“Literally” Sucker Punched!

Underlying Notes by Eva Pasco

An Enlightening Quiche by Eva Pasco

100 Wild Mushrooms Memoirs of the ‘60s by Eva Pasco

Once Upon A Fabulous Time... by R.M. Gauthier

It’s like “99 Bottles of Beer on the Wall”!

Take one down, throw it away. One less book review today.

The takeaway of Amazon reviews is disheartening for Indie authors who experience sluggish, sporadic, or stagnant book sales. The reward for our slow and tedious uphill climb along this precarious journey is a book review posted by a reader. Therefore, it’s a shock to discover the removal of a review every now and then, especially when that review is based on a verified purchase. Mind you, nothing but the removal of a 5-Star review will do, while a mean-spirited 1-Star, vitriolic slander-fest holds its ground despite an appeal, and subsequent curt dismissal.

First and foremost, it’s an insult to the reader who takes a leap of faith in purchasing a book and graciously takes the time to write an honest review providing feedback.

Last week, my Contemporary, 'An Enlightening Quiche,' had its reviews whittled down to 28—again! So close to 30, yet so far! My Nonfiction Memoir collection, '100 Wild Mushrooms: Memoirs of the ‘60s,' is down to 10.

Each day, I walk the gangplank, on edge, over what I’ll discover that may obstruct my path to the Promised Land of Visibility, purportedly attained after your book gets 50 reviews.

However, the hide of an Indie author is thick to begin with, having pioneered self-publishing on our own terms. Taking away one or more reviews over time can never undermine my integrity as a writer, erode myself self-respect, or devalue the merit badges my books have earned. I also take consolation that many bestselling authors have had few reviews prior to hitting it big.

Sales drive success, not reviews.

Although I’ve yet to strike the mother lode of book sales, like an errant weed poking through concrete, I’m determined to succeed in my own way—one book sale at a time.
5 likes ·   •  7 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on March 29, 2018 02:30 Tags: amazon, blog, eva-pasco, indie-author, removal, reviews
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Pamela (new)

Pamela Allegretto I had my first review removal last week. Although, in this case it was written by a read who had purchased the book off Barnes and Nobel. The review has been on Amazon for over a year. Why now? Ah well, che sara`, sara`! I'm over the anger and moving on. But still...


message 2: by Eva (new)

Eva Pasco Pamela wrote: "I had my first review removal last week. Although, in this case it was written by a read who had purchased the book off Barnes and Nobel. The review has been on Amazon for over a year. Why now? Ah ..."

Exactly--but, still!


message 3: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie What is the purpose of removing a review?!


message 4: by Eva (new)

Eva Pasco Stephanie wrote: "What is the purpose of removing a review?!"

Stephanie,

If it's a verified purchase, I have no idea. I realize they have policy guidelines, but if someone purchases a book in good faith and takes the time to write an honest review, I find it insulting to the reader to remove it.


message 5: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Oh, I agree. I suppose you've asked them why they've removed the review?


message 6: by Eva (new)

Eva Pasco Stephanie wrote: "Oh, I agree. I suppose you've asked them why they've removed the review?"

The first time--yes. You get the generic reply that it violated policy. They will also add that they consider the matter closed.


message 7: by Stephanie (new)

Stephanie Naturally they won't explain how it violated policy. Cute.


back to top