The Oversensitive Cross-Dresser: Shame, Stigma, and Defensiveness
Introduction: An Author's Encounters with Fragile Readers
As an author of femdom novels, I thrive on reader feedback—those raw, honest exchanges that fuel my creativity. Yet, lately, interactions with some male readers who identify as cross-dressers have left me puzzled and frustrated. One reader engaged in a wonderful correspondence with me, teaching me so much about the psychology of shame and cross-dressing. But then he started trying to dictate next steps, asking how we move forward and what I wanted to do. I explained that I was putting the idea in a drawer for now because it might be too niche a market—maybe people wouldn't like it so much. After that, he unsubscribed. I couldn't understand what in my response was so offensive, so I did something I never do: I invited him back. When he returned, he approached with skepticism, telling me that if I'm not a cross-dresser myself or don't like cross-dressing, then perhaps I'll never be able to write it properly, and that if you don't like something, you won't enjoy it or do it justice. I was so excited for him to see my new story, which was praised by others for having the best descriptions ever of cross-dressing, but he kept quiet and stays quiet to this day. Another tried to become a beta reader, but when I provided gentle critique about his work, he was deeply hurt and couldn't take it at all. I didn't understand why he was so deeply hurt—what did I do? It's impossible to work with a person where you have to walk on eggshells, being very careful, because in a minute he can switch, flip, and go away. A third promised to write a review on Amazon, but when I asked why he hadn't published it yet, he responded rudely and in an offended way. Eventually, I let him back in provided he wrote the review he promised, and he did—a beautiful one for one of my books. But after that, when I got excited and offered him to write another review for a different book, he took it as meaning we had a transactional relationship, that I didn't want to be a true friend and just wanted him to review for me. He went ahead and removed his original review from Amazon. Initially, I told myself there might be a correlation between being a cross-dresser and being mean, but then I decided to investigate, digging into academic sources, and understood that we're not talking about inherent meanness. The root causes are shame and stigma, leading to oversensitivity, quick withdrawals, defensiveness, and negativity spilling into unrelated discussions.
The Phenomenon: Oversensitivity and Quick Offense
Oversensitivity manifests as an exaggerated response to perceived slights, often unrelated to the cross-dressing itself. In my case, neutral comments—like explaining a story delay due to market concerns, providing gentle critique on beta reading, or excitedly requesting another review—triggered unsubscribes, deep hurt, rude responses, and review removals ([1]). This isn't unique; psychological sources describe how cross-dressers frequently experience guilt and shame, leading to defensive behaviors as a protective shield ([2]). Social stigma around cross-dressing fosters this fragility, where individuals anticipate judgment even in supportive environments ([3]). For instance, one reader saw my view as invalidating because I don't personally enjoy forcing a man to wear feminine clothes and become a sissy, assuming that without that enjoyment, I couldn't write it authentically, despite my accommodating approach to any kink or trophy. I am a student of my readers, studying them by asking questions, soliciting feedback, and accepting whatever someone tells me as the truth. I respect that deeply—on the contrary, I think people who can connect to their kinks and talk about them are those who enjoy life in general and specifically enjoy sex.
Roots in Shame and Societal Stigma
Shame is the core culprit—internalized negativity from societal stigma that views cross-dressing as "abnormal" ([4]). Cross-dressers often feel anxious, depressed, guilty, and ashamed, especially when hiding their behavior from others, which breeds anxiety and defensiveness ([5]). Even without overt pressure, the cumulative effect of lifelong hiding creates emotional fragility; studies note this leads to isolation and low self-esteem ([6]). Those who cross-dress often fear rejection if they share their secret, feeling guilty and ashamed, which embeds deeply and manifests as oversensitivity later ([7]). Stigma doesn't just cause immediate distress—it "trains" hypervigilance, where individuals anticipate rejection and react preemptively ([8]).
