Twilight Series by Stephenie Meyer discussion

Who would win in a battle royale?

Do you agree with the actors chosen to play Bella, Edward, Jacob, etc.? Or would you have chosen someone different?

Lots of magazines and TV shows are calling Stephenie the next J. K. Rowling. Do you agree?

Or do you think it has something to do with Robert Pattinson (Cedric Diggory/Edward Cullen) being in both movies?

Which authors would YOU recommend to Twilight readers?

At first, I hated them. But now, I really like them. But Kristen's vocie just doesn't quite fit it.

Hmmmm.... well, there's Richelle Mead and Melissa De La Cruz. Even though their veiws on vampires are different, they're still good.

I'm looking into the House of Night series by P.C. Cast. The order goes 1. Marked 2. Betrayed 3. Chosen. I haven't read them yet but I'm about to start, I'll let ya know.

I also read Boys That Bite by Mari Mancusi, it has two follow-ups but I've not read them yet. I believe the second is Stake That! and the third is Girls that Growl. The first book was decent, so now I can't not read the other two. It's some kind of syndrome, I swear.

I just can't see the Edward I envisioned in Pattinson. All I ever see when looking at him is Cedric Diggory. Kristen will probably do a decent job but I'm worried about Edward's role. Hopefully I'm not disappointed.

i luv Kristen, she has that prettiness that you don't really notice untill you look at her more, just like I envisioned Bella.

I actually think she might be the next J.K Rowling. Not only am I a HUGE Twilight series fan but I am like the biggest Harry Potter fan you can find out there. I have all the books and the movies up to date and have seen/read all of them at least twice. I love the Twilight series as much as Harry Potter. Plus the series is getting just as popular as Harry Potter was.

If it was to defend Bella, Edward would totally win. If not, then who knows?

I think the only one I have a problem with is Peter Facinelli as Carlisle, and really I think it's just because he doesn't pull off the blond well enough.

uhh..maybe. but i think meyer's level in writing is still far from rowling. rowling is still the most creative writer i've ever known.

Diggory, and the only reason I say that is because you're putting a wizard against a vampire; Edward may have supernatural powers, but Diggory has magic.

And magic always wins.

No. I love both JK Rowling and Stephenie Meyers, but there is no way that she is the next JK Rowling. I don't believe you can actually compare the two since they are totally differnt types of writers and series. Rowling created a whole new world in her Harry Potter series; Meyer not so much. Please no huge fans take this the wrong way, but Harry Potter will always be better (in my own opinion). Twlight is very popular, but it will never get as big as Harry Potter. The only reason they are comparing it is because Robert Pattinson is in it.

^i agree with Steph. the two series are very different. so i guess it wouldn't be fair compairing them. though twilight made me romantic and all at times, when it comes to style in writing, harry potter is miles ahead.

Like I said in the othero n Kristen isq perfect for Bella, bbut Edward being Pattinson I can't stand. This isn't what I imagined him as and I think if Kristen wasn't in this it would ruin the whole movvie for me. Does anyone think that their gobing to botch the whole movie up by shoving evrything together and skipping the little things? Hopefully they don't do what they did with Eragon and Blood and Chocalate.

Since I don't know many of the actors or actresses, I cant really say I disagree with the decision, sure I imagined them different, but I never imagined them as actual actors and actresses so I can't put them together. One thing I have noticed is that they chose alot of people who need to put wigs (or hair die, I'm not sure) on, and I don't really like that. Could they not find people who would work with the right hair color? THe only thing that really bothers me is Pattinson playing Edward. But who knows maybe he'll surprise me and pull it off.

what are some other books that can compare to the intensity i found in this series? i feel like i am having withdrawls now that im finished w all 3. i also read the first chapter thru the eyes of edward on meeting bella (midnite sun) . i am dying. i need recommends!!!!!!!!!help?

Hi, Marci. Some people haven't read Harry Potter yet so they don't know what happens with Cedric.

Consider it a hypothetical question where both characters are alive in a field together. Who do you think would win if they had to duel? Just use your imagination ;-)

Personally, I vote for Cedric Diggory as the winner.

Kissing Coffins series.

