The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner (The Twilight Saga, #3.5) The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner discussion


306 views
Is there going to be a movie?

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ I've heard a lot of rumours. anybody know the answer?


Sydney Check IMDb


Sydney I just checked and it dosen't know what it is... I think its safe to say no.


Whitney Hopefully not.


Darcey i hope there is going to be a movie but i dout it


Johns I hope not. Bree was already in Eclipse, don't know why the would have to make a movie about it all over again. It would delay Breaking Dawn pt. 2.


Alex It would be interesting to see how the book is in a movie perspective, don't you think though?


Johns Well, I guess. If it was just the part where Bree's in it, not the Cullens. I'd like it if it would be in just Bree's perspective with Deigo(sp).


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ Sydney, I checked IMDb and got the same answer. but i asked you guys, because sometimes they have the wrong answer....

Alex, Yeah, i agree. I would like to see a movie based on her 'short-second life'.

Raine, Yeah, i don't want them to make the whole movie all over again. that'd be boring. Just her part.


message 10: by Dawn (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dawn Husted Alexia -Team Malec :) wrote: "I've heard a lot of rumours. anybody know the answer?"

I haven't heard anything, I don't think so...


♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought there was going to be a movie. apparently not...


message 12: by Elizabeth (last edited Jul 28, 2012 03:18PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Elizabeth i dont think it would be that long or is a good idea


Nadine Maritz Did you guys read this > I dunno i was a bit thrown with the fact that she interluded her story with that of a well known fairy-tale


message 14: by kait (new) - rated it 4 stars

kait well....no..probably not because this was "technnically" IN ECLIPSE! They flashed to these scenes all the time. This thing was actually written FOR the movie because they needed something to flash to. It's all on Stephanie's website.


AlbertaJenn ♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ wrote: "Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought there was going to be a movie. apparently not..."

That was actually her copy of the book that Jodelle burned, back before the book was released. SM gave her a copy so she could get a better perspective on the character when she was filming Eclipse.


Sammi I don't think theres enough to make a whole movie.
But maybe a movie 'short' of her perspective on the Special Edition of the movie when it comes out would be a good addition. XD
Though I doubt it would happen.


message 17: by kait (new) - rated it 4 stars

kait AlbertaJenn wrote: "♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ wrote: "Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought there was going to b..."

Yep


Rosalie I dont think there should be a movie based on this short story. I would rather SM finish Midnight Sun or write a book based on Renesmee!


Georgia THERE BETTER BE!


message 20: by Cat (new) - rated it 4 stars

Cat I HOPE THERE IS!!!


Goshgirl Its not likely that there will be. The books to short and they would kind of have to re-shoot the ending of Eclipse... It would be a bit of a waste


message 22: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken I would like them to make a movie out of this story. They can do things to make a movie longer without changing it if they try.


message 23: by Essz (new) - rated it 3 stars

Essz I dont think so.. thats why they focused so much on Bree in Eclipse... To prevent them from doing a 5th. movie, and also the movie wouldnt last that long.. i dont think it would anyway..


Gabby AlbertaJenn wrote: "♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ wrote: "Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought there was going to b..."

Oh, haha. That confused me, too! :P


Meredith This book tied in with the 3rd movie. There was bits and pieces of it in the movie.


Sharon I had heard that there were going to be some 'mini movies' based on the characters and how they came to be vamps.........will be interesting to see the nature of these. I guess, if the hype is maintained, anyone will pay to see anything.


message 27: by [deleted user] (last edited Sep 07, 2012 05:38AM) (new)

I hope so the second short life of Bree Tanner is my favorite book in the whole twilight saga. Yes i know its not exactly part of the saga but it's a little book t the character and I loved it!!! :)


Charbel Oh God I hope not


Sharon Anita wrote: "I hope so the second short life of Bree Tanner is my favorite book in the whole twilight saga. Yes i know its not exactly part of the saga but it's a little book t the character and I loved it!!! :)"

I agree Anita, it was a worthwhile read and interesting to understand the 'hows' of those that survived the transition vs. those that didn't. And Bree was a very interesting character.


message 30: by [deleted user] (new)

Sharon wrote: "Anita wrote: "I hope so the second short life of Bree Tanner is my favorite book in the whole twilight saga. Yes i know its not exactly part of the saga but it's a little book t the character and I..."
Exactly I liked reading about those that survived and those that didn't. I also liked how short it was and quick and as you mentioned before Bree was an interesting character.


message 31: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Anita wrote: "Sharon wrote: "Anita wrote: "I hope so the second short life of Bree Tanner is my favorite book in the whole twilight saga. Yes i know its not exactly part of the saga but it's a little book t the ..."

ditto


Aleah I really hope they make a movie out of this novella. It is pretty short, but I think it can work into a movie. Plus, there was a lot of shady stuff going on with Riley and Victoria and the Volturi.


message 33: by Paul (new)

Paul Nat If they have to make a film about this novella, it better be a short animated film.
Would be cool to see Riley go berserk anime-style. LOL


message 34: by Love (new) - rated it 3 stars

Love hurtswick I hope nott!


message 35: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Lovehurts wrote: "I hope nott!"


LOL


message 36: by Louise (new)

Louise I hope that there will be a movie based on 'The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner'!! I also would love it if there was a movie/book on Renesmee's future and maybe even in her point of view. !!!!


Claire Riley Louise wrote: "I hope that there will be a movie based on 'The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner'!! I also would love it if there was a movie/book on Renesmee's future and maybe even in her point of view. !!!!"

Totally agree!


AlbertaJenn Gabby wrote: "AlbertaJenn wrote: "♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ wrote: "Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought ..."

Kaitlyn (2 B Read) wrote: "AlbertaJenn wrote: "♥ Alexia -Team Malec ♥ wrote: "Hmmmm, thanks. Because i heard-a long time ago. that the actor for Bree had to burn the script in fear it was ging to get stolen. sooo, i thought ..."

When Midnight Sun was leaked, there was a rumour that it was Robert Pattinson's copy that was leaked. It wasn't, but as a joke, Jodelle promised SM that she would burn her copy after she read it. She even took a picture of the fire and posted it on Twitter.


message 39: by [deleted user] (new)

It was all in Eclipse, like the parts without Bella in it.


Megan Why didn't they make a short movie of it at the end? I thought it was a slow paced book but I thought it would make more sense to put the parts with Diego and Bree Total Ship!!! Anyway, I thought it would explain more about how the Vultori thought of the attack cause Jane was there, I think Alec was but I haven't read the book in months.


Aliza I hope so... cross ur fingers!!!!


Sophie Thomson I'd like it if it was made into a movie, but i don't think its going to.


message 43: by Aponi (new)

Aponi Crice I know us Twilight fans really want there to be a 6 movie, and that we all want to see what happens with Jacob Black and Renesmee Cullen, I am hopeful that there will be a 6 movie I mean we all seen what Alice saw at the end of braking dawn part-2. And I know that I am 7 years late on this post but the very first time I ever watcher twilight was not even a year ago. umm please respond to this if you read it. Some say the world in end fire, some say in ice, What is your Fav quote??? hopefully I will talk to you tater. PEACE OUT!!!!


back to top