Psychological Insights: Defensiveness and Mental Health Links
Psychologically, transvestic disorder involves recurrent arousal from cross-dressing, often accompanied by shame-induced depression and anxiety ([9]). Dehumanization via subtle discriminations (microaggressions) amplifies this, indirectly worsening mental health through internalized shame ([10]). Cross-dressers may feel anxious, depressed, guilty, and ashamed, leading to withdrawal ([11]). This defensiveness spills over; broader research ties stigma to isolation and poor outcomes, with shame mediating hypersensitivity ([12]). In my experiences, this explains the abrupt unsubscribes and deep hurt—self-protection from perceived judgment, even in empathetic interactions.
ADHD Overlap: Amplifying Emotional Fragility
An interesting correlation exists between ADHD and gender non-conformity, including cross-dressing, with ADHD prevalence 3-6 times higher in transgender or gender-diverse individuals ([13]). This neurodivergence heightens rejection sensitivity and emotional reactivity, compounding shame-driven defensiveness ([14]). Studies suggest ADHD individuals may question gender norms more, but stigma exacerbates mental health struggles like anxiety, leading to amplified oversensitivity ([15]).
Hypervigilance: The Trained Brain and Reading the Room
These individuals' brains are trained to be highly sensitive, constantly reading into what others think as they walk in public with the fear of discovery ([16]). This fear of being "clocked" or exposed hones hypervigilance—a state of heightened alertness to potential threats, often seen in stigmatized groups like LGBTQ+ individuals ([17]). As a result, they become exceptionally good at "reading the room," picking up on subtle cues to avoid judgment ([18]). However, this training leads to a spillover effect: even in normal conversations that have nothing to do with cross-dressing—such as me interacting with a reader and saying their review wasn't so good and needs improvement—this can trigger the sensitivity. People get hurt deeply from what is just normal, empathetic communication ([19]).
Conclusion: Empathy Beyond Oversensitivity
Oversensitivity in cross-dressing readers stems from deep shame and stigma, not malice—a call for understanding ([20]). By exploring this in my novels, I hope to bridge gaps. Read the Grace Series for a glimpse into these hidden struggles; perhaps it's the key to less defensiveness and more open dialogue.
Sources
[1] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[2] Wisdom Within CT. "Cross Dressing Therapists and Counselors Support Acceptance." https://wisdomwithinct.com/cross-dres...
[3] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[4] Counsellors Online. "Why do men cross-dress?" https://www.counsellors-online.co.uk/...
[5] PMC. "Transvestism as a Symptom: A Case Series." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[6] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[7] Wisdom Within CT. "Cross Dressing Therapists." https://wisdomwithinct.com/cross-dres...
[8] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[9] Counsellors Online. "Why do men cross-dress?" https://www.counsellors-online.co.uk/...
[10] PMC. "Transgender Stigma and Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[11] Talk to Angel. "Counselling for managing Cross-dressing Behaviour." https://www.talktoangel.com/blog/coun...
[12] ResearchGate. "LGBTQ individuals' lived experiences of hypervigilance." https://www.researchgate.net/publicat...
[13] PMC. "Sexual Orientation Concealment and Mental Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[14] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[15] PMC. "Transgender Dehumanization and Mental Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[16] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[17] PMC. "Transgender Stigma and Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[18] PMC. "The Transgender and Gender Diverse and Attention Deficit." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[19] Reckon. "Why so many people with ADHD are breaking free from gender norms." https://www.reckon.news/lgbtq/2024/10...
[20] Daniel Dashnaw Couples Therapy. "Gender Expansive Behavior and ADHD." https://danieldashnawcouplestherapy.c...
