Between the Wars discussion
Group Reads
>
The Priory - General Discussion
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Gabriele
(new)
Mar 25, 2010 01:50PM

reply
|
flag

Before I started, I thought it had a lot of similar elements to ICTC - an ancient Priory/ Castle, an eccentric father, a stepmother, and two sisters who are very close, so it's really interesting to see the completely different way this book is playing out. I agree, Lee - it is darker than I had expected as well, but sill most enjoyable.

I'm reading too. Started a while ago but have had too much on my plate. However I'm ready to really get into it now. So you two have both finished? I had hoped more people would be joining in.
Hey, Jennie, check out Persephone Books - http://www.persephonebooks.co.uk/. We'd love to have you join our discussion!

I'm on page 119 - slowly getting through it
I like it well enough but can't shake off a sense of disappointment. Whipple's writing has a flair for the comic but there's an overriding tweeness, y'know? I thought it was going to be a much more grown up book than this.
I also don't feel much connection with the characters. But then, who would? They're all so beastly!
I like it well enough but can't shake off a sense of disappointment. Whipple's writing has a flair for the comic but there's an overriding tweeness, y'know? I thought it was going to be a much more grown up book than this.
I also don't feel much connection with the characters. But then, who would? They're all so beastly!
I think I have too much going on these days, because I'm already forgetting this book! It didn't stick with me the way ICTC has.
I have to agree. ICTC is pretty much perfect though, so perhaps a comparison it a bit brutal :D
I just finished Good Behaviour by Molly Keane, and found that something of a hard slog. Talk about unsympathetic characters!
I have that on my to-read list. Look forward to your review :)
With so many characters, I feel there's little development. I feel I don't know any of them, and that's not good some 300 pages in. Nor can I picture any of in my head.
I do like this book though. It's particularly human and Whipple doesn't shy away from uncomfortable topics.
I do like this book though. It's particularly human and Whipple doesn't shy away from uncomfortable topics.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Secret History (other topics)The Goldfinch (other topics)
The Perfect Son (other topics)
The Perfect Son (other topics)
Good Behaviour (other topics)