More than Just a Rating discussion

In the interests of transparency, goodreads staff has written up the policy they've been following when they've needed to evaluate flagged reviews. Read it here: http://www.goodreads.com/review/guide...

Note that in the Feedback group here on GR there are passionate discussions about these guidelines - members seem to be concerned about censorship etc., for example. Others (like me) like and appreciate the guidelines. If you have concerns, join Feedback please - it's an interesting forum. I only post the link here for reference. It is interesting and worth reading.

Hi Cheryl, thanks for posting the link - have you been following all that over in the feedback group? Wow.

Thanks Cheryl, I'll do my best to promote these guidelines as I am able. (Of course, as an amature at being amature when it comes to review writing, it's all I can do to put two words together that don't argue with eachother.)

Thanks, Cheryl! After reading the guidelines, I can't imagine what all the fuss is about. All sites have the right to set guidelines,these seem very fair and understandable.thanks for the info. :)

I've not been following the discussion in Feedback, just glancing at it once in awhile. Yes, TJ, they seem fair to me.

Well, there's been more bullying between certain authors and certain readers, and so these guidelines have gotten tighter.

Do an export of your "my books" now!

Then, read the first post of this: http://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/1...

Note 1. - do not read further in the thread unless you're a masochist.
Note 2. - know that *shelf* references to authors' behavior are not permitted, either.
Note 3. - understand that GR is talking about both positive and negative reviews and shelves.

As always, talk about the book, not the author, and you'll be fine.

I do have to admit that I'm not 100% sure it's ok to say, as part of a longer review about the book, something about "... this author's books are usually interesting...". Implication of GR's guidelines is that's ok, because it's about books, not author's behavior. But I'm going to be very careful about stuff like that from here out....

Cheryl in CC NV wrote: "...Note 1. - do not read further unless you're a masochist...."

LOL!!!


sigh....