Writing A First Draft - Part II

Writing the second novel was a vastly different experience than the first. This time, there were expectations, both internal and external. Publishers and readers were waiting for another novel and I, with a bestseller to claim, expected to have gotten better at the craft of writing. The opposite was true. I felt paralyzed and everything I wrote felt contrived. The more I tried the greater my self-doubt. My agent relayed a conversation she had with a publisher and all I remember is this "Looks like Susan is going to be another one book author." I think my agent thought that could be a motivator, but it wasn't. To the contrary. I threw out two partly written manuscripts I had written and stopped writing for a few months. I did, after all, still have a full time job in medical research and medical writing (all my formal education has been in biological science. But that's another story).

I went back to writing after a while and although I wasn't entirely happy with what I was producing, I just kept at it. This time, the writing didn't feel forced, even though it was bad. The difference is that I gave myself permission to write a terrible first draft, and in my mind, I likened it the art of sculpting. A sculptor starts with a large, amorphous lump of clay in the general shape of the final creation. For me, the mass of written pages was my lump of clay, which I could go back and shape, chisel, and refine later. But I had to produce the "clay" first. And that's what I did. I had about 450 pages of mostly stream of consciousness writing. Through that process, the contours of the characters began to emerge and I got to know them in the subsequent rewriting, where they came more into focus. As always, I fell in love with each of them and sought to know and understand them so they, eventually, could guide in writing their lives.

Of course, I had an editor whom I trust in this process: Martha Hughes. She saw the terrible writing and gave me general impressions, which were immensely helpful. She never judged, was always encouraging and always helpful. Having someone I could trust to read the early bad writing draft was essential. And for me, criticism at that stage doesn't work. I already knew it wasn't yet good and I needed to hear what worked. I needed to hear encouragement because that's how insecure I felt.

I eventually felt good enough about the direction of the novel to leave my full time job to finish writing. It was a big financial risk for a single parent in the US, but it was the only way and I still had some income from the first novel. A year later, I submitted and sold it. The financial risk, although calculated, was real and is still a problem for me, but well worth it. I'm doing something I love, finally. And I think I can keep doing it. It's a privilege to own my time, even though I work long hours. And I don't take that privilege for granted. I'm grateful every day for this unexpected life.
2 likes ·   •  1 comment  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on November 30, 2014 10:10
Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Khulud (last edited Mar 05, 2015 12:48AM) (new)

Khulud Khamis Thank you for sharing this, Susan. The process you're describing resonates with me. With my second novel, Taboos in Arabic, I am currently at that stage of producing clay also... giving myself the permission to write bad. I'm acknowledging the process, and recognizing the fact that writing never becomes easier with practice, but practice - and bad writing - is an essential part of the process. I'm so looking forward to reading your second novel.


back to top