The Lying Game discussion

How do you guys think killed Sutton?

I don't know why, but I have a strong suspicion it was Ethan. I hope I'm wrong though.

Wow really ? I don't know who killed her, but I neve suspected Ethan...

I haven't read PLLs, so I don't know if she gives little clues throughout the books or not. But little comments Ethan makes and comments or passages written before he shows up makes me think of him. Anyways... I hope I'm wrong. I do like his character.

I hope so too.

It could possibly be Ethan, but I think more so Mads father. I mean Sutton knew that he abused his kids, he has reason to stop Sutton dating Thayer and wants to keep Sutton quiet about his secret.

It may look like Ethan or Thayer now but I think that there is more to the story then they are letting on.

I think Garret, Laurel, Mr.Vega or Ethan maybe?

Hi!! I'm new here!! Honestly I think that the killer is Ethan because I've also read Sara Shepard's "Pretty Little Liars" series and she adds quite a bit of twist. So the killer in my eyes is the one who'd most would least suspect.... in this case, you might say Ethan. :D Just a thought.

Becky is my primary suspect because Becky appeared a bit emotionally unstable and she could be anywhere doing God knows what while Emma's suspecting all the wrong people.

i really dont no. i hope not ethan though

Mimapdx wrote: "How do you guys think killed Sutton?

I don't know why, but I have a strong suspicion it was Ethan. I hope I'm wrong though."

I hope it wasn't him though, but it would give Sara some ground for the shocking turn of events... it actually just might be him! I never really considered it up until I saw this post.

Sara's making you think it's Becky, when she shows up and all, but I have a feeling there's a much deeper secret waiting to be discovered.

After finishing two truths and I lie, I have a big instinct telling me its Ethan
He was not surprised when Emma revealed himself. I hope I'm wrong though

i didnt think it was ethan but i had a few theories while reading the books but i was wrong

The last person u would suspect is Ethan and he wasn't surprised at all when it was Emma and not sutton. That's my first theory
But since everyone thinks its Ethan would Sara Shepard really make it him...

It could be Ethan... or somebody totally out of the blue

I think chars father

I think chars father

I have a hunch about Ethan as well... But the Twitter twins seems kinda suspicious to me too...

What if it's the birth father of Sutton and Emma, do we even know who that is???

I think it's charlottes father. He's crazy

Wait got Charlotte and Madeline confused Madeline's father

Ooh I love the idea of the birth father!!!! It would be THE perfect twist! Emma might find out about him in the last book...

I dont think it would be Ethan.. Would be a shock but not a BIG shock as the books has led up and somewhat makes up believe that already. I really like the idea of Sutton and Emma's real birth father coming into the scene.

Lol well it was Ethan

I don't know why but I feel like its Thayer... He did disappear and all and at the end of the last book they started secretly dating so maybe they had a really intense break up and killed her... Thoughts??

I'm guessing you haven't finished the series- it's another Thayer