I don't like Kristen Stewart for Bella. I always pictured Alexis Bledel from "Gilmore Girls" as Bella. I think she would've been a better choice. She has this volunerablity that Kristen lacks. It's easier to see why Edward would fall so instantly in love with Alexis's big blue eyes. Kristen is kinda plain looking as a brunette.

I didn't think Robert Pattinson would work as Edward but, after seeing the trailer, I have to admit he's the perfect Edward Cullen :-) It's still so odd seeing him as Edward AND Cedric. He's a versatile actor :-)

I'm actually freinds with Richelle :-) If you love Vampire Academy, you should read her Succubus books ("Succubus Blues" and "Succubus On Top").

Melissa Marr also writes great YA Paranormals.

For Parnormal Romance/Dark Urban Fantasy (ADULT) series try:

Sherrilyn Kenyon/Kinley MacGregor -- Dark-Hunter and Lords of Avalon series (she's also starting a series called Nevermore soon. Sounds cool.)

JR Ward -- Black Dagger Brotherhood series

Kim Harrison -- Rachel Morgan series

Vicki Pettersson -- Signs of the Zodiac series

Charlaine Harris -- Southern Vampire series

MaryJanice Davidson -- Queen Betsy/Undead series

Katie Maxwell/Katie MacAlister -- Goth, Emily and Aisling Grey series

Jennifer Rardin -- Jaz Parks series

Jenna Black -- Morgan Kingsley series

Jocelyn Drake -- Dark Days series

Tate Hallaway -- Garnet Lacey series

Patricia Briggs -- Mercy Thompson series

Rachel Vincent -- Faythe Sanders series

Kelley Armstrong -- Otherworld series

Ilona Andrews -- Kate Daniels series

Jeaniene Frost -- Night Huntress series

D.N. Simmons -- Knights of the Darkness Chronicles

Lara Adrian -- Midnight Breed series

L.A. Banks -- Crimson Moon and Sasha Trudeau series

Carrie Vaughn -- Kitty Norville series

Jim Butcher -- Dresden Files (was a TV series but got cancelled. You can find the first season on DVD though.)

Tanya Huff -- Vicki Nelson series (which is also a show on Lifetime called "Blood Ties")
I also adore Cornelia Funke's Inkworld series ("Inkheart" and "Inkspell"). Inkheart is being made into a movie too starring Brendan Frasier :-D Check it out here: http://www.inkheartmovie.com/

excellent! thanks for all of these!

Okay, well, Bella's character is supposed to be plain! That's the whole point of the series! Edward is in love with Bella, even thought there is nothing that special about her. That's why she keeps questioning why edward chose her. I really think they chose a great person to play bella. Kristen is plain, and there isnt anything special about her. Its perfect. Alexic Bledel, in my opinion, would ruin that whole aspect.

I'm ok with some of the cast but I'm not really sure I like some of the other ones. At first I really didn't like Kristen as Bella but now I'm starting to see the Bella in her. I'm just a little dissapointed with some of the cast because I had pictured some of them different but I guess I'll have to deal with it.

I really don't know who would win. I think it might be a fair match. Sure Cedric has magic and spells but I think your forgetting that Edward can read minds and is really fast. He could just read Cedric's mind, find out what spell he is going to cast and when, and then move away from that spot. I guess if I had to choose I would say that Edward would win. Sure Cedric has Magic but is he super fast and freakishly strong?

Agreed Krista. I mean, what's the use of a sneaky attack when your opponent knows about it? Yeah, nothing!

Plus, Edward's hotter. 'Nuff said :P

You said it Ali and Krista, lols on the "edwards hotter." I wouldn't know but whatever.

Gregory Maguire, duh!
Books by him:
Wicked
Confessions of an Ugly Step-Sister
What-the-Dickens

The Godchild series is pretty cool. It's not about vampires or anything, but it has a Gothic vibe that makes you want to read more.

Cedric could always cast a spell to make sure Edward can't read his mind then cast another spell to freeze Edward in place so he's at Ceddy's mercy. Then Edward's speed and vampy strength wouldn't matter.

That's what I would do ;-)

Or... he could cast a spell that allows him to read Edward's mind as well as two more for super strength and speed. Then he'd simply level the playing field.

In either case, Edward ends up having the disadvantage. That's IF Ceddy's smart enough to think about it and quick enough to cast it.