As an author of femdom novels, I thrive on reader feedback—those raw, honest exchanges that fuel my creativity. Yet, lately, interactions with some male readers who identify as cross-dressers have left me puzzled and frustrated. One reader engaged in a wonderful correspondence with me, teaching me so much about the psychology of shame and cross-dressing. But then he started trying to dictate next steps, asking how we move forward and what I wanted to do. I explained that I was putting the idea in a drawer for now because it might be too niche a market—maybe people wouldn't like it so much. After that, he unsubscribed. I couldn't understand what in my response was so offensive, so I did something I never do: I invited him back. When he returned, he approached with skepticism, telling me that if I'm not a cross-dresser myself or don't like cross-dressing, then perhaps I'll never be able to write it properly, and that if you don't like something, you won't enjoy it or do it justice. I was so excited for him to see my new story, which was praised by others for having the best descriptions ever of cross-dressing, but he kept quiet and stays quiet to this day. Another tried to become a beta reader, but when I provided gentle critique about his work, he was deeply hurt and couldn't take it at all. I didn't understand why he was so deeply hurt—what did I do? It's impossible to work with a person where you have to walk on eggshells, being very careful, because in a minute he can switch, flip, and go away. A third promised to write a review on Amazon, but when I asked why he hadn't published it yet, he responded rudely and in an offended way. Eventually, I let him back in provided he wrote the review he promised, and he did—a beautiful one for one of my books. But after that, when I got excited and offered him to write another review for a different book, he took it as meaning we had a transactional relationship, that I didn't want to be a true friend and just wanted him to review for me. He went ahead and removed his original review from Amazon. Initially, I told myself there might be a correlation between being a cross-dresser and being mean, but then I decided to investigate, digging into academic sources, and understood that we're not talking about inherent meanness. The root causes are shame and stigma, leading to oversensitivity, quick withdrawals, defensiveness, and negativity spilling into unrelated discussions.
The Phenomenon: Oversensitivity and Quick Offense
Oversensitivity manifests as an exaggerated response to perceived slights, often unrelated to the cross-dressing itself. In my case, neutral comments—like explaining a story delay due to market concerns, providing gentle critique on beta reading, or excitedly requesting another review—triggered unsubscribes, deep hurt, rude responses, and review removals ([1]). This isn't unique; psychological sources describe how cross-dressers frequently experience guilt and shame, leading to defensive behaviors as a protective shield ([2]). Social stigma around cross-dressing fosters this fragility, where individuals anticipate judgment even in supportive environments ([3]). For instance, one reader saw my view as invalidating because I don't personally enjoy forcing a man to wear feminine clothes and become a sissy, assuming that without that enjoyment, I couldn't write it authentically, despite my accommodating approach to any kink or trophy. I am a student of my readers, studying them by asking questions, soliciting feedback, and accepting whatever someone tells me as the truth. I respect that deeply—on the contrary, I think people who can connect to their kinks and talk about them are those who enjoy life in general and specifically enjoy sex.
Roots in Shame and Societal Stigma
Shame is the core culprit—internalized negativity from societal stigma that views cross-dressing as "abnormal" ([4]). Cross-dressers often feel anxious, depressed, guilty, and ashamed, especially when hiding their behavior from others, which breeds anxiety and defensiveness ([5]). Even without overt pressure, the cumulative effect of lifelong hiding creates emotional fragility; studies note this leads to isolation and low self-esteem ([6]). Those who cross-dress often fear rejection if they share their secret, feeling guilty and ashamed, which embeds deeply and manifests as oversensitivity later ([7]). Stigma doesn't just cause immediate distress—it "trains" hypervigilance, where individuals anticipate rejection and react preemptively ([8]).
Psychological Insights: Defensiveness and Mental Health Links
Psychologically, transvestic disorder involves recurrent arousal from cross-dressing, often accompanied by shame-induced depression and anxiety ([9]). Dehumanization via subtle discriminations (microaggressions) amplifies this, indirectly worsening mental health through internalized shame ([10]). Cross-dressers may feel anxious, depressed, guilty, and ashamed, leading to withdrawal ([11]). This defensiveness spills over; broader research ties stigma to isolation and poor outcomes, with shame mediating hypersensitivity ([12]). In my experiences, this explains the abrupt unsubscribes and deep hurt—self-protection from perceived judgment, even in empathetic interactions.
