Sheechiibii’s comment > Likes and Comments
8 likes · Like
Agree with you completely. A more intense version of himself is exactly how I'd describe him in ACOMAF. When you think about it, he makes a lot of decisions for OTHERS because of how it affects HIM. He stops sending sentries out--because it's hard for him to deal with it. He doesn't want Feyre to leave the house in ACOMAF--because he can't focus when he's worried about her safety. He sends her away at the end--because he assumes he knows best for her safety. I know he's a High Lord and that requires at times overruling others. But too many times he makes these decisions for his own peace of mind.
If she was his prisoner then why did he allow her to return to her family? She was originally with him as a punishment for killing a fae (its not like he took her for no reason) and then he loved her but still let her go home. She chose to return.
She did not choose to return. Tamlin made her return and wouldn't even give her a reason why. She had no choice in that matter any more than the rest of her stay there.
I think she could have stayed had she truly wanted to. She didn't really try.
"The whole reason she's in his house, trapped, is because of a lie he told in order to threaten her to come with him in the beginning. "
I agree with you on several points but Tamlin had no control over this particular matter. Amarantha casted a spell that prevented Tamlin from speaking a word of the curse. How was he going to tell Feyre that she needed to come with him? What Tamlin did was all for the greater good. His aims were as noble as Rhysand's. The only difference between them is that Tamlin's actions are villainized while Rhysand's were glorified.
back to top
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
WinterRose
(new)
May 12, 2016 08:50AM
Agree with you completely. A more intense version of himself is exactly how I'd describe him in ACOMAF. When you think about it, he makes a lot of decisions for OTHERS because of how it affects HIM. He stops sending sentries out--because it's hard for him to deal with it. He doesn't want Feyre to leave the house in ACOMAF--because he can't focus when he's worried about her safety. He sends her away at the end--because he assumes he knows best for her safety. I know he's a High Lord and that requires at times overruling others. But too many times he makes these decisions for his own peace of mind.
reply
|
flag
If she was his prisoner then why did he allow her to return to her family? She was originally with him as a punishment for killing a fae (its not like he took her for no reason) and then he loved her but still let her go home. She chose to return.
She did not choose to return. Tamlin made her return and wouldn't even give her a reason why. She had no choice in that matter any more than the rest of her stay there.
I think she could have stayed had she truly wanted to. She didn't really try.
"The whole reason she's in his house, trapped, is because of a lie he told in order to threaten her to come with him in the beginning. "I agree with you on several points but Tamlin had no control over this particular matter. Amarantha casted a spell that prevented Tamlin from speaking a word of the curse. How was he going to tell Feyre that she needed to come with him? What Tamlin did was all for the greater good. His aims were as noble as Rhysand's. The only difference between them is that Tamlin's actions are villainized while Rhysand's were glorified.
