad when I read that! Poor Jacob! I don't know which one to choose...


message 4: by Alex (new)

Alex i dont know...you see Bella will never get older if she marries Edward....(well if she turns into a vampire) but with Jacob she gets to have kids...i dont know...(again!:)


message 5: by [deleted user] (new)

Bella will probably choose Edward, but Jacob might try to get inbetween them. (again)


message 6: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 But he's trying to save Bella!


message 7: by Alex (new)

Alex i think that jacob might kill himself...and bella will go to edward...thats what i think...or the other way around...ya know like edward killing himself and bella going to jacob.


message 8: by Alex (new)

Alex man this is hard to choose!


message 9: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 i know... either way, someone will feel alone and left out. :(


message 10: by Alex (new)

Alex maybe she wont choose either...THATS A MAYBE


message 11: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 i dont think that bella's the type that, when given the chance to be with one of two really nice guys, would choose neither. just my opinion.


message 12: by Alex (new)

Alex mmm...idk we will just have to wait for the book...i guess


message 13: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 its too far away for me!!!!! i... need... to...read... the... book.... why does it have to be in august?


message 14: by Alex (new)

Alex idk...and the movie im so NOT GOING TO BE PATIENT!!!


message 15: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 i hate waiting. why must we be left in suspense??? just give us the book!!!!!!


message 16: by Alex (new)

Alex shes probably like making some more tuches to it then she just wants to make us wait CURSE U WAITING!!


message 17: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 but i thought she was done with it! and they were finished editing and everything! why would she add things like, 3 months before it comes out??


message 18: by Alex (new)

Alex idk really...its kinda wierd


message 19: by Kail (new)

Kail (whispersoflove) | 1 comments Hey, I just joined this group. I think Bella should stay with Edward. Isn't he just DREAMY?! If only I could be with him... lol ^_^ jk But, really, she should stay with Ed.


message 20: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 he is dreamy, but hes like, a rock. imagine cuddling with a rock!!


message 21: by Alex (new)

Alex yuck bad image in my mind could have lived my WHOLE life without seeing that image in my mind!


Isabella Marie Swan | 5 comments what so you mean that he's like a rock? I mean when he's with bella it doesn't matter right ?


message 23: by Alex (new)

Alex yeah it does...really can u see ur self snuggling up with a HUGE beautifal rock...? tell me that


message 24: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 I guess it really doesn't matter to Bella, because they love each other, no matter how weird they look, or how rock-like they are, or how much their blood sings to them... they still love each other. But if she didn't like the "rockness", she could be with Jake, because he's soft and cuddly (haha. now he sounds like a huge teddy bear)


message 25: by Alex (new)

Alex no...more like a werewolf! but ya i mean jacob...i dont know i think i would like him better...edward is to...wierd


message 26: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 *laughs* we're comparing rocks to teddy bears... haha!!!


message 27: by Alex (new)

Alex *giggle* but which one would you choose?? i mean rock....teddy bear...rock....teddy bear....i dont know about you guys but I would choose the teddy bear...but the thing is what if the teddy bear is like really ugly and hard to play with and the rock is really pretty and shiny and you collect rocks...man i am sounding SO weird...:P


message 28: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 haha. but still.... its so hard to choose... i probabaly would choose the teddy bear, no matter how ugly it was... :P


message 29: by Alex (new)

Alex ya me too!!


message 30: by Allison (new)

Allison (abriea) JACOB!?!?!?!?!?!?! EWWWWWW!!!!


message 31: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 whats so eww????


message 32: by Alex (new)

Alex whats wrong with JACOB!!!


message 33: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 he's so nice and he actually cares about bella's well-being!!! im not saying that edward doesn't, but he left bella when she clearly needed him!! and jake was there to um... COMFORT her!!!!! (unlike edward...)


message 34: by Alex (new)

Alex edward is TO protective


message 35: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 WAY too protective. he sometimes acts like bella's a toy, a very precious toy. and he doesnt like to share.


message 36: by Alex (new)

Alex i know that is ture


message 37: by Alex (new)

Alex and he like gets mad at her all the time and then trys to make it up for bella by kissing her and old gushy bella just cant stand not to be kissed by edward so ya....ugh sorry guys ims like not in my right mind today so im blaming all the wrong people


message 38: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 no, no, we dont mind. but i do agree, edward is like, "i'm sorry bella, so i will kiss you." but he has a good heart, i think. he just doesn't like sharing.


message 39: by Alex (new)

Alex i know!


message 40: by [deleted user] (new)

can you blame hime i mean he always says he's waited so long for her


message 41: by Alex (new)

Alex ya but what if he finds someone better?


message 42: by Teresa 8-22 (new)

Teresa 8-22 he likes her because she smells good... and he's so mean to himself, even though he wants her. he beats himself up because he's "ruining" her life.


message 43: by Alex (new)

Alex haha nicley worded teresa!!


message 44: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments You know what, I don't think Bella should have either of them. She just hurts them both. I mean I get the whole conflicted heart thing, but Jake and Edward aren't good enough for her. If I had to pick betwwen them, I'd want Edward, I love old fashioned people, and "playful repartee." See the song "And So Did I" a choir selection for my choir concert.


message 45: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments That's a cool theory, but you know, you can say sex. No one will come and arrest you and I'm no too young. God, I've had health already and seen the videos, including journey into life *shudders*.


message 46: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments lols, no I don't that happened to me my first time too. God, more sex things. i'm not usually this perverted i've been hanging around my friend who has a myspace WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY too much.


message 47: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments lols, you're sooooo funny. yeah, i don't have a myspace nor do i want one. but thanks for thinking i sound funny! a wise t-shirt once read: you're funny, but looks aren't everything.


message 48: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments i know right, do you like gilmore girls


message 49: by Sammy (new)

Sammy | 17 comments once again, i know right.


message 50: by Alex (new)

Alex yep


« previous 1
back to top