ADHD Overlap: Amplifying Emotional Fragility
An interesting correlation exists between ADHD and gender non-conformity, including cross-dressing, with ADHD prevalence 3-6 times higher in transgender or gender-diverse individuals ([13]). This neurodivergence heightens rejection sensitivity and emotional reactivity, compounding shame-driven defensiveness ([14]). Studies suggest ADHD individuals may question gender norms more, but stigma exacerbates mental health struggles like anxiety, leading to amplified oversensitivity ([15]).
Hypervigilance: The Trained Brain and Reading the Room
These individuals' brains are trained to be highly sensitive, constantly reading into what others think as they walk in public with the fear of discovery ([16]). This fear of being "clocked" or exposed hones hypervigilance—a state of heightened alertness to potential threats, often seen in stigmatized groups like LGBTQ+ individuals ([17]). As a result, they become exceptionally good at "reading the room," picking up on subtle cues to avoid judgment ([18]). However, this training leads to a spillover effect: even in normal conversations that have nothing to do with cross-dressing—such as me interacting with a reader and saying their review wasn't so good and needs improvement—this can trigger the sensitivity. People get hurt deeply from what is just normal, empathetic communication ([19]).
Conclusion: Empathy Beyond Oversensitivity
Oversensitivity in cross-dressing readers stems from deep shame and stigma, not malice—a call for understanding ([20]). By exploring this in my novels, I hope to bridge gaps. Read the Grace Series for a glimpse into these hidden struggles; perhaps it's the key to less defensiveness and more open dialogue.
Sources
[1] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[2] Wisdom Within CT. "Cross Dressing Therapists and Counselors Support Acceptance." https://wisdomwithinct.com/cross-dres...
[3] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[4] Counsellors Online. "Why do men cross-dress?" https://www.counsellors-online.co.uk/...
[5] PMC. "Transvestism as a Symptom: A Case Series." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[6] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[7] Wisdom Within CT. "Cross Dressing Therapists." https://wisdomwithinct.com/cross-dres...
[8] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[9] Counsellors Online. "Why do men cross-dress?" https://www.counsellors-online.co.uk/...
[10] PMC. "Transgender Stigma and Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[11] Talk to Angel. "Counselling for managing Cross-dressing Behaviour." https://www.talktoangel.com/blog/coun...
[12] ResearchGate. "LGBTQ individuals' lived experiences of hypervigilance." https://www.researchgate.net/publicat...
[13] PMC. "Sexual Orientation Concealment and Mental Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[14] Psychology Today. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/co...
[15] PMC. "Transgender Dehumanization and Mental Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[16] Merck Manuals. "Transvestic Disorder." https://www.merckmanuals.com/home/men...
[17] PMC. "Transgender Stigma and Health." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[18] PMC. "The Transgender and Gender Diverse and Attention Deficit." https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles...
[19] Reckon. "Why so many people with ADHD are breaking free from gender norms." https://www.reckon.news/lgbtq/2024/10...
[20] Daniel Dashnaw Couples Therapy. "Gender Expansive Behavior and ADHD." https://danieldashnawcouplestherapy.c...
date
newest »
newest »
Receiving gentle critique on my beta reader feedback from an author who is a luminary in the realm of erotic fiction with a Masters in creative writing, who meticulously crafts realistic fantasies with logical structure and nail-biting tension sending the reader into erotic bliss constantly receiving 5-star reviews, I only take as a compliment. I appreciate the valuable time given to me to help improve and be the best beta reader feedback I can be for both the author and myself, whether it be positive or negative critique nobody is perfect and we all need help from one another in life to better ourselves. Gentle critique is given to improve the experience for both, and how the receiver takes it is a reflection of their true personality in my opinion.
I think another root cause, not just crossdressers, but males in general is the male ego which gets hyper sensitive and attacks when it feels slightly hurt, often taking rationale out of the equation. I have seen this consistent so many times in various scenarios. Even as a male I cannot fathom the behaviours at times. I am just grateful I am not like that.