Remember wizards are quick too. They play Quidditch at speeds normal muggles would find dizzying.

I have to admit, that's one thing that's gotten on my nerves--Bella constantly questioning why Edward chose her because she's so plain. I mean, sheesh! Grow some confidence already! Or, get a makeover LOL I've seen plenty of celebrities who started off plain and ended up looking really gorgeous with the right make-up, haircolor/highlights and clothes. It's not like she'd need a stylist or designer brands. Wal-mart or Walgreens has cheap stuff.

And I honestly think Alexis Bledel would have added to the movie more than Kristen. In my opinion, she's a better actress. Her vulnerablity is much more believable. And it's easier to see why Edward would fall for her understated elegance and feminity. She also seems more frail than Kristen, which would make Pattinson seem even more powerful in his vampire role. Kristen's a little too tomboyish for my tastes.

**NOTE: Wicked is an excellant book (and and even better musical LOL) but some younger fans may not understand all the political and social satire in it.

Still, I adore Gregory Maquire! :-) I suggest renting it from the library first to see if you like it before buying it.

Or borrowing it from a friend

Must agree, Kamikaze Kitty.

And no offense, but Edward being hotter doesn't really help him at winning.

Personally, I don't like Alexis Bedel; I don't think she's that great of an actress. I can't see her as Bella, she just doesn't fit. Kristen, on the other hand, I believe, is perfect for the role.

Awwww but we like him that much more!
Don't you think it's hilarious that they keep enticing the readers to choose between the two books? First they called Stephenie the next J.K. Rowling, then they cast Cedric as Edward!
*Shrug* I don't know, maybe it's just a coincidence.

Good point, Ali. I actually posted another thread here about JK and Stephenie being compared. Honestly, I think it didn't happen until Pattinson was cast as Edward. Him being in both movies is what I think really started the whole comparison.

i read wicked and saw play,loved it. son of a witch i have also

Good point, Brianna! But no one said Ceddy couldn't cast the anti-mind reading spell BEFORE the duel started. After all, he'd be casting a spell on himself, NOT Edward. So it wouldn't be against the rules. He can even bespell himself not to be intimidated or overwhelmed by Edward's presence. I doubt anyone would stop him from spelling himself before a duel.

Then all he has to do is zap Edward with a freeze spell as soon as the fight started. That requires what? One word and a flick of his wand? And that happens at the same time so it would only take a second to do. Wizards are fast too (think Quidditch). Plus, Ceddy can do this all from a distance, which is a big advantage. Edward has to be up close and personal to do any damage to Cedric.

So it IS possible for Cedric to win within the first two minutes. If Edward doesn't know what Ceddy is thinking, Ceddy could cast the spell before Edward reached him. Then Edward's unable to move and Ceddy wins :-)

Now that's if this is a duel where both sides meet and agree to fight. If it's just a regular fight that happens without being planned, Ceddy could still win if he took to the sky quickly on his broom and zapped Edward from there. But that's if he HAS his broom on him. Otherwise, I'm not sure what would happen. Edward would def have more of an advantage then.

I forget, can Edward fly? I'm getting the two series mixed up now in my head LOL

Edward Cullen.

Both girls are great actress's, but Kristen is smaller and a great actress. The only thing that bothers me about her is that she has a deep or "boy" voice.

Who says Cedric even knows how to do that?

True. Then again, who says he doesn't know? Or can't ask? ;-) Depends on how much time he has before the duel.

even if Cedric didn't have a broom he could cast the summoning spell, accio.

I love Alexis Bledel, she's on Gilmore Girls! Which is on right now! Oh, and Alexis Bledel is a better actress, but then again I am a bit biased (misspelled?). Maybe you should consider, Kristen as Bella and then dubbing her vi=oice with a better voice

Edward would win. He can read Cedric's mind, so he would see his every move, and he has UBER speed, so he could quickly move out of the way. Edward ALL the way. :D

I don't know if you can compare Twilight series and Harry Potter...but I think Stephenie Meyer is a better writer, so she could be.

I don't think so. I agree with Steph and Pauline, the two series are very different. You can't really compare them. They are both fantasy stories, but the topics are so different and the authors' styles!