Writing Passionates discussion
Advice
>
How do you make a supernatural element in a novel credible?
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Alan
(new)
Jul 14, 2008 07:10AM

reply
|
flag
hi alan! i am also a fantasy writer, and i know exactly what you mean. the important thing about a fantasy character is that he/she must still be a believable person--with thoughts, feelings, strengths, and weaknesses--even if she/he has supernatural powers. not all conflicts in the story can be solved w/magic, or the reader learns nothing and feels no connection to the main character. therefore, he/she must experience human conflicts as well as supernatural ones. for example, what are his/her relationships w/other characters like? how does he/she react in certain situation? how do other characters treat this character if they find out that he/she has supernatural powers? also, to a certain extent, the character should have some fear about his/her powers. he/she may wonder, "why am i not like everyone else? how far can i go with these powers? what happens if i use these powers too much? should i use them at all?" what's important is that the reader can somehow relate to the character, and feel for the character, even though the reader does not possess powers such as the ones that the character possesses. I hope that helps. :)

Yes you do!! Lol. The sequel is called Gathering Blue and the triquel is called Messenger. Be warned- when you read Gathering Blue, you'll think that it has nothing to do with the Giver, but once you read Messenger you realize what it has to do with The Giver. You will find out what happened to Jonas and Gabe after...
Gah. I hated The Giver... Of course I had to read it for school so maybe that's why i hated it... :P
idk..... i found the characters annoying. i mean, i know that most of them were supposed to be kinda creepy and unfeeling and everything. GAH! i don't remember; i just thought it was weird and sad and i'm not really into these 'evil futuristic society' kinds of books cuz there are just so many of them...

I think you've already been given some of the best advice. i would say have the main character have at least one (probably more) quality that makes him extremely human. Maybe some dumb habit like chewing his fingernails, twisting his hair. It's those inconspicuos (I can't spell..) details that make characters human in my opinion. It's like the evocotive (spelling not working this late... sorry!) details taht give a setting romance and reality, only it's taking the theory to characters.

So, simply put, to answer your question. Create your story world in such a way that makes the power seem real and write in a way that makes Aunt Mary, who never reads this genre, believe it can happen. Roddenberry, used this as a test for elements of Star Trek. Say for example a starship.If Aunt Mary thinks it looks like one, smells like one, sounds like one, It probably is one.
I hope this helps.
G W Pickle

First exaggerate it a lot, that'll show you the things you have to make incredibly human.
Sounds like a very cool story.

I'm an aspiring Dark Fantasy Novelist and I know exactly what you mean, you have to make the character seem realistically "surprised" and just make if feel like they know they hold something special within them. Should they hide it for a while? Maybe finally using the power in public to help someone in need, thus revealing their ability? You have to decide!