Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer discussion

Who do you think is best for Bella and who would YOU choose?

EDWARDDDDDD!!!!
I'm definitely obsessed with him.

I feel Edward is a better choice. He's so in love with her that he'd accept not being with her if that's what's best... even though it would kill him. He wants to die when she does because he couldn't live a second knowing she doesn't exist anymore.
There is no greater love than that.

But I feel so bad for Jacob. He's such a good guy. I really hope he finds someone else that he will be happy with in Breaking Dawn... and Bella better not get jealous... she's done enough crying and moping around about Jacob in front of Edward... Edward loves her and shouldn't have to see her upset over another guy.

I was kind of annoyed at Bella at the end of Eclipse.
Don't get me wrong I still love Bella, but when Jacob was going off to fight the newborns and she asked him to kiss her, at first it was to save his life... but then she liked it and wanted it and said she was in love with him.

I feel like that's not fair to Edward... she should love him so much that she doesn't have room to be in love with anyone else, you know? I mean, Edward would do ANYthing for her. He's so in love with her that he could never love anyone else!

I agree with Sarah that Edward is the better choice for Bella... if she wants to be a vampire. Clearly their love can't survive if Bella does not become a vampire. But considering how Bella faints at the sight of blood, etc., I think she might be better off with Jacob. He's at least half-human and so she could actually have a sort of normal life with him. Although I don't think she feels the same for Jacob as she does for Edward, and that would eventually hurt her relationship with Jacob in the end.

Personally I think Bella can have Edward--I want Jacob for myself!

Nooo Bella can't have Edward. He's mine!