Christopher Paolini (INHERITANCE CYCLE series) discussion
Book 4
>
Thorn
message 1:
by
Brianne
(new)
Jun 30, 2010 07:39PM
What's up with him? You know he has opinions just like shaphira, but... he seems really shallow. You think we'll ever hear him talk?
reply
|
flag
I hope so, i don't believe he wants to be like he is, i think he wants to be free like Shaphira and Eragon.
i feel like he's more evil than murtagh.
but i think its from having Galbatorix' and what's his face dragon in his head, i don't think any dragon would choose to be eivl, it is from influence of an evil source, aka, man, elevls...their riders, or in his case master.
mhm... well wild dragons are sugar cookies either.
Well you know what i mean!!!!! come on!!! would one of the last dragons on earth choose ectinction, because the only female dragon would rather die than fight for the other side!!!!! I mean really???? Dragons aren't stupid!!! don't act like they are!!!!!
true... i feel like CP has given us a lack of view into the eyes of shurikan and thorn to be giving saphira so much personality.
Yes now we agree, and sorry for blowing up it was the only way to get you to agree, and well you see for yourself i'm good at manipulation.
I don't know if i would consider thron as evil...He is only doing what he is supposed to be done on his part by Galby. I think this is something we will learn more off in the 4th book as well. We will be given some insight of how things are for thorn and Murtagh.
Maybey he dosen't know any better, because knowing Galby he would have been told that these people were the evil ones, so maybe his is just fighting for what he thinks is right.
Yeah yeah yeah, i'm a dragon lover, i wish they were real you can all see that can't you.... or am i lying???
Aellie wrote: "Yeah yeah yeah, i'm a dragon lover, i wish they were real you can all see that can't you.... or am i lying???"yes I can see that. It's okay though nothing wrong with it. :)
well... i think he can tell fighting and killing the only other kinds of his species is wrong...
trust me alot of ppeps think ist really weird!!!
Anyway i don't think thorn knows any better and Mutagh or however you spell it is to weak to not do what he is told.
well...if murtagh knows better, thorn knows better.
i guess but like i said Galby is too powerful and they are too weak to resist.
Well its not their fault.... i mean thorns not even a year old yet and he has all this power that he dosent know what to do with it and Galby has like fifty times more than he gave thron and Murtagh
yeah... thorn is unnatural... then again... he's not really a year old. dragon's are conscious the whole time they're in the egg. right? that's why saphira is so developed emotionally and calls eragon "little one"
well yeah but i mean physically, and he is already bigger than Saphira, and also he might not be as mentally developed because he spent all that time in isolation and Saphira got out into the world some and could learn a bit soooo. you know?? and also with thorn not knowing better it could be because Galby is fogging both of thier minds so they are pretty much like the iron man suits and he can control everthing they do you know??
physically doesn't really matter though.
yeah it dose!!!!! he is physically inhanced and thats what makes him so clumsy!!! Duhhh!! did you even pay atention while reading the books!!??!!??
yeah he is!!!! agian did you pay attention!!??!! when he was fight ing Saphira the book actually said he was clumsy!!! look it up thats not the exact words but im telling you!!
Sorry, might be able to check it out from the library in a few days though so ill get it up then.
btw i know i'm right though i've read all the books ten times each soooo......
Aellie wrote: "well ur not arguing anymore"finally
I hope that something big happens to Murtagh and Thorn... I don't know, falling in love or some deep philosophical crap, and that it changes Murtagh's true name. That would release him of his bonds, wouldn't it? Eragon mentioned it to Murtagh, didn't he?
your right, Eragon told him that he could change his true name and that way he could escape from being under galby's control.
I think Nasuada will somehow meet with Murtagh, they will fall in love, it will break Galbatorix's bonds with him, and they will marry Or, if the story will be tragic, Murtagh will kill Nuasuada on his master's orders, he will go so bitter he will break his bonds, and will run away, then commit suicide...
Tragic, huh?
Yeah, Murtagh and Nasuada... I could see it happening. I just hope Murtagh finds away out of Galby's control.
are you saying murtagh likes nasuada?
Murtagh ♥ Nasuada ???NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!
NO PEOPLE!!! I'm saying I could see it HAPPENING, meaning it is PLAUSIBLE, not that I think it WILL!!! I doubt it will, people gosh.
i can see it happening too and i can say it is vaey plausable. but i think murtagh dose like nasuada.
so your saying you think it could happen but you don't think it will
Harpoon wrote: "Murtagh ♥ Nasuada ???NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!"
YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEES! SEE PAGE 683! HE LIKES HER!
