Reading Time: 3 minutesWhy Influencer Relationships Matter

Crafting a book is hard. Promoting it? Even harder. In today’s crowded publishing landscape, book influencers—bloggers, reviewers, and social media creators—can amplify your visibility and help you reach new readers. But there’s a catch: many authors unintentionally damage these relationships before they even begin.

If you want to succeed at pitching book influencers, you need to understand their perspectives, respect their boundaries, and build partnerships based on authenticity—not demands.

1. Influencers Aren’t Employees

Some authors treat influencers as though they’re obligated to deliver a glowing review on command. But influencers are independent voices, not marketing contractors. Telling them how to review your book, asking them to edit their posts, or expecting only five-star content is a surefire way to lose trust. Authenticity is their currency, and they guard it carefully.

2. Don’t Send Unedited Work

Influencers aren’t beta readers. Sending an unfinished or poorly edited book is unprofessional and disrespectful of their time. Before you pitch, make sure your manuscript is polished and ready to be showcased.

3. Never Send Unsolicited Copies

Dropping unsolicited print or digital books into inboxes—or worse, mailing physical copies—without consent is more likely to annoy than impress. And following up with “So, when will you review it?” only compounds the issue. Always ask before sending.

4. Respect Their Schedules

Many influencers plan their reading and content calendars months ahead. They juggle jobs, families, and personal obligations. Expecting them to drop everything for your release date shows a lack of empathy. As one reviewer put it: “We love to read, but we are not machines.”

5. Don’t Take Criticism Personally

Not every review will be glowing. Some influencers may decide not to review your book at all. That doesn’t mean your book is bad—it just wasn’t the right fit for their audience. Reacting with anger or defensiveness can damage your reputation across the community, as bloggers often talk to one another.

6. Your Book Isn’t the Only Book

Influencers are inundated with pitches and ARCs. Acting like your book should be their top priority—or guilt-tripping them if they don’t respond—won’t get you far. Patience and humility go a long way.

7. Do Your Research Before Pitching

Nothing frustrates influencers more than irrelevant pitches. If someone doesn’t review sci-fi, don’t send them your time-traveling alien romance. Take five minutes to read submission guidelines and tailor your outreach. Personalized pitches show you respect their work and readership.

8. Don’t Expect Stars for Kindness

Yes, being polite matters. But kindness alone doesn’t guarantee five-star reviews. Influencers are trusted because they’re honest with their audiences. Expect authenticity—not flattery.

9. Swag Won’t Buy You Credibility

Sending extra gifts, bookmarks, or personal notes in hopes of influencing a review can backfire. Most influencers see through this. Focus on building genuine relationships rather than transactional ones.

10. Always Say Thank You

Perhaps the simplest but most overlooked step: gratitude. Influencers pour hours into reading, reviewing, photographing, and posting about books—usually without pay. A thank-you email, a social media share, or even a comment on their post goes a long way.

Final Thoughts: Relationships, Not Transactions

At its core, successful pitching to book influencers is about respect and partnership. Influencers want to support authors, but they also deserve appreciation and professional courtesy. Treat them as collaborators, not tools, and you’ll stand out in a crowded inbox for all the right reasons.

When you pause before hitting “send” on your next pitch and ask yourself, Am I respecting their time, talent, and boundaries?—you’ll be on your way to building lasting, mutually beneficial relationships that can elevate your author career.

Resources & Free Downloads

Children’s book marketing and tips for summer

Building early reader groups and superfans for longterm success

How to drive more sales if you have a “summer read”

Why brand marketing matters so much more than you realize

Getting more book reviews and why your reaction matters

Check out all the episodes of our book promotion podcast anywhere you listen to podcasts!

Be sure to sign up for our newsletter on the right-hand side of our blog homepage. If you haven’t opened a recent one your registration may have lapsed.

Follow us on Instagram for book marketing tips and some much-needed levity

The post Pitching Book Influencers: What Authors Need to Know appeared first on Author Marketing Experts, Inc. .