Harry Potter vs Twilight discussion

32 views
Twilight vs Harry Potter > Harry Potter vs Bella Swan (after Transformation)

Comments Showing 1-50 of 81 (81 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1

message 1: by Andy (new)

Andy Harry would win i think.... it would be hard though because Bella is super strong in her new form...



...but Harry wouldn't be able to read her mind... maybe Bella...



message 2: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments But Bella has poor judgement...so Hary would totally win!


message 3: by Andy (new)

Andy I actually think that because bella is newborn and has a totally protected mind, and super speed and strength. so... ya...


message 4: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments But she married a Vampire!!! And she's stubborn. And she doesn't know how to fight. AND she's not a very good character.

I just don't like her much.


message 5: by Andy (new)

Andy Harry doesn't know how to fight either....


message 6: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments He can at least do some spells. And worse come to worse, he knows the imperious curse now...


message 7: by Andy (new)

Andy true


message 8: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) I would say Harry too, for the reasons you said Laurena.


message 9: by Andy (new)

Andy really... again alone.


message 10: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Bella cuz she rocks!


message 11: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments No...Harry.


message 12: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Harry, because even i , a mere human, would be able to beat a pathetic character like Bella.


message 13: by Andy (new)

Andy but once she's a vampire, she'd be really strong (newborn and all) plus she'd go straight for the blood.


message 14: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Not really. Bella wants her eyes to be as far from red as the rest of them. She has uncanny control. She wouldn't go for the blood...but she would be tempted. And in that moment of hesitation, Harry could strike, and win.

And then he would lose to the wrath of Edward. :)


message 15: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy even i, a mere muggle, could beat that prat Eddy in a fight!


message 16: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments He isn't a prat. And a human couldn't beat him. Maybe a witch or wizard, but that is a big if.


message 17: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Edward is a prat, a twit, a git, a prick, a numpty, a tosser. He stinks.


message 18: by Andy (new)

Andy no see, you're mistaking Edward for yourself. You see, you're only calling him that because you're taking out your anger from something. I'm serious, you have no reason to call him that, he's kinda crappy yes, but i don't see you with a worldwide amazingly awesome character that everyone knows about, so seriously.


message 19: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy "no see, you're mistaking Edward for yourself. You see, you're only calling him that because you're taking out your anger from something."

no, i am nothing like that creeper. Yes my anger that this world is so consumed with such a terrible book.

"I'm serious, you have no reason to call him that, he's kinda crappy yes, but i don't see you with a worldwide amazingly awesome character that everyone knows about, so seriously. "

he is very crappy, that is one reason. and no i don't have an over exaggerated, no life character.


message 20: by Andy (new)

Andy no character has a life. He's not overexagerated, and at least he's known, unlike you.


message 21: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Bravo Andy


message 22: by Kimathy (last edited Jun 13, 2010 05:05PM) (new)

Kimathy not a literal life, duh. but a life in the book. he is very exaggerated to me and no I'm not known but who said i wanted to be?

Bravo Kimmy


message 23: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments You are cheering for yourself there....

And I'm again with Andy. Edward has a life. His life just changed when he met up with Bella...that's all. He's frickin amazing.


message 24: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy "You are cheering for yourself there.... "

really? no way, i never noticed.

His life is all about Bella. And he is a frickin' pedo.


message 25: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments i havent read Breaking Dawn yet...


message 26: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Okay. I'll take that into acount Adam.

And Edward's life is about Bella. That's all he lives for now.


message 27: by Andy (new)

Andy It's called love. (creepy stalkerish love, yes, but still)


message 28: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments Love is love. And in this case, it just took over his life. Which is better than the alternative...Bella dead.


message 29: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Laurena wrote: "Love is love. And in this case, it just took over his life. Which is better than the alternative...Bella dead."

what is wrong with a whiny annoying prat being dead?


message 30: by Andy (new)

Andy it would make the story real boring without a main character.

Also, why do people click the reply button when replying to the post right above the one that they are now writing.


message 31: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy Andy wrote: "it would make the story real boring without a main character.

Also, why do people click the reply button when replying to the post right above the one that they are now writing."


i don't know...


message 32: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Kimathy your a prat for calling people prats so often!


message 33: by Andy (new)

Andy haha


message 34: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments How true, how true... :)


message 35: by Kimathy (new)

Kimathy so? what do i care if you think i am a Prat? i like myself, actually i am extremely conceited and LOVE myself, so i don't really care what you say or do or call me. :] but nice try there.


message 36: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) I wouldn't call Bella whiny or annoying, but that's just me.


message 37: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments she sort of is, in my opinion


message 38: by Andy (new)

Andy only in the second one, and i understand that--its love!


message 39: by Becca (new)

Becca (harrypotterfreak13) Yes. Love.


message 40: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Kimathy wrote: "so? what do i care if you think i am a Prat? i like myself, actually i am extremely conceited and LOVE myself, so i don't really care what you say or do or call me. :] but nice try there."

Being that high on yourself isn't good Kimathy you should get that checked out, people might start hating you, oh wait people probably already do.


message 41: by Andy (new)

Andy BURN!!


message 42: by Adam (new)

Adam  (adawg) | 116 comments Andy wrote: "only in the second one, and i understand that--its love!"

no, its obsession, which is bad for a girl her age, and she is EXTEMLY whiny in every book, its just ultra whining in New Moon


message 43: by Andy (new)

Andy its your own opinion on what is whiney, i dont think she is. It's fine. It's obsession--but that's what love is. You don't understand.


message 44: by Andy (last edited Jun 21, 2010 11:57AM) (new)

Andy watch this!!! hahahahhahahaha


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWRyj5...


message 45: by Dodgegirl (last edited Jun 21, 2010 11:58AM) (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments that video is funny haha love randomly finding funny things on youtube!


message 46: by Andy (new)

Andy haha, i know


message 47: by Laurena (new)

Laurena | 309 comments I watched it. It was odd...but I loved the older lady at the end.


message 48: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments Thats what we were freaking out at you in the hallway about lol!!!!


message 49: by Andy (new)

Andy yeah.... hahahaha


message 50: by Dodgegirl (new)

Dodgegirl | 206 comments one hand and you chop chop chop heeeehheeeeheeeeeheeee


« previous 1
back to top