Heroes of Olympus discussion

Who will win? O.O

Annabeth. I like Piper a lot, but Annabeth's just a better fighter. Piper's good too, but Annabeth's also too smart to be charmspoken...and Piper wouldn't use her charmspeaking against Annabeth.

True if we're thinking training, Annabeth does probably have more of a chance as she is the most experienced and as u said smart (combat, street, school, u name it) Piper could if she wanted to, charm speak Annabeth, even if she's super smart (which again is a YES!) charm speak can change that, even the most logical person could get tricked into thinking "U know what, ure right Medea! Cliff jumping would be fun! Let's do it! :D So that could tip up Piper's edge. Without powers annabeth, with powers maybe.... just maybe... Pips

I think it depends on where they are. Y' know, because Piper can collapse tunnels and stuff. Otherwise Annabeth would most likely win.

Jayjay wrote: "I think it depends on where they are. Y' know, because Piper can collapse tunnels and stuff. Otherwise Annabeth would most likely win."

She can.

I thought Hazel could do that hummm... but Piper does have charm speak... but let's say if she got a cold... totally Annabeth cause let's face it, she is the best fighter out of the two

Annabeth. no doubt about it.

Well depending on skills totally Annabeth

well, i mean like if they were to fight with weapons and stuff, then it would most definitely annabeth!

Oh so true then, Annabeth would kick Piper's behind all the way across Mount Olympus xD And Percy and Jason would be standing there open mouthed xD

I think Annabeth would totally win. I mean Piper has just pretty much picked up a sword. Annabeth has had her knife since she was 7. So Annabeth just has WAY more experience. :)

True but we also have Pipers charm speak right?

True but we also have Pipers charm speak right?

*head-desk* how did I forget that?!?!? Guhhhhlunga!!!!!

xD She charms peaked up to forget *snap* xD

Tsk, tsk. I thought Piper was better than to do that.
Piper: -.-

that's little unfair advantage that i would hope piper would refrain from doing that because if she were to charm speak Annabeth to win a fight(which i really don't think she would because she doesn't like controlling peoples minds like Medea did) i would have to go and slap her because that's a total unfair advantage!

I know but *shrug* That's how it works and remember Piper sometimes does it without wanting to. Plus it's also a bit unfair that she would have to fight against Annabeth how's been training for years and she just picked up a weapon a few months ago right? Either way there's an unfair advantage

They are both powerful but I would want Annabeth to win.

Me too :) She's my fav female character, her and Thalia <3 Awesome Besties

Ikr?! I was all, "GASP" when Thalia came back.

Me too :3 I loved her SOOOOOO much!!! I'm so glad she's not a tree :3 <-- This is why you should never ease drop on a PJO conversation xD

Annabeth obviously, she's had more experience as a demigod, plus Piper's a daughter of APhrodite, so she's probably weaker

But piper could just say go get me coffee quick.

Hey being a daughter of Aphrodite doesn't mean anyone's weaker, different, but not weaker. She has her own strengths just as Annabeth does but what her godly parent is doesn't change anything about her. And exactly, Annabeth even commented Pipers charm speak could affect her in the MoA. So..

In a fight it would seem natural for Annabeth to win since her Mom is a goddess of wisdom and battle. Piper might have skills though, and charms peaking can be handy but I think Piper wouldn't use charm speak; she would not to cheat, that seems unfair like something Octavian would do.

Well remember she has accident,y used charm speak multiple times in the series, she might not notice if she gives a slip to Annabeth

annabeth would win.piper has hardly any experience or skill.

Why do people like doing this? they are both cool! Both good guys! We all probably like annabeth more cause we know her better but they are both awesome in their own ways!

HalfBlood wrote: "Why do people like doing this? they are both cool! Both good guys! We all probably like annabeth more cause we know her better but they are both awesome in their own ways!"

Yup.

Yeah both are best in their own way.

exactly

Annabeth is way better than Piper.

Something I think not everyone realizes is Annabeth has her own form of charmspeak. How many times has she talked herself out of danger? For this reason I think it would be pretty fair, but Annabeth would definitely win.

Annabeth would definently win. she has the power of smarts on her side, and is smart enough to resist pipers charm talk.

I think Annabeth would win. She's a better fighter and tho Piper has charmspeak, annabeth would still win. she would come up for a plan of attack, like putting something in her ears so she couldn't hear piper.